News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by RobertRoberts on Sunday April 15, 2018 @02:36AM (#16841551)
Why does this feel a little like fear-mongering?

George Carlin on germs, really funny stuff.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CnmMNdiCz_s

Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by ItsMe000001 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:28AM (#16842091)
You should have read more than the headline before commenting.
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by RobertRoberts on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:19AM (#16842501)
Let me rephrase then:

"Why does this _headline_ feel a little like fear-mongering?"

Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by ItsMe000001 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:29AM (#16842539)
Unless you have an (irrational exclusive) association of "virus = bad/fear/disease" to begin with the headline is perfectly fine. It's just your interpretation made by adding your own context. You should try to separate what is actually there from what you yourself add. It's a statement of fact that sounds interesting and that's all, and unlike what the other person said it's not very "click baity", it actually is a pretty accurate description of the main point.
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by RobertRoberts on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:41AM (#16843116)
No virus that I have ever had, or heard of anyone having, was ever called "good".

I'm literally stunned this isn't common sense.

To prove me wrong, please show me any everyday circumstance an average person from the past 50 years would have had a good experience with a virus.

Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by ItsMe000001 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @01:47PM (#16843834)
You should read the article and take a course in biology. Coursera and even more so edX.org offer excellent free courses.

To you last sentence: The fact that you exist. Viruses contributed significantly. If you had read the article(!) you would already have been told about that, including examples.

For example, quoting the article:

> Researchers recently identified an ancient virus that inserted its DNA into the genomes of four-limbed animals that were human ancestors. That snippet of genetic code, called ARC, is part of the nervous system of modern humans and plays a role in human consciousness — nerve communication, memory formation and higher-order thinking. Between 40 percent and 80 percent of the human genome may be linked to ancient viral invasions.

It bothers me that there are people on HN that keep commenting while completely disregarding the article that is being discussed.

Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by RobertRoberts on Sunday April 15, 2018 @02:35PM (#16844119)
>You should read the article and take a course in biology.

You have proved my point for me. The everyday person has never once in their life, ever, heard that viruses are good.

I'm an educated and well read, and I have only recently started hearing this, and only because of genetic manipulation. This is a _new_ idea in the last 20 years, and even today, it appears to be all talk about something in the future, and not a single instance I've ever heard of where you could get a virus treatment that was good for you today.

I read the article, I am talking about average people, not scientists who read journals.

It's shocking to me that people have such short memory. Maybe you are a teenager, but there was no virus manipulation 50 years ago that was considered a benefit to humans. And if there was, it certainly wasn't advertised to the masses.

Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by ItsMe000001 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @03:20PM (#16844376)
> The everyday person has never once in their life, ever, heard that viruses are good.

Uhm... I'm shocked to find someone who seems to think that viruses have an effect only when people "believe" in them/have heard about them. Sorry, that's not how anything works. It is of exactly zero importance whether or not anyone has "heard" about viruses. I'm shocked to read stuff like that in this forum.

We were talking about the headline, and I repeat, it's a faithful representation of the main point, pretty much 1:1. From my perspective, I felt well informed when clicking on the article - for once I actually knew what it would be about before I clicked. That is a good thing.

Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by RobertRoberts on Sunday April 15, 2018 @03:37PM (#16844467)
The title of the article is this:

>Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day

I learned in 4th grade science that viruses are parasites. Having trillions of parasites falling from the sky every day is not a good thing.

Some mental gymnastics are required to conclude "parasites are good", but I suggest that the vast majority of people don't believe parasites are good.

Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by ItsMe000001 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @04:46PM (#16844855)
Full circle. I point to my previous comments. You keep repeating your weird claims as if that makes them seem any less weird. The title is well-chosen. If you had a horrible education that is besides the point, it has nothing to do with that article. Sorry for your bad experiences in school, can't help you there I'm afraid, I don't understand why you bring it up.
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by RobertRoberts on Monday April 16, 2018 @01:56AM (#16846936)
My first comment was about the title being "fear-mongering". If you don't think saying "parasites are falling from the sky" is not fear mongering because you are more educated than others, then maybe you simply can't understand the common man's dilemma.
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by chiefalchemist on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:44AM (#16842593)
Perhaps not fear mongering, bu it's closer to click bait. You'd expect an outfit like the NYT not to stoop to such intentions and tactics.
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by andai on Sunday April 15, 2018 @02:44AM (#16841567)
Really? I thought it was more like awesome-mongering.
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by RobertRoberts on Sunday April 15, 2018 @04:55AM (#16841896)
What is awesome about viruses raining down from they sky?
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by doyoulikeworms on Sunday April 15, 2018 @05:44AM (#16842004)
I don’t mean to be pedantic, but

> awesome: causing or inducing awe; inspiring an overwhelming feeling of reverence, admiration, or fear

Trillions of viruses falling from the sky is up there in awesomeness to me!

Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by kortex on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:39AM (#16842818)
A four-billion(ish) year old global signal transmission network! Think of the bandwidth in the DNA of trillions of viruses per square meter!

And possibly a galactic network, if panspermia is a thing. What's the probability of life emerging ab initio on an organic planet, vs collisions spreading seed molecules from a source planet to those nearby?

https://www.universetoday.com/137954/galactic-panspermia-int...

Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by aquadrop on Sunday April 15, 2018 @05:18AM (#16841943)
The fact that it's happening and we're still alive.
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by RobertRoberts on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:20AM (#16842504)
Doesn't this strongly imply that we are actually quite immune to virus naturally, and only that a depressed immune system is what allows viruses to wreak havoc?
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by sfink on Sunday April 15, 2018 @04:44PM (#16844845)
You seem to think of viruses as all the same? The headline (and text before the paywall) does not say or imply that these are human-infectious viruses. They're just viruses. As in, a basic form of life, basic enough that it's highly questionable whether it makes sense to call them living. They're everywhere. As are bacteria, and bugs (rapidly descending in orders of magnitude in that "everywhere"!) But it's certainly news to me that trillions are falling from the sky; I would have guessed that uv radiation would disrupt ("kill"?) them.
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by RobertRoberts on Monday April 16, 2018 @08:08AM (#16848352)
>As in, a basic form of life,...

From the article:

>Do viruses even fit the definition of something alive?

You said:

>"...does not say or imply that these are human-infectious viruses."

Article said:

>"Viruses and their prey..."

I think it's safe to assume this article's intent is to share information that is not obviously known to everyone, that's it's supposed to be "news" (ie, it's from the New York Times). So let's not pretend that this article is a rehash of common knowledge about the value/state of viruses.

Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by amelius on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:29AM (#16842095)
This may change when the viruses are made to deliver engineered payloads.
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by RobertRoberts on Sunday April 15, 2018 @03:33PM (#16844446)
What happens if there's a bug in the gene code/splicing, and a self-replicating virus causes a worse problem that it was intended to solve? (this happens all the time in pharmaceuticals already) Or because a virus was manipulated, it can then mutates in a way that in it's natural state, would never mutate? (another unforeseeable result)
Re:Trillions of Viruses Fall from the Sky Each Day by ncmncm on Monday April 16, 2018 @08:04PM (#16854171)
Viruses always mutate, and they are far more clever about it than any puny human. But fewer than one in a billion viral species has the slightest interest in infecting you.