News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by poutine on Saturday September 11, 2010 @01:09PM (#1681857)
I'm horrified at the amount of people calling him a douche and asshole in his blog comments for asserting his rights. I didn't think such submission to authority had become such an American trait.
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by tptacek on Saturday September 11, 2010 @01:57PM (#1681985)
As someone who used precisely this word to describe him, I'll say that it's his attitude and his worldview that any cooperation with law enforcement is fodder for a vast conspiracy to incarcerate him that motivated me. It is not an abrogation of your civil liberaties to answer a question.

That said, I also recognize the value of what he did, and I'm glad there are douchebags like him out there, exactly like Colbert's "Douchebag of Liberty" segment about the guy who flips off patrol cops as a matter of policy. Thank you, douchebags of liberty.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by mattmaroon on Saturday September 11, 2010 @02:26PM (#1682044)
The attitude and worldview I find more naive and paranoid than douche-baggish. What really made me think "what a tool" me was quote "The CBP goons want U.S. citizens to answer their questions as a ritualistic bow to their power."

It's the fundamental (and obviously incorrect) assumption that they're some sort of thugs, rather than decent people just trying to do the job they are paid and trained to do, that makes the author a certified douche bag.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by dgordon on Saturday September 11, 2010 @03:55PM (#1682234)
"It's the fundamental (and obviously incorrect) assumption that they're some sort of thugs, rather than decent people just trying to do the job they are paid and trained to do, that makes the author a certified douche bag."

I don't find that obviously incorrect. The banality of evil is probably the most important lesson in human nature of the twentieth century, and it makes many kinds of "decent people just trying to do the job they are paid and trained to do" look a lot closer to thugs -- or at best their enablers.

Could he have done what he did in a less abrasive way? Probably so. But refusing to go along with even little infringements on human liberty is an essential part of eternal vigilance.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by tptacek on Saturday September 11, 2010 @04:11PM (#1682254)
Can you explain how you managed to transit from "The banality of evil is probably the most important lesson" to "it's not obvious that the border police aren't thugs"? Are people thugs by default in your worldview? Or just all law enforcement officers?
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by barrkel on Saturday September 11, 2010 @04:14PM (#1682262)
People in positions of power often act inadvertently thuggish, yes. It's in the nature of positions of power and the human condition. It's why it's so important to have checks and balances, and ensure that those checks and balances are exercised regularly so that they don't get rusty from disuse.

Take the Nazis. It's not like every German was evil, or even that most Germans were evil. It was the situation and structure that was evil, and the social proof, and a hundred and one other things, that add up to decent people doing monstrous evil.

Character really doesn't matter for as much as a lot of people like to think. Almost everything people do comes down to their incentives and their situation, from the lowest thug to the most noble statesman. Ascribing flaws or nobility to character is a way of personalizing these situations, often to justify treating people with very few options with harshness and cruelty, while rewarding people in the position to do good with social standing and wealth, etc.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by tptacek on Saturday September 11, 2010 @04:30PM (#1682288)
It doesn't help when you have a society led by Hitler, Goebbels, and Himmler. By which I mean to point out that Nazism is a silly comparison to make.
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by mattmaroon on Sunday September 12, 2010 @12:57AM (#1683077)
Well, in fairness the thread did go on long enough to satisfy Goodwin's law.
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by dgordon on Saturday September 11, 2010 @04:24PM (#1682273)
What the banality of evil suggests is that "evil" or in this case "thuggish" behavior is much more a function of social role, and less a function of character, than people thought. (Yes, it really was a radical idea -- recall that two-thirds of the people in Milgram's famous experiment went to shocking an unresponsive subject with 450 volts, when almost everyone had assumed, prior to the experiment actually being run, that only a one-in-a-thousand psychopath would get there. Check out Milgram's book Obedience To Authority for more details.)
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by tptacek on Saturday September 11, 2010 @04:28PM (#1682282)
You're doing a fine job illustrating the banality of evil, but you're not explaining what that has to do with the situation at hand. Yes, we need to be on guard for situations in which authoritarianism provides cover for evil. That's why we have a constitution and a court system and why we elect the people who create laws and appoint the people who enforce them.
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by philwelch on Saturday September 11, 2010 @05:16PM (#1682366)
Holding someone up from reentering his own country because he didn't tell you all about his trip to China is rather thuggish behavior in my opinion.
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by barrkel on Saturday September 11, 2010 @04:12PM (#1682258)
People turn into thugs in large part because of their position in power dynamics. That is, it's most probably that it's the job that makes people thugs, not the people themselves (decent though they may be outside the job). Cf. Stanford Prison Experiment etc.
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by tptacek on Saturday September 11, 2010 @04:25PM (#1682277)
The Stanford Prison Experiment suggests that we be on guard for situations where power dynamics encourage thuggish behavior. It does not, however, follow from the experiment that every law enforcement officer is a thug.
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by dgordon on Saturday September 11, 2010 @05:51PM (#1682435)
"Not every X is Y" is almost never a relevant or meaningful argument. It certainly doesn't answer "Position X promotes Y-like behavior, and so many "decent, average people" in position X will be Ys."
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by points on Saturday September 11, 2010 @06:12PM (#1682470)
He was being a dick for the sake of it.

You don't answer an officials first question with "None of your business" unless you're being a dick, trying to get in trouble, or trying to pick a fight with them.

Just tell them what they want to hear in wooly non-descriptive language.

She only asked "Why were you in China" for god sake. Just answer "I like China".

These moral crusader 'principle of the thing' types irritate the hell out of me.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by arvinjoar on Sunday September 12, 2010 @08:04AM (#1683510)
I went to an American High School for a year and noticed that compared to Swedes, Americans tend to really respect authority. I was screamed at by a history teacher for calling him "Newell" when I should have said "Mr. Newell" (in Sweden we don't do this, so it's easy to forget).

Swedes tend to be naïve when it comes to the government though, but that might be because compared to the USA the rate of corruption in Swedish government is low.

But yeah, from experience I've found that Americans demand customer service from the private sector, but never from the public sector. What is up with that?

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by hugh3 on Saturday September 11, 2010 @05:21PM (#1682381)
Perhaps that's because where you see "asserting his rights" I just see an attention-seeking lawyer lording himself over low-paid fellow human beings with a dull and thankless task to perform.

You can "assert your rights" all you want, and those include the right to be a douchebag. If I meet you at a bar and I say "Hi, how are you?" and you say "Screw you, I don't have to answer your questions!" you're well within your rights but still a douchebag. It's nice to know you have the legal right to do something stupid (burn a koran or stand on a street corner in Harlem with a sign that says "I hate niggers") but putting those legal rights to the test may still make you a douchebag.

Also, I'm considering it from the point of view of the hundreds of people who were no doubt stuck behind him in the line while he threw his little hissy fit.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by mattmaroon on Saturday September 11, 2010 @01:45PM (#1681943)
Funny, I feel the exact opposite. I'm horrified that people would consider this asserting his rights rather than being a douche.

Asserting your rights is not moving to the back of the bus because your skin is the wrong color. Not just telling some customs guy who gets paid $12 an hour to answer questions mandated by Congress the answer to some insignificant questions is just being a douche.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by wrs on Saturday September 11, 2010 @02:05PM (#1682002)
What is the "douche faction's" obsession with the pay of CBP officers? Is that somehow relevant to the discussion? He only dealt with the front-line officer for about two minutes anyway--in the back room he asked for a more-highly-paid superior and got one. So I'm assuming that makes you happier?

BTW, do you have a citation for "mandated by Congress," or are you relying on the statement of the $12/hour officer for that?

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by mattmaroon on Saturday September 11, 2010 @02:24PM (#1682042)
The point of the pay is to illustrate how far removed the person the author is being a douche to is from the people who make the policies. People in low level jobs like that are generally just trying to get through the day.

Asserting that "The CBP goons want U.S. citizens to answer their questions as a ritualistic bow to their power" is douchebaggery in it's highest form, and it illustrates his mindset as that of man vs government. That statement alone, referring to decent people just trying to do their job as goons, qualifies the author as a douchebag.

Also, how much power does a guy on a low-level government wage really feel they have? I'd bet anything they're told in their training that what they do is extremely important, that they are on the front lines in the war on terror. And they're also told that when someone refuses to cooperate (which, by the way, no terrorist would do) there's pretty much nothing they can do about it. They have what they feel is responsibility without power, which is a terrible situation for them to be in.

I certainly don't know or care if those questions are mandated by Congress. (I don't find it hard to believe that they were though, or at least mandated by a group set up by Congress for that purpose.) It doesn't really matter.

What I'm sure of is that they weren't mandated by the any of the people who questioned our author, especially if there are check boxes for them in some software. They probably weren't mandated by anyone who had ever met any of the author's victims, or even heard of them. And the people who mandated them will most likely never even hear of this guy or the handful of nutjobs like him.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by argv_empty on Saturday September 11, 2010 @03:21PM (#1682165)
The point of the pay is to illustrate how far removed the person the author is being a douche to is from the people who make the policies. People in low level jobs like that are generally just trying to get through the day.

If it is not a legal requirement that they detain entrants who do not answer questions entrants are not required to answer, then someone who does so anyway does not get to use the "just doing my job" defense.

Asserting that "The CBP goons want U.S. citizens to answer their questions as a ritualistic bow to their power" is douchebaggery in it's highest form

Except this is precisely what distinguishes them from CBP non-goons.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by mattmaroon on Saturday September 11, 2010 @03:37PM (#1682196)
This is yet another reason why the pay is important. Low level jobs are process-oriented. They are designed to be carried out by average people. They are trained on what to do in various situations, of which this is probably one. I don't know about legal requirements, but I'd bet anything their training doesn't tell them to just say "have a nice day" when someone refuses to answer simple questions.

The customs agents this guy dealt with were just doing what they were trained to do. That's all they can be expected to do, all they should do. It's unreasonable to treat them as goons for simply doing their job. They're real people, most of them probably decent ones (because really, most people are decent people) who have families to feed, mortgages to pay, cars to buy, etc. Assuming that they are not makes the author a douchebag (and one who reads way too much Orwell).

There is not a distinction between goons and non-goons that can be made. He'd probably get similar results at any airport he went to because they all go through the same training program.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by kelnos on Sunday September 12, 2010 @06:56AM (#1683434)
I don't know about legal requirements, but I'd bet anything their training doesn't tell them to just say "have a nice day" when someone refuses to answer simple questions.

Then it should. He is under no legal obligation to answer their questions. If I were to try something similar, I'd be much more polite about it, but, rude or not, he was perfectly within his rights to refuse to answer.

Now, if other factors were enough to actually raise reasonable suspicion that he had done something wrong (such as smuggling some contraband into the country), then the proper response is to move him on to further screening.

It's unreasonable to treat them as goons for simply doing their job.

Ah, yes, the tried-and-true "just doing their job" argument. I don't buy it. People are responsible for their conduct while performing their job. Their employer may set policy, but in the end the person implementing that policy that must accept shared responsibility for that policy.

They're real people, most of them probably decent ones (because really, most people are decent people)

Wait, wait, wait. Now, I'm going on just the words of the author here, but:

"The officer changed tack to bad cop. 'Let this guy sit until he cools down,' the officer loudly said to a colleague. 'It could be two, three, four hours. He’s gonna sit there until he cools down.'"

How does that describe the actions of a decent person? I don't care if the author was rude to the customs official. Declaring in a power-trip manner that you're going to make someone wait for 2-4 hours just because you can... how is that decent?

I do think the guy was a bit of a douche in how he handled the situation: "none of your business" is probably one of the rudest ways he could refuse to answer. Something more like, "I'm sorry, but I'm not legally required to answer your questions and would prefer not to," seems like it would have garnered a better response, both from the customs officials, and from the hordes of commenters calling him a douche. If he had done that, and still was subjected to the same mistreatment, I'd feel a lot more sympathetic. But still, he did nothing legally wrong, and exercised his rights as a US citizen, and was detained and hassled for it. That's wrong.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by dgordon on Saturday September 11, 2010 @04:02PM (#1682244)
I don't think you can read too much Orwell, nor, in nonfiction, too much Solzhenitsyn or Milton Mayer.
Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by mattmaroon on Sunday September 12, 2010 @01:11AM (#1683092)
Any Orwell other than Animal Farm is too much Orwell.

Orwell's fundamental problem was that he didn't understand how organizations function, and how the whole differs from the sum of its parts. He saw only the trees and not the forest. He understood what motivated individuals well, and just extrapolated that out, which led to erroneous thinking.

Aldous Huxley was quite the opposite, which is why his vision of government and society has in many ways materialized but his vision of the individual has not. There was a great post here a couple weeks back about the two that illustrated it.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by amh on Saturday September 11, 2010 @04:52PM (#1682332)
So, just curious; where's the dividing line between "poor government schlub just doing his job" and "Nazi prison guard who knew he was doing evil", assuming you'd agree the Nazi guard is culpable on some level?

Fact is, government employees can choose to work elsewhere. But as a citizen I'm stuck with my government. That's why you won't see much sympathy for law enforcement in these situations.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by mattmaroon on Saturday September 11, 2010 @11:36PM (#1682981)
You're not stuck with your government, you could move elsewhere, probably about as easily as a border patrol employee could find another job.

I don't know where the line is, but it's pretty clear that the customs agent is on the other side if it from the Nazi guard. It's certainly somewhere in between those two.

Re:What happens when you refuse to answer a passport control... by othermaciej on Saturday September 11, 2010 @09:34PM (#1682814)
> I certainly don't know or care if those questions are mandated by Congress. (I don't find it hard to believe that they were though, or at least mandated by a group set up by Congress for that purpose.) It doesn't really matter.

> What I'm sure of is that they weren't mandated by the any of the people who questioned our author, especially if there are check boxes for them in some software. They probably weren't mandated by anyone who had ever met any of the author's victims, or even heard of them. And the people who mandated them will most likely never even hear of this guy or the handful of nutjobs like him.

They probably weren't mandated by anyone at all, or at least, no one with the rightful author authority to mandate answering such questions. Thus, it's valuable to the rest of us that some exceptional people will assert their right not to answer.