News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by tptacek on Thursday September 09, 2010 @02:58PM (#1676454)
No, it's not a "free speech issue" because you have no right under the Constitution to post whatever you'd like on Rackspace's private property, and the contract you enter into to post anything there specifically enjoins you from posting "harassing" or "hate" speech.

Sorry to be pedantic, but people have weird ideas about what the 1st Amendment actually means. "Congress shall make no law" does not mean "Rackspace shall make no rule".

Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by rbanffy on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:06PM (#1676484)
In other words, you have no free speech on the internet because all the routers, wires, servers, links, modems are the property of their owners and they are free to censor whatever you post as long as they have sufficiently ambiguous clauses on their contracts that may or may not involve you as a part.

How far can you bend your constitution before it breaks?

Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by NateLawson on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:25PM (#1676557)
You have a good point that a private monopoly can ultimately limit public rights like free speech. If there's no alternative provider that is willing to host hate speech, you can't broadcast it in that form.

I can think of three ways to provide for that:

1. Public servers, possibly sponsored by the govt

2. Regulation of Internet access run by private companies

3. Waiting for private competition to create such a space

The first one worked well in the early days of the Internet. There were lots of rules against commercial use of publicly-funded computers but little content regulation. Despite what some may think about the govt, it has lost most times it has attempted to limit free speech.

Regulation sort of works for railroads and telecom lines. Bell gets a monopoly on wiring but they have to provide access to disabled people, can't do discriminatory pricing, etc.

The last one is least likely to succeed. I don't know of any private US company that advertises themselves as "no takedown unless required by court order". It seems there is little profit advantage in marginalized speech compared to the cost of defending against attacks on it.

While it's good to see Ipredator and BayImg providing services with this kind of guarantee, the fact that such an effort only seems possible in Sweden should give us pause.

Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by devicenull on Thursday September 09, 2010 @09:24PM (#1677556)
https://www.nearlyfreespeech.net/ is one I can think of.
Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by ax0n on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:17PM (#1676520)
You aren't contractually bound when you use bizarre routers and wires, but your ISP probably holds you to a similar agreement. Also, you can do whatever you want until you get shut down, but a court of law will see it from the contract side. You can feel free to say whatever you want using your own resources, but if you're using someone else's and they don't like what you're doing, then tough shit.
Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by tptacek on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:16PM (#1676517)
I demand the immediate use of your HN account to make fun of your understanding how how our Constitution works. Free speech.
Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by rbanffy on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:56PM (#1676685)
You have your own HN account and I will do nothing to prevent you from poking fun of whatever you want.
Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by TWAndrews on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:46PM (#1676654)
Well, yes. One of the great things about the internet is that its regulation, as compared to other industries is relatively light. The flip side of that is that the government has little or no legal basis to ensure that people have a platform from which to speak.
Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by Andrew_Quentin on Friday September 10, 2010 @09:29AM (#1678751)
Supposing it was New York Time, sure something quite unimaginable, but supposing this web host decides to terminate their contract and no other host in the country would provide them with a hosting service, would that be an infringement of freedom of speech?

Perhaps if we view it from the perspective of the black letter of the law, that is the constitution, the highest law of that country, it might not be an infringement. However freedom of speech goes beyond the constitution, it is a principle ingrained in our society and culture.

To address your differences between private and public, a newspaper of course has no obligation to give him space in their platform, nor the television, but the internet is different. The former two are selective, the internet is free for all. If private bodies are able to go around policing the kind of content that is to be found on the net, the difference between them and the government is a mere technicality.

Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by greenlblue on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:32PM (#1676591)
As good citizens of a country Rackspace personnel also abide by certain rules and one of those is abiding by the laws of the land. The US constitution is pretty explicit about limiting expression and free speech so I can see how it could be argued that this is a free speech issue but that was not the point I was making.
Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by strlen on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:36PM (#1676608)
> As good citizens of a country Rackspace personnel also abide by certain rules and one of those is abiding by the laws of the land.

The law of the land very explicitly says "Congress shall make no law restricting..." not "Rackspace shall shut down no website".

Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by greenlblue on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:42PM (#1676631)
This is why people make a distinction between the spirit and the letter of the law. The point is that congress represents the people and if every private citizen starts censoring everything on their property well then technically congress is not limiting or restricting anything but you are left with a society that is devoid of any free speech.
Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by strlen on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:48PM (#1676657)
> spirit of the law

The spirit of the law, in the sense of what writers of the constitution intended is a lot more limited: not only did they specifically not want it applying to private property, they didn't even mean to apply it to states; several states had established churches. Fourteenth amendment incorporation is why is why the first amendment applies to state and local governments, as well as federal government. Some amendments e.g., second (The Right to Bear Arms) weren't incorporated until recently.

> but you are left with a society that is devoid of any free speech

You have your property, on which you can practice free speech. Find another managed host, colocate at a datacenter yourself or get a DSL line with a static IP. There's also public property: universities, libraries, public squares.

Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by greenlblue on Thursday September 09, 2010 @04:20PM (#1676774)
They also didn't anticipate various mediums of expression being supported by very few individuals and even as a private owner of something you are still going to deal with other people using whatever you own to express themselves in some fashion and if the government chooses not to limit speech on collective property then as a good citizen you should do your best to emulate the states best practices because after all those servers are powered by some kind of electric power plant that is supported by the people that are participating in the collective political process. Anyway my point was not whether this should be framed in terms of free speech and how a group of fear mongering, hateful, hypocritical xenophobes were having their first amendment rights curtailed but that Rackspace did the right thing by knocking them down a few pegs.
Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by tptacek on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:34PM (#1676599)
"When operating a communications service, you must provide equal access to all views" is not one of the laws of the land. It isn't even a law that governs network television stations, and they run on spectrum borrowed from the people.
Re:Rackspace Shuts Down Koran-Burning Web Site by strlen on Thursday September 09, 2010 @03:39PM (#1676623)
To be pedantic, according to Supreme Court, states can pass laws that extend the freedom of speech onto private property; some states e.g., California do so, but they target de-facto public spaces such as shopping centres, not servers in a rack:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruneyard_Shopping_Center_v._Ro...