News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by solracanobra on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @01:52PM (#16813609)
So what's the benefit of these? We understand that the key to weight loss is calories in, calories out.

What's so hard to understand about that..? Maybe I am missing the point. Is this just to gather more evidence to prove caloric deficits are the correct way?

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by bgentry on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:03PM (#16813728)
At the pure physical level, yes: calories remaining = calories in - calories out

However, the "calories out" portion of that equation is actually quite complicated. In recent years many studies have indicated that the body does not process all calories in the same way. So "calories out" depends on a lot of things, including:

- metabolism, which can be increased by exercise and muscle mass

- what specific kind of "calories in" you're getting, and how your body processes these

- calories burned directly by exercise

To highlight one specific example of this, a calorie of fructose may be processed by the body very differently than a calorie of, say, vegetable fat: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by wutbrodo on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:35PM (#16814053)
> However, the "calories out" portion of that equation is actually quite complicated

The "calories in" part is more complicated than people like to admit too, and probably more important for weight loss. The way our body handles hunger and its relative primacy in our mental state makes it unnecessarily difficult to calorie restrict and then maintain, when eating certain diets. It's like telling an alcoholic "just stop drinking, duh" or an insomniac "just relax and sleep, simple as that". Just because something is in our brain doesn't mean we have full control over it, and I'm not sure why food is treated like something that everyone magically has complete self-control over, in contrast to _literally everything else_.

I'm really really fortunate to have grown up in a good food culture, and worked on it a little more in college. Meeting CICO goals and losing weight when I want to is really not that difficult for me, but I don't think this has much to do with self-control or my genetics. The way I eat just makes hunger less of a factor in my life: I rarely get hungry, skipping meals is never a problem, I get satiated quickly, etc etc.

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by Andre_Wanglin on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:25PM (#16813927)
>However, the "calories out" portion of that equation is actually quite complicated. In recent years many studies have indicated that the body does not process all calories in the same way.

I think of this as the "calories in" portion. There was never any reason to assume the means by which we measure the caloric content of food truly represented the caloric energy available to the body.

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by WorldMaker on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @03:14PM (#16814483)
It's the phlogiston fallacy that all heat is equally the same chemical energy, and that all chemical reactions "just" produce or consume heat. The body is not an ideal furnace, and food is not an ideal fuel.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by xutopia on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:19PM (#16813878)
The process for storing fat as fat is paradoxically very difficult for the body chemically. The easiest way for the body to add stores of fat reserves is through sugar and the more refined (HFCS comes to mind) it is the easiest it is for the body.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by kmm on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:43PM (#16814136)
Can you source that? Because as far as I can tell, de novo lipogenesis is a relatively rare process, exactly because our body prefers to just store the fat in the blood as fat. Sugar is burned preferentially, and only when your carb intake exceeds your total daily energy expenditure, it will start converting it to fat: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10365981

I'm not sure what chemically needs to happen, fat is transported from the bowel to the bloodstream in a relatively complex process, but once it's in the blood, it's in the same form as in storage, as triglycerides.

In fact, the triglyceride content of a person's fat stores will reflect their diet, which is a strong indication it comes directly from the food without processing: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/4072956

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by tacon on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @08:02PM (#16816917)
Paleo Diet & Strength Training Biochemistry | Doug McGuff M.D.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F7GB3h82tcQ

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by jmull on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:42PM (#16814124)
> We understand that the key to weight loss is calories in, calories out.

That's not at all true.

CICO is a straightforward restatement of a law of thermodynamics, and I'm not disputing that at all.

But from a weight-loss perspective, understanding CICO isn't necessarily that helpful, and certainly not "the key". The difficult question is how any particular individual can make CO > CI. (Well, actually, the goal is to balance CO with CI at a healthy weight, but of course that's step 2 for a lot of people.)

There are many millions of people for whom the answer to that question is not known.

I suspect it's because Human metabolism is complicated, with numerous overlapping and interacting mechanisms and system, where the parameters for how they interact vary by individual... hormones, habits, social network, culture, taste, access to food options, physical health, your job, etc., can all be significant factors, depending on the individual. Meanwhile, food producers of various sorts are often acting at cross-purposes, since their goal is to make as much money as possible, not necessarily help people lose weight.

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by WorldMaker on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @03:20PM (#16814539)
> CICO is a straightforward restatement of a law of thermodynamics

The Second Law of Thermodynamics applies to closed systems only. Show me the ecosystem where food consumed and a human body is a perfectly closed system with no other inputs/outputs and I'll show you how that does not resemble the real world and you are making underlying assumptions you cannot prove.

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by bitwize on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @05:35PM (#16815941)
In a closed system, CI=CO=0, by definition, so I think you've got the wrong thermodynamic law.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by WorldMaker on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @05:57PM (#16816119)
Apologies, I did mean the First Law, but the criticism still applies. The First Law of Thermodynamics also includes a closed system assumption.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by WorldMaker on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @06:37PM (#16816380)
Unless by "restatement of a Law of Thermodynamics" it is meant "restate of the Law of Conservation of Mass-Energy", at which point the criticism becomes that you now have a tougher isolated system assumption in the general case to prove.

The real criticism, however is that you cannot just assume that CICO is a restatement of the Law of Conservation of Mass-Energy, because it relies on the spurious assumption that "nutritional calories" are sufficient approximations for the entirety of energy in the system.

There's been a ton of work in chemistry and physics to untangle the mistakes of phlogiston theory, and caloric theory [1]. The SI unit of energy is now the Joule to absolutely distance from the problematic "calorie", and the confusion between what nutrition studies call a calorie and what Physics calls a calorie and what Joules are is an amazing mess.

Nutrition "science" seems to me like the last bastion of some middle ground between phlogiston and caloric theory, and CICO the battle cry of its devout believers.

[1] https://www.britannica.com/science/caloric-theory

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by pubby on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @03:44PM (#16814758)
I used to bash CICO as being an over-simplification until I actually looked at the numbers.

The average american eats 3600 calories per day. Fat ones eat more; perhaps 4000 to 8000. This is far beyond amounts recommended to lose weight effectively: 1500 or less.

There are lots of variables in human nutrition and metabolism, but the biggest by far is the fact that people are eating 3-5x the amount of food they should.

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by Faaak on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @01:56PM (#16813658)
CICO is not exactly true. Not all calories are equal. Fat calories, for example, are much less absorbed by the body than carbohydrates.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by azemetre on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:49PM (#16814211)
You're talking about calorie differentials amounting to 40 or 80 per day. Hardly something worth considering for the average person, but I'm sure it gives you easy grant money to chug out reports.

If you think obesity is due to the difference between 80 calories or so, you have other drastic immediate concerns (the terrible mental model being one). People aren't becoming obese because their body isn't "processing" fat calories compared to carb calories, they are obese because people eat obscene amounts of food daily.

Countries like France and Italy eat massive amounts of carbs in their diets and they don't have obesity issues on the scale of the United States.

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by Andre_Wanglin on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:04PM (#16813743)
It's still CICO. It's just that the way we currently measure the caloric content of a food does not represent what is actually bioavailable.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by laretluval on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:37PM (#16814068)
So it’s CICO for some unobservable quantity of calories. Real useful.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by adrianN on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:42PM (#16814122)
It's really useful if you don't change your diet, but eat less of the same stuff as before.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by laretluval on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @11:17PM (#16817711)
Not necessarily. Bioavailable calories may not be a linear function of calories consumed.

CICO is empirically vacuous.

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by garrettdc on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:13PM (#16813825)
It does a good enough job at modeling reality that we can make decent predictions with it. While the details of CICO may be more complicated, for someone who is obviously out of shape, the advice of "Eat some extra protein and make sure you are consuming below maintenance calories" works 9/10 times.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by WorldMaker on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @03:21PM (#16814559)
Which is why Weight Watchers and Jenny Craig have never changed their formulas, always works for everyone, never have repeat customers, and are nearly broke charities, right?~
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by tacon on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @08:09PM (#16816951)
Those companies are a nicely disguised cover to maintain one's status quo. An online marketer once pointed out a Jenny Craig(?) advertisement: "Eat all the food you want!" Busted.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by rimliu on Thursday April 12, 2018 @04:01AM (#16818841)
Calories that not abosorbed are calories-through, not calories -in.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by supreme_sublime on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:02PM (#16813720)
The point of these is body positivity basically. You are fat and it isn't your fault. Even if you do exercise it won't be enough. It is strange though, pretty much no one thinks that just exercising is enough. Any workout program will tell you that a 6 pack is made in the kitchen. Lifting weights and doing some cardio will certainly help the process and help you be healthier in general.

The biggest factor is nutrition.

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by garrettdc on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:17PM (#16813861)
> The biggest factor is nutrition

Yes!

> The point of these is body positivity basically. You are fat and it isn't your fault.

I didn't see this at all in there. If anything, this is written to people who think they can outwork a bad diet, which is rarely the case for anyone over 16. Nothing in there was about body positivity or anything. It just showed that even when we run and "burn 300 calories" that you are possibly holding that back somewhere else to stay at caloric balance.

Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by supreme_sublime on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @02:34PM (#16814029)
That's fair, I was definitely reading between the lines a bit. Just seems like the kind of article that some people who are deep in denial about their health will point to as "proof" that they are just this way and cannot change.
Re:Mice compensate for extra exercise by reducing other phys... by tacon on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @08:12PM (#16816970)
There is some help in weight control from lean muscle mass. Fat needs about 2 kcals/day/pound to stay alive. Muscle needs something in the 20 kcals/day/pound range to stay alive. Also, having a good amount of lean muscle mass naturally leads to a more active lifestyle in general. But these are still minor compared to basic diet.