There is an unwritten contract between any cafe and the public: purchasing any item - even the tiniest coffee - and you also get the option of staying at the cafe for a period of time. Refusing to leave, or to purchase something, violates that contract.
Because they were being asked to leave on a discriminatory basis.
> Refusing to leave, or to purchase something, violates that contract
Attempting to enforce a contract with racial bias is illegal and, ultimately, unenforceable.
Regardless, Starbucks has explicitly stated they do not have this policy, so your opinion of unwritten coffee house expectation is wrong and immaterial.
Do you understand why they called the police in the two black men loitering, but not on any of the white people in the store who were also loitering?
I'm sure lots of people have been asked to leave at lots of starbucks of all stripes. And then they did, so it didn't get to the trespassing/police part.
These people were asked to leave and stayed 20 minutes after that, until the police showed up, who also repeatedly asked them to leave, before finally removing them.
https://www.reddit.com/r/news/comments/8cysu4/starbucks_will...
We also have a few 911 responses (paramedics, Public Safety), generally involving homeless as well.
This is in suburban Sunnyvale.
Why did Rosa Park not give up her seat? Or Why did Gandhi choose to be thrown out of the train rather move out of first class?
Because they knew that they were being treated unequally.
actual. written. rules.
So even though she paid her fare, the rules at the time were that she had to give up her seat when asked.
So not the best counter-point, unless you agree that, whether or not money has been paid, and written or not, bullshit is bullshit. And getting kicked out of a cafe when there are other peaceful loiterers who were not also kicked out, is bullshit.
edit: gratitude, not appreciation, silly me.
what happened afterwards is what made it a historic act. Before the year-long bus boycotts began, she was just some black lady who got arrested for disobeying the law.
That's what the Starbucks manager did wrong - the men knew they were being asked to leave because they were black men, not because they didn't order. They weren't causing trouble and weren't doing anything different from the white patrons - during the arrest some white patrons were pointing out that didn't order either yet weren't asked to leave.
The argument is not nor has it ever been, "is a patrons only policy wrong?" The argument is "telling patrons they don't have to purchase an item every time they are in your store and then abrogating that agreement only if you're black" is wrong and illegal, and secondarily (not that you even asked) that the cops should not have arrested anyone once they got there; they should have deescalated the situation. The bystanders were right, and the authority figure was wrong; they listened to the wrong people.
As far as what you've read: in this moment they were meeting a friend. Waiting to order your coffee until your friend gets there so you're drinking coffee together is polite, and is kind of the whole point of meeting for coffee. Meeting for "oh I already finished my coffee, now isn't this awkward" isn't a plan I've ever made.
> What am I missing here? What is the correct play for dealing with a non-customer that refuses to leave your store?
State that up front and enforce it without a racial disparity.
Starbucks want people to always come to their stores to meet and hang out because they sell more coffee that way. It's in their interest to not enforce a purchaser only policy.
No, that's not the definition of loitering. They had a purpose to be there. They were waiting for a friend.
Do you have a link for this? My understanding was that one of the men asked for the bathroom code and was told the bathroom was for paying customers only. When he sat down, the manager called the police. I haven't seen any indication that management actually asked them to leave (but I certainly may have missed it).
I can't understand why they refused to leave
They were waiting for the rest of their party to show up.
From being told about it, he was refused the code because "the bathrooms are for customers," then started recording on his phone as he asked a white guy leaving the bathroom whether he'd ordered anything and whether he'd had any problems when he requested the code.
the original videos of the situation (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AdFJAKFvVNs) only goes so far in terms of clarification. it certainly seems like management overstepped at some point, but when?
As usual, rules become guidelines for the privileged.
The cops came, and eventually arrested them after they refused to comply with instructions. They were taken to the police station, but Starbucks did not intend to press charges so they were let go.
What am I missing here? What is the correct play for dealing with a non-customer that refuses to leave your store?