News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by shin_lao on Friday September 10, 2010 @08:35AM (#1678623)
The "paypal blocked my money" stories are frequent.

I'm curious to which extent this is legal. I'm pretty sure a bank isn't allowed to block access to your accounts without a formal request from a legal entity.

Paypal doesn't "own" the money. This sounds to me as extremely abusive.

Is that this frequent?

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by jimbokun on Friday September 10, 2010 @08:55AM (#1678677)
Can anyone explain how PayPal is not constantly in court defending against class action law suits? No lawyer anywhere has considered the possibility of a massive payout from representing all of the clients over the world whose money PayPal has swallowed without explanation? Or, somehow, PayPal has managed to craft contracts so legally airtight that they can do absolutely anything with anyone's money with absolutely no legal obligations on their part?

It seems like the latter, but that seems to indicate that the legal systems of the world are fundamentally broken.

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by _delirium on Friday September 10, 2010 @02:07PM (#1679644)
They do sometimes get sued, though nobody's been hugely successful yet. Someone filed a class-action suit a few months ago over the holds issue, but I haven't been able to find any follow-up (e.g. whether it got certified as a class-action, dismissed, etc.): http://www.auctionbytes.com/cab/cab/abn/y10/m06/i08/s02

They were also sued in 2002 over the same issue, and settled in 2004 for the rather small sum of $9m, though they did also agree to modify their hold policy as part of the settlement (whether they've followed the terms of that agreement, I don't know): http://www.settlement4onlinepayments.com/injunctive.pdf

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by mkr-hn on Friday September 10, 2010 @09:04AM (#1678696)
Anyone with the money and will to tangle with Paypal has the clout to get enough attention to make Paypal change their mind.
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by jseliger on Friday September 10, 2010 @11:45AM (#1679190)
A corollary: Anyone with the money to tangle with Paypal has the wits not to need to use Paypal in the first place.
[deleted]
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by jacquesm on Friday September 10, 2010 @09:15AM (#1678718)
I've had this happen to me with $50K and it wasn't 'lies or made up' in that case, I suspect most of them are much like mine.

You realize you're up against a giant in a foreign country that says they'll release your funds in 6 months time. So rather than spend 50 K on American lawyers and end up with nothing even if you win you grit your teeth and get on with your job vowing to never use the service again. And they did pay out after 6 months.

In my case I've not even managed to stand by my vow because I had to pay a few people using paypal. But I'm no longer accepting paypal payments myself and I would advise everybody to keep their account balances as low as possible.

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by gdee on Friday September 10, 2010 @12:31PM (#1679321)

  >   But I'm no longer accepting paypal payments myself 
  > and I would advise everybody to keep their account 
  > balances as low as possible.
Sound advice. In my new private project, I redraw from paypal every 200 euros. Thankfully, that's a lot of redraws (for certain definitions of a lot) and I'm a bit behind redraws but I learned the lesson from the losses the company I work with endures every month. Details in this same thread. (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1679288)
[deleted]
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by jacquesm on Friday September 10, 2010 @09:31AM (#1678763)
edit (recovered because parent deleted their comment):

> citricsquid wrote: > And you're in the "legitimate claims" part, like I said. What's the story behind your problem, why did they take your $50k?

endedit.

To this day I haven't a friggin' clue. We were in their beta program when they started with batched money requests, we helped them debug their stuff and came with a bunch of helpful suggestions. We had over 30% of our customers using the paypay monthly money request to renew and had a whole pile of back-end stuff to handle the details.

boom one day to the next our account is frozen. But, and this is the juicy part, outstanding money requests were still being honoured and the money was taken from the users accounts when they tried to pay us.

So, from the users point of view they had paid and wanted service, from our point of view we did not receive the funds. Of course we realized the users couldn't help that so we gave them service anyway and only got their payment 6 months later. If PayPal would have at least stopped transferring money in to that account we could have made a different arrangement with those users for that month (fortunately this only affected the 'running' month for which money requests had been made).

Not a single person at paypal ever thought it worth their time to tell us why our account had been frozen.

I realize wallet systems are hard, that there are lots of people that will flock to a system like that in order to defraud it and so on. But when you're that close with a customer that has been in your pilot program and you freeze their assets and stonewall then you have a bunch of issues in your company that need taking care of.

PayPal, and by extension their parent company Ebay, sucks.

Re. Ebay, I alerted them recently to a bunch of guys that moved from Africa to London that are on their dutch auction site (yes, it's that complicated) using ripped images and fake details on vehicles and they're still at it, again, no response whatsoever.

I think that plenty of people are in the 'legitimate' claims part, and I'm giving you an illustration why we don't bother fighting. Personally I recognize too many elements in most of those stories to chalk them up to being bogus, what do those people have to gain from claiming paypal froze their accounts for no reason.

On my end there is nothing to gain, it's just another experience with a large company.

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by khafra on Friday September 10, 2010 @09:46AM (#1678807)
I've seen Paypal described as a fraud detection company monetized by a payment transfer front-end. With that core competency in mind, it astounds me how bad they are at recognizing communication from a customer that deserves attention and response.
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by Xurinos on Friday September 10, 2010 @12:23PM (#1679298)
What do you use now for your payments instead of PayPal?
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by jacquesm on Friday September 10, 2010 @12:39PM (#1679349)
Virtual access billing, a Dutch IPSP run by a bunch of friends of mine. They use segregated merchant accounts so the risk of them going belly up is minimal.
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by loewenskind on Friday September 10, 2010 @09:31AM (#1678762)
So you call most of the people who've ever claimed to have a problem with PayPal liars (unsurprisingly no less) and the nearest thing to a citation you provide for this claim is an anecdote and some naive pop legal analysis about "if they were bad they would get shut down!"?

Stay classy.

EDIT: Fixed faulty word selection.

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by jacquesm on Friday September 10, 2010 @09:54AM (#1678826)
s/lairs/liars and antidote/anecdote and it makes more sense.

touchscreen?

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by loewenskind on Friday September 10, 2010 @10:04AM (#1678853)
Sadly, no. Defeated by spell-check. :(
[deleted]
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by loewenskind on Friday September 10, 2010 @10:26AM (#1678928)
There seems to be some kind of timeout for responding to people who respond to you. I had to wait over 15 minutes to respond to someone yesterday. I get the feeling it has something to do with thread depth (e.g. prevent us from getting replies instantly nested 10 deep).

>My experience has been that while Paypal definitely have problems, a lot of the reported problems are exaggerated or lies.

Again you make the claim with nothing resembling a citation. What do you mean "my experience". Do you work for PayPal and actually chase these? Do you just hear things around the water cooler and have this impression? What is your experience exactly?

>So are you contesting that Paypal would get away with stealing everyones money all the time?

All the time? It's relative. Relative to the amount of transfers they do, I suspect it's a very minuscule amount. And I don't think they steal the money per se, just freeze the account.

Personally I think the problem is just that PayPal has near non-existent customer service. So if your account gets frozen you just have no way of getting something done about it.

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by acabal on Friday September 10, 2010 @08:38AM (#1678629)
That's the rub--Paypal is not a bank. They can do whatever they want with the virtual money that is exchanged on their servers. Which is why a real merchant account is the only serious option for a larger-scale business.
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by jacquesm on Friday September 10, 2010 @09:40AM (#1678792)
Paypal actually is a bank, just not in all jurisdictions.

As for the 'virtual money', it's not virtual, it's real. They run what is technically called a wallet system.

A real merchant account is of course an option, but the transaction fees can be quite high, there is the charge-back risk and a whole pile of regulatory hoops to go through before you can get that to work. Larger scale businesses have plenty of users for who credit card use is not an option. Large parts of the world are relatively free of the credit card plague and so can not pay you using your merchant account. For those situations paypal (or something like it that does not have paypals drawbacks) is a solution.

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by eru on Friday September 10, 2010 @10:07AM (#1678859)
Yes, in Germany you could probably get away with just a normal bank account and accepting direct bank transfers.
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by aw3c2 on Friday September 10, 2010 @01:06PM (#1679433)
Not as easily as with Paypal as transactions take a day or two.
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by nodata on Friday September 10, 2010 @08:42AM (#1678641)
They are a bank in Europe - or at least, they have a banking license in Europe.

Edit: mattmanser got there first.

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by mattmanser on Friday September 10, 2010 @08:42AM (#1678639)
They are a bank in Europe, just not the US. Sounds like the whole legal status in the US is a bit of a mess really:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PayPal#Regulation

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by all on Friday September 10, 2010 @11:16AM (#1679087)
While that may be true, Luxembourg is known as a tax haven. I note that Amazon also registers its European operations there. From the same source as you cited:

"Concern about Luxembourg's banking secrecy laws, and its reputation as a tax haven, led in April 2009 to it being added to a "grey list" of nations with questionable banking arrangements by the G20." [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Luxembourg#Banking]

So, in effect, Paypal is probably a bank in nominal terms only. They can still do pretty much whatever they want with your money and get away with it. That is why my company went with WorldPay even when we started out. We don't get charged any fees, just commission, and we get free fraud insurance on the major credit cards.

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by auxbuss on Friday September 10, 2010 @02:46PM (#1679790)
Paypal is a bank in Europe, as stated. I was one of those who lobbied to achieve this. I was burned by this odious outfit more than five years ago. You don't get two chances with someone else's money in their lifetime.

You can't be a bank "in nominal terms only" in Europe. Once registered as a bank you are bound by EU and Member State laws. There's no sidestepping that. Governments can't sidestep them.

The fact that Paypal is registered as a bank in a European Member State means that they must abide by these laws and the regulation that goes with it.

Remember, loser pays in European courts. So when a bank steps outside the law, it will be liable for costs and "damages". It is not in their interests to break or even "stretch" the law.

Regardless, I wouldn't do business with Paypal if you paid me. Well, perhaps I would, but pay it straight to my bank, and not via Paypal.

P.S. My fight goes on: this week I have been active again in the European Parliament with MEPs fighting to get the appalling ACTA spiked. Something we should all be aware of and striving to kill.

Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by acabal on Friday September 10, 2010 @08:55AM (#1678676)
I stand corrected, good to know!
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by laverick on Friday September 10, 2010 @08:50AM (#1678661)
Well, you can bet this kind of experience would quickly convince somebody to add alternative billing/donation options :)
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by dRother on Friday September 10, 2010 @11:29AM (#1679136)
It's not 'virtual' money. We're not talking tokens here, this is actual money.
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by Alex3917 on Friday September 10, 2010 @08:46AM (#1678651)
Stories like this have been frequent for almost ten years now. I remember writing about this in 2005 and it was already old news by several years then.
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by hristov on Friday September 10, 2010 @10:12PM (#1680823)
The problem is credit cards. Credit cards are very un-secure and a credit card owner usually has a right to do a charge-back which means that a credit card processor has to get their money back, which means that every credit card processor puts in conditions in their contract that allow them to block your funds if they smell even a whiff of impropriety.
Re:Paypal is holding over 600,000 euros from the minecraft d... by jemfinch on Friday September 10, 2010 @03:37PM (#1679944)
> I'm curious to which extent this is legal. I'm pretty sure a bank isn't allowed to block access to your accounts without a formal request from a legal entity.

It's simple to explain: Paypal isn't a bank.