Have you tried UDF?
http://duncanlock.net/blog/2013/05/13/using-udf-as-an-improv...
Re:DragonFly BSD 5.2
by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday April 14, 2018 @11:35AM
(#16837742)
UDF has a lot of issues in actual implementation. For instance MacOS will only support UDF on an unpartitioned disk, while Windows will only support it on a partitioned one (IIRC was true for 7, may not be anymore). Additionally, since it has posix permissions, I expect it will have the same multi-user issue on posix systems that ext does, though I haven't tested this.
What’s wrong with FAT?
Re:DragonFly BSD 5.2
by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday April 14, 2018 @11:29AM
(#16837711)
It doesn't scale well and it is legally encumbered.
I really would have thought that the open source community could have tackled this problem, but no one seems interested.
Can't be done. It's 2018 and FAT is still apparently the best we can do for universally usable filesystem.
And don't go trying to pin this on Windows not supporting ext or something stupid like that, because an ext filesystem cannot by default be both read and written universally even on systems that have full ext support, because they bake in permissions and the default umask botches this simple use case.
I realize this is sort of tangential to what you're saying, but I think a big problem we have in tech communities is that we focus too much on fancy interesting things and not enough on stuff that gets things done simply.