I don't mean to question CloudFlare's integrity.
It's just that, for claims about privacy, I'd rather depend on more than trusting any one party.
Because these sorts of comments read to me as "yeah, you're the best right now, but are you perfect? No.". Nobody claimed perfection, and there's value in being the best.
But I never depend on any one of them. I use nested chains. That's my no means perfect, because routes are relatively static, unlike Tor with its frequently changing circuits. But the basic idea is the same. Compromise would depend on collusion, perhaps forced, of multiple parties. Or some serious traffic analysis.
Here, there's CloudFlare, its auditors, and perhaps Google. So maybe there is distributed trust in that. But still, I'm happier to put more independent parties between me and them. Tor, or at least a nested VPN chain.
This is relevant as the CEO has previously woken up one morning after a troublesome sleep and it has been argued, gone against his word (for good and anti nazi reasons). Many argue that he was entirely within his right to do so, and he was! So in this case, would he be entirely within his right to start monitoring all that data. As he asks, paraphrasing: "what more can I do to ensure my word is good."
Or are you arguing that even Cloudflare couldn't get raw DNS traffic?