News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Go That Way, Really Fast by derefr on Sunday September 12, 2010 @06:03AM (#1683388)
> Yes, Apple has indisputably better taste -- and an impeccably controlled experience. But at their current rate of progress, they'll be playing second or third fiddle to Google in the mobile space inside a few years. It's inevitable.

I'm not sure whether the second sentence is supposed to actually contradict the first here, or if it's just a separate, orthogonal assertion (perhaps about technical quality or features)—but if Atwood is really trying to imply that you can iterate toward "tastefulness", that's simply ignorant.

There is a reason that the term "design" exists as a separate and unique idea from "implementation." By looking at your entire problem space top-down, you can see the "shape" of the space, and so head straight toward the global minima. Plopping down in one place and running really fast will just get you to the top of the nearest hill, not the tallest mountain. Google is great at hill-climbing, but I've never seen them start on a hill, realize they were stuck, climb down, and find a mountain. (Instead, Google's successful projects either start at the base of the tallest mountain—Pagerank, Gmail, Chrome, etc.—or are acquired from someone else who has already done the design stage for them—Maps, Groups, etc. It doesn't seem like Android is in either of these categories.)

Re:Go That Way, Really Fast by rimantas on Sunday September 12, 2010 @07:12AM (#1683448)
I am not even sure what the second sentence means. Google no longer produces phones. Was it about OS? Then how do you compare order of the fiddles? By market share? Makes little sense. By revenue? Makes no sense in this case. By customer satisfaction? iOS progress it tightly coupled with hardware: iPhones, iPad, iPod touch. Android progress is handicapped by carriers — how do they push updates to handsets.
Re:Go That Way, Really Fast by ergo98 on Sunday September 12, 2010 @09:58AM (#1683659)
The whole paragraph is a meaningless orthogonal assertion. Jeff wanted to say "look at how Android has progressed", but somehow go waylaid into defending his historic strong iPhone bias, destroying whatever example he might be making.

However, to your point, discarding "tastefulness" as meaningless subjectivity, yes of course you can iterate towards a better, more attractive, more usable user experience.

Anyone who has lived with Android through 1.x on to 2.x and finally to 2.2 would say that many elements have absolutely improved dramatically -- constant usage provides feedback that refines design, while simply having time and resources provides the avenue to implement more advanced UI elements.

And during that time Google has added a number of UI and design experts to the team (again, time and focus: It actually matters now, whereas before they got the core product it didn't). It does seem to be paying off.