Re:How good software makes us stupid
by jdietrich on Sunday September 12, 2010 @01:55PM
(#1684154)
I am bloody sick of that troll Nicholas Carr.
Exactly the same things were said of printing - conservatives said that we would lose the ability to remember things when all knowledge could be looked up in a book.
Exactly the same things were said of slide rules and calculators - that we would lose the ability to reason as our ability to calculate atrophied.
The obvious debunking of Carr's argument is the incredible level of skill so many computer users exhibit. Obviously we HNers are all aware of how bloody difficult programming is, but we forget just how complex a lot of very ordinary software is. Watch a skilled Photoshop operator or a really good Starcraft player in action and you'll see Carr's hypothesis go down in flames. Something as mundane as Excel is easily more complex than any system in the world just a few decades ago.
Carr is at the bottom of a very long line of dreary, reactionary trolls, cursing that the young people today don't know how easy they've got it, that they're going soft with their newfangled tools.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by earnubs on Sunday September 12, 2010 @02:47PM
(#1684279)
"Watch a skilled Photoshop operator …"
I've worked with a couple of people who are pretty handy with Vim, process control, Screen, etc. Watching them in their workflow, the hand movements, is mesmerising in the same way a dance can be. Purely anecdotal but they also have IQs that would be around the genius level.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by cturner on Sunday September 12, 2010 @03:15PM
(#1684328)
I consider mastery of a discipline and genius to be distinct. I'm fluid like that in screen and vim, and not particularly smart. Musicians get it - it can be awesome watching a conductor juggling a weak choir in rehearsal with batton and piano.
People who have it probably have more mental energy to devote to other things - which would be a huge advantage - but that's not the sane as 'unprecedented insight'.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by integraleq on Sunday September 12, 2010 @03:18PM
(#1684337)
I would also agree with that sentiment. What you do on a consistent basis more than likely becomes "short-circuited" into your mental perception of the world that you navigate from day to day. Much like not using a programming language that you knew well for six months can, I believe, cause some kind of "mental atrophy" in that particular skill set.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by sabat on Sunday September 12, 2010 @02:05PM
(#1684187)
I am bloody sick of that troll Nicholas Carr.
Couldn't have put it better myself. He really thinks he's good at being reductive.
cursing that the young people today don't know how easy they've got it
Every generation is sure that these young kids today, with their hair and their clothes, just don't appreciate how hard things used to be. Every generation is wrong about that, of course.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by edanm on Sunday September 12, 2010 @02:26PM
(#1684240)
"Every generation is sure that these young kids today, with their hair and their clothes, just don't appreciate how hard things used to be. Every generation is wrong about that, of course."
Funny anecdote: for years, my father kept telling me that "when he was a kid, we called our father sir". Made sense, until one day I read a book in which the character's father complained of the exact same thing, but the book was written in 1900.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by Qz on Sunday September 12, 2010 @04:14PM
(#1684443)
Every generation is wrong about that, of course.
Actually, they're right -- it's just that in the grand scheme of things, how much easier we have it today than the last generation, is insignificant compared to how hard life is in general. We do have it better, but it doesn't make us dumber because the world still needs smart people to keep it going.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by sabat on Sunday September 12, 2010 @09:49PM
(#1685182)
Meh. I'm old enough to have been aware of what things were difficult for the previous generation and how they're easier now. And: there are new things that we have to deal with that the previous generation could never have conceived. In my experience, life never gets easier; it just changes.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by lotusleaf1987 on Sunday September 12, 2010 @05:26PM
(#1684591)
Upvote. Carr doesn't know what transactional memory is obviously. Most people don't know how to do a lot of things, but with Google they know how to figure it out in 2-3 minutes. I remember Sherlock Holmes in I think 'A Study in Scarlet' tells Watson he tries to forget information that he doesn't have a use for so it doesn't clutter up his mind. I think that's pretty much how most people are now, why bother memorizing something if they know how to figure it out when it is needed.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by rflrob on Sunday September 12, 2010 @02:39PM
(#1684264)
"It is a profoundly erroneous truism, repeated by all copy-books and by eminent people when they are making speeches, that we should cultivate the habit of thinking of what we are doing. The precise opposite is the case. Civilization advances by extending the number of important operations which we can perform without thinking about them. Operations of thought are like cavalry charges in a battle--they are strictly limited in number, they require fresh horses, and must only be made at decisive moments. "
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by metamemetics on Sunday September 12, 2010 @01:50PM
(#1684139)
>"Months later - the people who had the unhelpful software actually could remember how to do the puzzle, and the people with the helpful software couldn't."
In the real world people with helpful software can take advantage of their time saved by tackling even harder classes of problems that people with unhelpful software never even had the time to get to.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by alexandros on Sunday September 12, 2010 @01:49PM
(#1684133)
Socrates was grumbling that writing things down was impairing our ability to learn things by heart.
As far as I am concerned, the more rote memorization that things machines can take off my brain's to-do list, the more time+space I can devote to higher-level thinking.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by Chris_Newton on Sunday September 12, 2010 @04:43PM
(#1684502)
> As far as I am concerned, the more rote memorization that things machines can take off my brain's to-do list, the more time+space I can devote to higher-level thinking.
I agree up to a point, but someone who understands lots of grammar but has no vocabulary is just as poor a communicator as someone with lots of vocabulary but no grammar, or perhaps even worse. I am concerned that modern trends in education could create a generation with lots of ideas but no practical experience or background information to put anything in context. They can't look everything up every time, and they are going to need a certain level of knowledge to appreciate the significance of the ideas they are learning.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by integraleq on Sunday September 12, 2010 @03:21PM
(#1684343)
I would agree with you, but I think there is something to be said for the kind of mental dexterity it takes to do higher-level thinking while having a detailed view of what you are trying to accomplish. I would not want to give up all lower level cognition though. To each his own I guess.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by okaramian on Sunday September 12, 2010 @04:36PM
(#1684487)
I think understanding the concept of the lower level stuff without having to have rote memorization is important.
As an example, high school kids learn calculus via rote memorization (at least this is how we learned it). We learned what the derivative of x^2 was, etc. but not necessarily what the derivative is. The majority of testing doesn't really focus on the concept, and it should.
As I got into college I understood the concepts behind mathematical thought and everything started making sense. So I guess I'm in the "less rote memorization" camp.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by schwanksta on Sunday September 12, 2010 @01:54PM
(#1684147)
All of these dire predictions of better technology dumbing us down are getting tiresome.
People who are lazy, and wouldn't bother memorizing a route anyway, will be helped by something like SatNav or Google Maps -- and yes, probably use them as a crutch. But it's better than them not being able to get anywhere. Me? Having instant access to a birds-eye view of every road in my city (Los Angeles) has given me the tools I need to memorize many routes, and is one of the reasons I can drive around this city so effectively.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by daychilde on Sunday September 12, 2010 @01:53PM
(#1684146)
But they've missed the true comparison.
The question isn't: "Would a London cabby using satnav software without having learned the city do better than a London cabby who learned the city?"
The question is: "Would a London cabby using satnav software do better than one without - both having learned the city?"
In other words: Assuming good satnav software that knew current traffic conditions and historic average speeds of the roads, with an easy interface to offer multiple routing options that are easily changeable (for instance) - wouldn't that be helpful to a cabby vs. a cabby that didn't have that extra tool?
I don't think it's fair to compare human+tech vs. human-only performance with no tech. Better to compare them with tech, since the whole point is that technology is available and used.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by metamemetics on Sunday September 12, 2010 @01:58PM
(#1684161)
We're already there. Man has always existed in that symbiosis since he's been man. Man is defined by his exceptional tool use, so I will claim man has never not existed in symbiosis with machine and been just "man".
A ship that can carry a settler across the ocean is a prosthetic foot that extends his powers of travel. Eye-glasses are prosthetic eyes that extend your power of vision.
With the internet we are basically building improved books with better lookup features, they both are still prosthetic memory storage communicating information visually.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by cageface on Sunday September 12, 2010 @02:11PM
(#1684205)
True, but I think we're crossing one of those historical barriers where a quantitative difference becomes so large that it becomes a qualitative difference. The kind of symbiosis you achieve with devices that connect you instantly to every other person on the planet and to which you can offload all kinds of calculation and information gathering is truly new.
I'm not a triumphalist about it either. Technology gives but also takes.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by metamemetics on Sunday September 12, 2010 @03:02PM
(#1684309)
Well "instantly" here probably means a response time of ~ 100-3000ms depending on the amount of processing being offloaded for an internet service.
I agree it's new to be measuring this in milliseconds and discussing fiber optics rather than hours and the transatlantic-cable (or days and the pony express).
If we're in the long view and talking about evolution, I disagree that the underlying process driving this has changed.
I guess it's just a discussion of the merits between looking at the position of a car vs. one of its derivatives such as acceleration. You need to know all of them to predict its future position and there are possibly an infinite number of derivatives.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by adnam on Sunday September 12, 2010 @02:20PM
(#1684225)
The Knowledge is a very hard test. It can take 3 years to pass, and you need to learn 320 set routes within 6 miles of Charing Cross. My aunt did The Knowledge anf now drives a black cab by day, and a rather expensive Mercedes sports car the rest of the time.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by cturner on Sunday September 12, 2010 @03:30PM
(#1684363)
Despite the trade protection their firm gets, the money is low, particularly considering outlay, hours and conditions. Yet the quality of the experience is consistently good in a city where service is often poor.
I'm interested to know what causes this: whether it's due to the discipline (the thrill of navigating a puzzle, like a unix operator gets), or the institution (feeling like you're part of something important).
I had a freaky conversation with a driver last winter about messaging systems. He knew all the right questions after I told him what I did, and made comments about the particular technologies. It came out that we were working on the opposite ends of a big integration between firms. He was unhappy with that life and very comfortable at the prospect of spending the rest of his days driving a cab around.
Re:How good software makes us stupid
by scott_s on Sunday September 12, 2010 @04:00PM
(#1684421)
Give me studies, not arguments. Using tools - and "good software" are just tools - that free us from having to use intelligence for a task allows us to direct that intelligence to other tasks.
Yes, I'm not as good at arithmetic as a technical person from 50 or even 30 years ago. But I'm freed from having to do all of that myself so I can focus energy to what I actually care about.
Exactly the same things were said of printing - conservatives said that we would lose the ability to remember things when all knowledge could be looked up in a book.
Exactly the same things were said of slide rules and calculators - that we would lose the ability to reason as our ability to calculate atrophied.
The obvious debunking of Carr's argument is the incredible level of skill so many computer users exhibit. Obviously we HNers are all aware of how bloody difficult programming is, but we forget just how complex a lot of very ordinary software is. Watch a skilled Photoshop operator or a really good Starcraft player in action and you'll see Carr's hypothesis go down in flames. Something as mundane as Excel is easily more complex than any system in the world just a few decades ago.
Carr is at the bottom of a very long line of dreary, reactionary trolls, cursing that the young people today don't know how easy they've got it, that they're going soft with their newfangled tools.
I've worked with a couple of people who are pretty handy with Vim, process control, Screen, etc. Watching them in their workflow, the hand movements, is mesmerising in the same way a dance can be. Purely anecdotal but they also have IQs that would be around the genius level.
People who have it probably have more mental energy to devote to other things - which would be a huge advantage - but that's not the sane as 'unprecedented insight'.
Couldn't have put it better myself. He really thinks he's good at being reductive.
cursing that the young people today don't know how easy they've got it
Every generation is sure that these young kids today, with their hair and their clothes, just don't appreciate how hard things used to be. Every generation is wrong about that, of course.
Funny anecdote: for years, my father kept telling me that "when he was a kid, we called our father sir". Made sense, until one day I read a book in which the character's father complained of the exact same thing, but the book was written in 1900.
Actually, they're right -- it's just that in the grand scheme of things, how much easier we have it today than the last generation, is insignificant compared to how hard life is in general. We do have it better, but it doesn't make us dumber because the world still needs smart people to keep it going.
Since you've proved it with your powers of induction. Not saying that you are wrong about the next generation, but you might be.
Alfred North Whitehead, http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Alfred_North_Whitehead
In the real world people with helpful software can take advantage of their time saved by tackling even harder classes of problems that people with unhelpful software never even had the time to get to.
As far as I am concerned, the more rote memorization that things machines can take off my brain's to-do list, the more time+space I can devote to higher-level thinking.
I agree up to a point, but someone who understands lots of grammar but has no vocabulary is just as poor a communicator as someone with lots of vocabulary but no grammar, or perhaps even worse. I am concerned that modern trends in education could create a generation with lots of ideas but no practical experience or background information to put anything in context. They can't look everything up every time, and they are going to need a certain level of knowledge to appreciate the significance of the ideas they are learning.
As an example, high school kids learn calculus via rote memorization (at least this is how we learned it). We learned what the derivative of x^2 was, etc. but not necessarily what the derivative is. The majority of testing doesn't really focus on the concept, and it should.
As I got into college I understood the concepts behind mathematical thought and everything started making sense. So I guess I'm in the "less rote memorization" camp.
People who are lazy, and wouldn't bother memorizing a route anyway, will be helped by something like SatNav or Google Maps -- and yes, probably use them as a crutch. But it's better than them not being able to get anywhere. Me? Having instant access to a birds-eye view of every road in my city (Los Angeles) has given me the tools I need to memorize many routes, and is one of the reasons I can drive around this city so effectively.
Technology is a tool. Use it how you will.
The question isn't: "Would a London cabby using satnav software without having learned the city do better than a London cabby who learned the city?"
The question is: "Would a London cabby using satnav software do better than one without - both having learned the city?"
In other words: Assuming good satnav software that knew current traffic conditions and historic average speeds of the roads, with an easy interface to offer multiple routing options that are easily changeable (for instance) - wouldn't that be helpful to a cabby vs. a cabby that didn't have that extra tool?
I don't think it's fair to compare human+tech vs. human-only performance with no tech. Better to compare them with tech, since the whole point is that technology is available and used.
A ship that can carry a settler across the ocean is a prosthetic foot that extends his powers of travel. Eye-glasses are prosthetic eyes that extend your power of vision.
With the internet we are basically building improved books with better lookup features, they both are still prosthetic memory storage communicating information visually.
I'm not a triumphalist about it either. Technology gives but also takes.
I agree it's new to be measuring this in milliseconds and discussing fiber optics rather than hours and the transatlantic-cable (or days and the pony express).
If we're in the long view and talking about evolution, I disagree that the underlying process driving this has changed.
I guess it's just a discussion of the merits between looking at the position of a car vs. one of its derivatives such as acceleration. You need to know all of them to predict its future position and there are possibly an infinite number of derivatives.
I'm interested to know what causes this: whether it's due to the discipline (the thrill of navigating a puzzle, like a unix operator gets), or the institution (feeling like you're part of something important).
I had a freaky conversation with a driver last winter about messaging systems. He knew all the right questions after I told him what I did, and made comments about the particular technologies. It came out that we were working on the opposite ends of a big integration between firms. He was unhappy with that life and very comfortable at the prospect of spending the rest of his days driving a cab around.
Yes, I'm not as good at arithmetic as a technical person from 50 or even 30 years ago. But I'm freed from having to do all of that myself so I can focus energy to what I actually care about.