Re:C++17 Compiler Bug Hunt
by DoofusOfDeath on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:45PM
(#16776718)
You're post nicely summarizes the dual nature of the evolution fo the C++ standard: it gets more complex in certain ways, so the language hopefully gets simpler in other ways.
In think the GP was correct in pointing out that the ways in which the language is getting more complex is a problem for implementations of the compiler and/or the standard C++ library.
You may be correct that the GP was unfairly calling the committee "eager" to make the language more complex. But perhaps we can agree that the language is becoming more complex, and that the complexity comes at a cost.
I think that's what bothers me about your comment; your phrasing "continually stuff more features into the language" implies a short-sightedness, but if you actually follow the work of the committee you can see that the thinking all the way from when it was C++0x to now maintains a long-term view.