News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by abduhl on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @09:07AM (#16857887)
I see things like this ("These buildings aren't unsafe because there's no choice, they're unsafe because the builders wanted to save money and the building code was too loose to stop them.") posted by people on HN quite often. As someone who has worked in the Bay Area on buildings, I read things like this and laugh. They come from a place of ignorance - anyone who thinks the building code is "too loose" has never successfully engineered something which complied with it.
Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by wpietri on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @09:38AM (#16858133)
A code can be both too strict and too loose but for different aspects. The article makes clear that the building code trusts skyscraper developers much more than makers of smaller structures. E.g., "A five-story building has the same strength requirements as a 50-story building."

The obvious counterproof to your argument is Millennium Tower, a 60-story skyscraper, which has sank at least 16 inches so far. Most of those one 1 side, so the building now tilts at least 15 inches at the top: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-02-01/who-will-...

They are still trying to figure out how to fix it. Doing so could cost well more than it took to built it in the first place. One proposed plan is to anchor it to bedrock on the low side, then let the tower sink further until it's about even before anchoring the other side: https://sf.curbed.com/2018/4/16/17242450/millennium-tower-si...

I honestly think it's reasonable that the building code gives skyscrapers a lot of leeway. Traditional building codes are very prescriptive, and that works better with (common and similar) houses than (rare and varied) skyscrapers. But the ongoing clusterfuck that is Millennium Tower makes it clear we can't just trust developers to get it right. As mabbo says, they have a strong financial incentive to cut corners.

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by abduhl on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @12:48PM (#16860016)
Why would the strength requirement for a 5 story building be different from a 50 story building? Do the building materials behave differently when you increase a number?

The Millennium Tower is not a "counter proof" to my argument, although it has become a bellwether for exactly the kind of posters I call out in my original post. My argument is that people on here who do armchair structural engineer and make comments like "the building code is too lax" are ignorant and full of shit. All the Millenium Tower proves is that, even with a building code, it is still possible to get unintended consequences. To the rest of your post about skyscrapers getting a lot of leeway - they don't get any more leeway than any other structure, they just have the money it takes to invoke portions of the code that allow alternative analysis methods. It just doesn't make sense financially to do some of the complex modeling for a 3 story building to shave 5% of material costs.

If anything, the building code is more stringent on skyscrapers because it does require more advanced analysis. This analysis is NOT precluded for smaller buildings, it is just not worth the money.

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by wpietri on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @01:26PM (#16860382)
> Why would the strength requirement for a 5 story building be different from a 50 story building?

Because if it falls over it won't just kill 5 stories worth of people, but 50 stories plus an unknown number of people in the building it falls on, as well as creating a giant civic problem?

> ignorant and full of shit

Oooohkay, buddy. At best you are playing semantic games here. If your theory is that the building code is just fine when things like the Millennium Tower can happen, then we disagree on what "fine" means.

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by ggcdn on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @03:42PM (#16861633)
> If your theory is that the building code is just fine when things like the Millennium Tower can happen, then we disagree on what "fine" means.

What portion of the building code do you think needs to be updated in response to the Millennium situation? In reality, the building code achieves a success rate far in excess of what engineers deem acceptable. It is unfortunate that the Millennium is a big glaring exception, but the fact remains.

Geotechnical engineering (the cause of the Millennium lean) remains a highly empirical field of engineering with uncertainties that dwarf structural ones. Hence there is a lot of built-in conservatism in design parameters like bearing pressures. But there are limits to the amount of information you can ascertain of what's below you that you cannot see. Looking back in retrospect and saying "well obviously they should have had longer piles" like many people have on the various threads about the tower is a pretty ignorant thing to say, and it shows that they do not have an appreciation of the engineering behind the decision. There a tens of thousands of examples of friction piles that have worked flawlessly. The engineering evidence appears to have supported the decision, but the in-situ soil conditions varied from their design model. This, in my opinion, is not a failure of codes, but an unfortunate, statistically rare outcome.

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by wpietri on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @05:37PM (#16862525)
Engineers may deem this acceptable, but given that San Francisco taxpayers may end up footing the bill, I doubt the rest of us do.

I understand that the people who built it believed that they were doing just fine. But I also understand that there are enormous pressures to keep costs low on a project like this. The notion that for this building those enormous pressures had exactly zero contribution to this outcome is a claim I certainly wouldn't accept without evidence.

If this were really in the range of statistically expected outcomes, then a) there should have been a plan in place to fix it before the structure went up, and b) they would have had sufficient insurance coverage to pay for the fix. Neither is true. The ongoing gosh-golly-who-cooda-node routine plus the simultaneous festival of blame-shifting suggests to me that, at best, the business side of the operation went well beyond what an engineer would have done in the same place.

The correct fix to the building code here I'm happy to leave to the experts, just as long as they eliminate outcomes like this. If that ends up raising the costs for other fancy buildings stuffed with pied-a-terres for the wealthy even to prohibitive levels, I am entirely fine with that. Erring on the side of of earthquake safety while building near major faults in major metropolitan areas seems like a great choice to me.

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by ggcdn on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @06:15PM (#16862782)
> just as long as they eliminate outcomes like this

I guess the point I'm trying to make is that complete elimination isn't possible in a long tail statistical distribution. There will always be a point where we have to draw the line, and there will always be freak occurrences of undesirable outcomes. This is the crux of engineering - finding the correct balance between cost and safety. Perhaps the current state is not enough, but the wildly disproportionate amount of structures that are working just fine tells me we are close.

> If that ends up raising the costs for other fancy buildings stuffed with pied-a-terres for the wealthy even to prohibitive levels, I am entirely fine with that.

Building codes aren't only applied to high end buildings. Any changes affect the (badly needed) low end housing just as much as high end buildings. Just another thing to consider.

> Erring on the side of of earthquake safety while building near major faults in major metropolitan areas seems like a great choice to me.

No disagreement there ;)

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by wpietri on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @12:25AM (#16864597)
The outcome I'm referring to isn't just the sinking building. It's the clusterfuck of a sinking building and years of chaos that could spill over into extensive costs for others. Long-tail outcomes perhaps can't be eliminated, but they can be 100% mitigated through planning and insurance.

Medical care has a much longer tail, for example, but many countries manage to provide full financial coverage and individual support in treating and managing even very rare diseases.

If you're saying this was a reasonably forseeable but unlikely outcome of cost-driven skipping out on the bedrock anchoring that neighboring buildings used, the I don't think it's too much to ask them to have an answer to the question of, "Ok, if your cheap solution doesn't work, what will you do next?" And if they don't have a good answer to that, I also don't think it's too much for them to not be allowed to build the thing.

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by babygoat on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @09:19AM (#16857981)
Your comment would have more gravity if you pointed to specifics instead of touting some vague credentials and telling other people they're wrong.
Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by JackFr on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:00AM (#16858929)
> more gravity

Now that would be a serious problem.

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by phkahler on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @09:15AM (#16857935)
>> anyone who thinks the building code is "too loose" has never successfully engineered something which complied with it.

Perhaps, but have you compared it to the building code in Japan? I personally have qualifications in this area so I'm just asking.

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by phkahler on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @03:01PM (#16870020)
Too late to edit. Why oh why did I omit the word "don't" in front of "have qualifications"? It was meant to be an honest question to fill a gap, not a weird confrontational thing.
Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by kadenshep on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @09:21AM (#16857998)
Shallow dismissals make you look like you have nothing to say. The article posits one thing, then the OP gave a concrete example clarifying why one region is having problems the other doesn't. You then come in and just claim that the building codes aren't actually that loose while jerking yourself off about your experience in the matter, despite the article's position on unsafe buildings and the OP correctly pointing out that a region with similar problems doesn't have an issue with its high rise buildings that they allowed to be built.

Do you have anything else to say besides vague claims on your credentials and experience?

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by bogomipz on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @09:14AM (#16857931)
I don't doubt you but could you elaborate? Thanks.
Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by fancyfacebook on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @09:34AM (#16858097)
The fact of the matter is in a best case scenario, 10% of these buildings are going to collapse in a major earthquake. 10% of the newest, shiniest, up to code buildings. Best case, that's the engineering code, that's the spec. They are designed to collapse 10% of the time.

In reality many more will collapse, because some buildings are older and not up to code, as well as earthquakes generally just being weird and unpredictable.

Do you think 10% of buildings collapsing is a "loose" or "tight" code? 10% losses is acceptable in say, human habitation?

Re:San Francisco’s Seismic Gamble by Retric on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:18AM (#16858509)
That's not how tolerances work.

You don't get exactly 10% failure rate, you have to demonstrate better than 10% failure rate which means going past that point. Further, failure is not 'collapse' failure is anyone in the building being unable to exit safely.

And again, they are aiming for a 9.0 that's a ridiculously large earthquake. An 7.8 similar to the last SF earthquake would still be a major earthquake, but vastly less dangerous by comparison.