News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by lurquer on Thursday April 12, 2018 @02:31PM (#16823623)
Is there practical expirementsl evidence demonstrating birds can sense magnetic fields? That is, can you train a bird to select between two boxes, one of which contains a strong magnet?

Just wondering. I'd read about theories regarding iron in the beaks and whatnot. Sounds cruel, but why not (a) train the bird to select the magnet, then (b) remove beak and check if it can still do the trick, or (c) remove eyes and see if it can still do the trick.

I'm not entirely sure, though, that (a) has been accomplished. Can't find anything on it.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by miles on Thursday April 12, 2018 @03:28PM (#16824131)
> "Sounds cruel, but why not (a) train the bird to select the magnet, then (b) remove beak and check if it can still do the trick, or (c) remove eyes and see if it can still do the trick."

It sounds cruel because it is cruel.

Reminds me of this quote from Dostoevsky's "The Brothers Karamazov"[0]:

Tell me yourself, I challenge your answer. Imagine that you are creating a fabric of human destiny with the object of making men happy in the end, giving them peace and rest at last, but that it was essential and inevitable to torture to death only one tiny creature ... and to found that edifice on its unavenged tears, would you consent to be the architect on those conditions? Tell me, and tell the truth.

[0] http://www.bluffton.edu/homepages/facstaff/bergerd/classes/L...

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by noir-york on Thursday April 12, 2018 @03:56PM (#16824363)
Nice bit of literature reference there. The interesting thing about moral frameworks is there are so many to choose from.

Throughout history we have been known to send our sons and daughters to die in large numbers to first gain, and then protect, basic freedoms. And for other, less honourable, reasons as well...

Returning back to science, a utilitarian could easily make the case that, if it is impossible to avoid, being cruel to bird for the sake of humanity may be a tradeoff worth making.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by Area12 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @04:38PM (#16824721)
So does morality/ethics boil down to numbers/metrics? I'm not being sarcastic; I don't know the answer myself ... and I'm not entirely sure that I would want to "know".

Humans have gained great powers of number calculation, but I suspect that our greatest power and obsession has always been story-telling. We tell stories to each other and ourselves, and those stories form the basis of our ethics and morality.

Which is why I think utilitarianism always feels cold and unsatisfying; it doesn't play well as a story.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by blattimwind on Thursday April 12, 2018 @05:25PM (#16825065)
> So does morality/ethics boil down to numbers/metrics?

The field of ethics essentially considers how to build and analyse arguments. Ethics generally does not make decisions; and it's not a flowchart you can follow to get a yes/no answer, either. People often use the world "unethical" as-if it is a proper adjective, meanwhile it actually refers to themselves having concluded that the act/object is not ethical within their reasoning; it's not an actual property of an act or object.

Much like broad philosophy, it's a language for expressing thoughts. It doesn't think for you. Or, if you like, mathematics is a language for expressing some other thoughts. Mathematics doesn't solve problems for you, or prevents you from writing 3+1=5.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by JamesLeonis on Thursday April 12, 2018 @10:55PM (#16826835)
There is a distinction between Ethics and Morals. Morals are the things you value, like liberty and happiness. Ethics are decision-making systems that you configure with morals. They are designed to aid you in situations where two or more of your morals/values are in conflict.

Before talking about Utilitarianism, we first must talk about it's parent Consequentialism. The basics are this; Consequentialists state that the outcomes of an ethical decision should leave the outcome in a superior moral position. This is opposite of such systems like Kantian Virtue Ethics that state a more a priori value on the decision, even if the outcome is negatively affected. Honor might be a Virtue Ethic, since you would always act honorably even if the situation makes that a bad course of action.

Utilitarianism is a balance point between two Consequentialist children: Ethical Egoism and Ethical Altruism. Both (respectively) examine the outcome based on the individual making the decision, and the rest of the situation outside of the individual. Combining both Utilitarianists examine the outcomes of both the individual and the surrounding environment when determining which course of action to take.

tl;dr: Ethics are amoral systems of decision making that tell you where and how to apply your morals.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by tisdy on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:39PM (#16826974)
> Morals are the things you value, like liberty and happiness

I disagree, the conventional and I think the more widely understood meaning of 'morals' would be 'principles' or 'standards of right and wrong'. I think the term 'values' would do just fine.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by noir-york on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:21AM (#16827515)
Not sure why your comment was downvoted. Its an informed comment that adds to the discussion.
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by golergka on Friday April 13, 2018 @03:38AM (#16827847)
Any moral or ethical system will have logical inconsistencies and fallacies because they are based on instincts developed by human evolution, not mathematical axioms. Those instincts were developed in groups of 100-200 people, directly depending on your ability to see other human being face to face, know him and emphasize with them. They break down when you try to extrapolate them to millions of people.
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by lkrubner on Thursday April 12, 2018 @04:32PM (#16824685)
"a utilitarian could easily make the case that"

Are you making that argument? Your comment seems an extreme example of writing that uses the passive voice.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by jstanley on Thursday April 12, 2018 @04:58PM (#16824880)
I think it's more interesting to honestly discuss the argument and its merits if one doesn't have to personally vouch for it upfront.
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by noir-york on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:32AM (#16827566)
The moral framework used generally tends to determine where one falls on the major debates in ethics. As I happen to be aware of the different moral frameworks, I do not have the luxury of being beholden to an unexamined, implicitly "chosen" moral framework. Often times my internal debate is which framework is the most appropriate to evaluate the ethical question at hand. I am talking about hard ethical problems here like euthanasia, not the everyday things like lying, theft, etc.

To answer your question, while in my personal life I take a more deontological (Kantian) moral approach, if I were in a policy making role I'd take the pragmatic, utilitarian road; that bird would be sacrificed if it really did help advance science. Ecce homo.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by Retric on Thursday April 12, 2018 @02:35PM (#16823662)
Yea, there are some interesting experiments on this stuff. Though they used drugs vs surgery to test it out.

Tunnel test

The pigeons were trained to go to one end of the tunnel if the coils were switched on, generating a magnetic field, and to the other if they were switched off, leaving Earth's natural field unperturbed. "I was pleasantly surprised. The pigeons were very fast learners," says Mora, now at the University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill.

Their skills were impaired, however, when the researchers attached magnets to their upper beaks, and also when the upper beak was anaesthetized. This suggests that their ability is down to the presence of magnetically sensitive material in this area, the researchers report in this week's Nature1."

https://www.nature.com/news/2004/041122/full/news041122-7.ht...

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by lurquer on Thursday April 12, 2018 @08:03PM (#16826029)
Hey, thanks! That's what I was looking for! Their procedure is far less bloody than my proposal... that's probably why I'm not a biologist. I guess the "Let's just chop it off and see what happens" ploy isn't all that sophisticated.
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by piptastic on Thursday April 12, 2018 @02:32PM (#16823627)
maybe just blindfold the bird, instead of removing the eyes
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by mandelbulb on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:40PM (#16826510)
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by jrimbault on Thursday April 12, 2018 @03:20PM (#16824056)
Don't most bird just go to sleep when blindfolded ? Or is it just an idea that got in my mind ?
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by SAI_Peregrinus on Thursday April 12, 2018 @04:37PM (#16824714)
They don't tend to actually sleep. They do become more docile, because they can't see to fly without risking hitting something.
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by jrimbault on Friday April 13, 2018 @03:59AM (#16827937)
Thinking about it, it was pretty dumb on my part. I know about hunting birds, I should have thought about that.
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by lloeki on Thursday April 12, 2018 @10:06PM (#16826623)
> they can't see to fly without risking hitting something.

This sentence makes me wonder: are they docile because it genuinely calms them, or are they entering a sort of helpless automatic panic mode, like "OMFG no escape, can't fly, can't move"?

The latter sounds like the bird is getting a terrifying experience.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by elchief on Thursday April 12, 2018 @03:21PM (#16824069)
Alligators do. Not sure about birds
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by godelmachine on Thursday April 12, 2018 @02:41PM (#16823706)
You are genius, coz I consider myself non violent, and even I couldn't think of the blindfold idea when the above guy spoke of removing their eyes
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by lurquer on Thursday April 12, 2018 @08:07PM (#16826048)
I considered blindfolding, but from what I gather the protein would be activated merely with the presence of the field.

Looks like the humane way to test, according to the article cited above, is to affix magnets to the eyes/beak to see if it disrupts anything. In any case, in retrospect, I personally feel my suggestion to remove the beak is more cruel than removing the eyes. Both are hideous to contemplate. But, a bird without a beak? That's just a miserable thing to imagine.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by caf on Thursday April 12, 2018 @08:50PM (#16826236)
The original article suggests that the cryptochrome responsible for magnetic sensing must be stimulated by light to work, and in particular light of the right wavelength.
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by wil421 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @06:23PM (#16825481)
“One man's life or death were but a small price to pay for the acquirement of the knowledge which I sought, for the dominion I should acquire and transmit over the elemental foes of our race.”

- Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein

I would hope science has evolved were we could devise a test without having to resort to such a method. Maybe I am too far removed from such things, out of sight out of mind.

Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by felipemnoa on Thursday April 12, 2018 @06:45PM (#16825647)
There are probably ways to accomplish what you are saying without mutilating the bird. i.e. Just cover its eyes instead of removing them. etc. etc.
Re:Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptoch... by liveoneggs on Thursday April 12, 2018 @03:11PM (#16823982)
next remove the guts and feathers; add salt, pepper, flour, egg whites; dip in hot oil; enjoy