Re:Tesla crash in September showed similarities to fatal Mou...
by Dylan16807 on Friday April 06, 2018 @04:18AM
(#16771770)
> Saying it's easy is effectively saying that the hundreds of very intelligent engineers working on these systems are idiots because it looks like it should be a piece of cake.
Saying one very very specific thing is easy is not the same as calling engineers idiots. It's bad to conflate "the system is hard" with "every single piece of the system is hard"
> The driving system has to combine this with other sources of information for it to be useful, and that's where problems creep in.
There are many places where integrating information can let errors creep in.
The car adding its own ground velocity in is just... not one of them.
> What I'm trying to say is that there are a number of fuzzy steps to get from sensor readings to actual object detected, and then from actual object detected to "known obstacle" classification, as you put it.
Agreed. But while some steps are fuzzy, some are easy. The chain from start to finish is fragile and difficult. But some of the individual links are rock-solid.
> I'm going to add this to my longer article writing list. Thank you for the constructive debate on this.
I'm not sure if we really got anywhere productive here, but good luck!
Saying one very very specific thing is easy is not the same as calling engineers idiots. It's bad to conflate "the system is hard" with "every single piece of the system is hard"
> The driving system has to combine this with other sources of information for it to be useful, and that's where problems creep in.
There are many places where integrating information can let errors creep in.
The car adding its own ground velocity in is just... not one of them.
> What I'm trying to say is that there are a number of fuzzy steps to get from sensor readings to actual object detected, and then from actual object detected to "known obstacle" classification, as you put it.
Agreed. But while some steps are fuzzy, some are easy. The chain from start to finish is fragile and difficult. But some of the individual links are rock-solid.
> I'm going to add this to my longer article writing list. Thank you for the constructive debate on this.
I'm not sure if we really got anywhere productive here, but good luck!