News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by azernik on Thursday April 05, 2018 @08:36AM (#16764252)
In context, they clearly are referring to the municipal government when they say the city shouldn't exist, not to the physical collection of people and infrastructure.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by EarthIsHome on Thursday April 05, 2018 @08:40AM (#16764284)
All the services they say they want are provided by the municipal government. How are they going to provide all the services of the government without the government?
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by dbingham on Thursday April 05, 2018 @08:56AM (#16764417)
That is always the question asked. They would argue that things could be voluntarily self organized, instead of structured in coercive heirarchies.

In other words, they would say that people who are capable of being doctors should provide medical care, and organize themselves in a way to make sure that care gets provided sensibly. When potholes need fixing the community should meet and figure out how to get it done. They believe we can do all of these things with out needing an organized state that gets to dictate anything, money to incentivize, or police as coercive enforcement.

I'm sure I'm butchering it a bit. It might not be quite that simple, but it's along those lines.

And yes, it's idealistic as hell. That said, I know a lot of anarchist activists and damn, do those guys know how to get shit done.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by eeZah7Ux on Thursday April 05, 2018 @09:44AM (#16764822)
> And yes, it's idealistic as hell.

Not really. In countless rural societies, throughout the world and through history, it's been commonplace for people to help each other with building their homes, making dirt roads and small bridges, making food and many other tasks - without charging each other for money or bartering.

Essentially a small village can work much like a very large family and people would use money almost only when interacting with strangers in a different village.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by PeterisP on Thursday April 05, 2018 @07:24PM (#16769675)
Sure, there are a lot of social processes that work in smallish communes where people mostly know each other. But that doesn't scale - the relationships break down above the Dunbar limit and become substantially different as you don't even know most of the people. The processes and motivation that work in a 50 people community will not work the same way in a 5000 people community; in the first case people might behave as if they're all a big family with shared interests, in the latter case they will not.

The fact that X works in a small village should not be considered as evidence that X would plausibly work in a mid-sized town. For homo sapiens and groups of them, scale matters a lot.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by tonyedgecombe on Saturday April 07, 2018 @06:42AM (#16780203)
I'm not sure it's that great in a group of fifty, you would have real problems if you stand out in some way or aren't particularly useful.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by lifeformed on Thursday April 05, 2018 @06:43PM (#16769450)
That can work for small communities, but you wouldn't ever be able to accomplish large scale tasks with that limited scale of organization. And not just big buildings and bridges (which one could argue are unnecessary), but projects like research in medicine and agriculture which benefit everyone, but require a large centralization of resources, leadership, and lots of time to create. That doesn't seem like something that could emerge from a anarchist society.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by eeZah7Ux on Friday April 06, 2018 @09:14AM (#16772912)
> you wouldn't ever be able to accomplish large scale tasks

I never said that model is meant to be applied at large scale.

> projects like research in medicine

You could have chosen an example like building a dam. In many countries academia works in a highly decentralized fashion and is less money-driven than other fields. Also see FLOSS.

> doesn't seem like something that could emerge from a anarchist society

Not from a handful of individuals. However anarchism does not reject large and complex organizations (on the contrary):

https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Anarchist_FAQ/Why_do_anarchist...

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by hermitdev on Thursday April 05, 2018 @09:59PM (#16770358)
> ... and bridges (which one could argue are unnecessary)

I'm pretty sure you're referring to the Bridge to Nowhere [1] here (~$400M), but one could argue for a number of public works projects that are unnecessary, stupid, or the cause of recurring large expenditures.

Chicago, built on a swamp, still constantly has flooding issues. The Deep Tunnel project [2] is currently at > $4B, and still can't handle a relatively common spring storm without dumping sewage into either Lake Michigan or the Illinois-Michigan Sanitation Canal. Not to mention the other regional estuaries that get polluted by overflows such as the Des Plaines River or the Salt Creek (which just happens to run by the Chicago area's premier zoo: Brookfield).

Also, Washington DC, also built on a swamp (literal, not the figurative "drain the swamp"). Not sure what measures the city takes to prevent/handle flooding. Also potential hurricane target.

New Orleans, built below sea level...right next to the sea, and also a prime target for hurricanes, the worst in recent memory being Katrina. Response to that? Rebuild. Should have been relocate. First search from Google I found says costs from the recovery on that were ~$108B [3] (I don't know the accuracy of this - first time I've ever visited the site). I don't know how much the Army Corps of Engineers has spent rebuilding the dikes & levies that failed after Katrina, but I'd put money down that it is far beyond the $400M spent on the "Bridge to Nowhere".

Point is, the Federal government is there to help all citizens, those in small & large communities/cities alike. Infrastructure projects cost money, period. They're actually cheaper in rural areas due to cheaper local labor, sometimes material, and usually (but not always) less corruption and cronyism (road repairs around Chicago are generally of very poor quality, do not last long and are poorly planned - e.g. in Cook County, a road will often be repaired one week, and then promptly torn up the next to replace a sewer/water/gas main).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravina_Island_Bridge [2] http://www.encyclopedia.chicagohistory.org/pages/367.html [3] https://www.thebalance.com/hurricane-katrina-facts-damage-an...

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by jschwartzi on Thursday April 05, 2018 @09:28AM (#16764685)
The rub is that your need leaders in the sense of initiating things, but that you're without an organized class of people who are paid to lead.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by dbingham on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:02AM (#16772306)
You actually don't need leaders. I've been part of plenty of leaderless flat heirarchies that self organized pretty damned well. People just stepped up to do things that needed doing. The problem isn't that people can't function with out leaders. The issue is more that, those sorts of flat heirarchies don't tend to scale well.

But that doesn't necessarily mean they couldn't, if we put some effort and education into training people how to operate in them better. I'm less skeptical of the idea that we could operate in self organized non-heirarchies than I am of the idea that would could do away with the money and all formal organizations.

The idea that we could do everything by informal agreement just seems really unstable to me. Like you'd never quite know what the rules were and like they could change at any moment.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday April 05, 2018 @07:47PM (#16769812)
> When potholes need fixing the community should meet and figure out how to get it done.

OK.

> They believe we can do all of these things with out needing an organized state

Well, see, we met and decided that that's how we're going to get things done. It happens at the time a town decides to incorporate. How does it decide to do that? Usually by a referendum passing among the town's voters.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by icebraining on Thursday April 05, 2018 @08:58AM (#16764438)
They are provided by the government now, but do they have to be? An anarchist would say "no".

Much as been written about the organization of anti-capitalist anarchist societies. One work on that is An Anarchist FAQ[1], but beware that like any other political group - an especially on the left - there will certainly be other anarchists decrying that text as nonsense and false anarchism and such.

[1] https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/the-anarchist-faq-ed...

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by wz1000 on Thursday April 05, 2018 @08:56AM (#16764419)
From the article:

“There can be no ethical services provided by the government because they are facilitated through the power of the gun,” writes PARC, presumably while flipping the bird like in the top photo. “Don’t get us wrong, we believe that many of these services are crucial for society, like healthcare, education, and maintained roadways, but we believe that the way to achieve access for all is by deconstructing the state and capitalism, as well as other coercive hierarchies that exist in our society. It is this driving philosophy that motivates our actions, not only to fix the potholes, but to take power back from the state, into the hands of the people.”

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by nailer on Thursday April 05, 2018 @09:22AM (#16764623)
> facilitated through the power of the gun

Fascinating, seeing as many people's experience of self-identified 'anarchism' is through the power of the fist.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by icebraining on Thursday April 05, 2018 @09:33AM (#16764735)
Isn't using your fists just self-defense when someone is pointing a gun at you?
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by nailer on Thursday April 05, 2018 @11:50AM (#16765993)
Sure, but in most cases anarchism is 'bash the fash' with 'fascist' being defined as 'anyone we don't like' including unarmed people. Fists or makeshift weapons are typically used as they can't be traced.

It's odd: anarchists openly justify violence in defense from 'fascism', whereas fascism is correctly defined as obtaining and maintaining power through violence, without seeing the irony.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by icebraining on Thursday April 05, 2018 @01:10PM (#16766761)
Are you sure it's "most cases", or just the ones you hear about in the news? How many do you know personally? Beware of the availability bias.

As an anecdote, I live near a left-wing anarchist group called the Center of Libertarian Culture, and I can assure you they're all pacific people.

It's odd: anarchists openly justify violence in defense from 'fascism', whereas fascism is correctly defined as obtaining and maintaining power through violence, without seeing the irony.

There's no irony; anarchists don't want to obtain and maintain power, just to prevent others from doing so.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by nailer on Thursday April 05, 2018 @03:39PM (#16768231)
I know a couple, from tech, who are anarchists: I'm friends with one of them despite them being very damaged people. Both are openly violent towards anyone right of Bernie Sanders and one other told me, with a serious face, they wanted to stab everyone in the pool at a tech conference I attended.

By beating the shit out of people you're obtaining power for yourself. Modern anarchism is fascism, masking itself as the opposite.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by mdpopescu on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:44AM (#16771391)
Not all people calling themselves anarchists (or Christians, or Muslims, or intellectuals, or X for any value of X) are actually X.

Sure, "no true Scotsman", but still; what you're describing is indeed fascism, it has nothing to do with any principles of anarchism I'm aware of.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by nailer on Friday April 06, 2018 @06:42AM (#16772236)
Yes, I know. Hence explicitly mentioning 'self described anarchists' in the thread. The people in the article are also self described anarchists. You're arguing very successfully against a straw man.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by icebraining on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:17AM (#16771280)
Why do you think that couple is representative of the whole (or even most) anarchists today?
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by nailer on Friday April 06, 2018 @09:11AM (#16772891)
Because every anarchist I've known personally, met online, or read about shares their same ideals of moral superiority through violence.

Saying 'violent thugs don't represent the original priciples of anarchism' is missing the point, in the same way that people who say 'real communism hasn't been tried' and ignore the 100M dead people.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by perl4ever on Friday April 06, 2018 @11:43AM (#16774091)
All of the anarchists I've ever known have been mild mannered geeks and academics.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by nailer on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:27PM (#16775186)
Some of those academics smash people's skulls with bike locks. People who are mild mannered often enjoy violence when they think they can't be identified.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by perl4ever on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:52PM (#16776792)
That is an interesting assertion, but I don't think it is a good way of convincing people to see things your way. The more I hear the message that anarchists and anti-fascists are the real fascists, the less receptive I am to the viewpoint. It's similar to the repetitive promotion of the idea that civil rights activists are the real racists. There is the message you are sending with the argument itself, and then there is the meta-message you are sending by making the argument. The former can be fairly logical, and yet be undermined by the latter.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by nailer on Saturday April 07, 2018 @03:53AM (#16779850)
1. People who use violence to obtain power are fascists. All fascists suck, whether left or right. The only person saying right wing fascists aren't real fascists is you, while making a very poor straw man argument.

2. Civil rights activists aren't primarily known for violence. Anarchists are.

3. Saying their actions have nothing to do with the principles of fascism is like staring at a wall of human skulls in Cambodia and saying this has nothing to do with the principles of socialism: you're missing the point.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by dragonwriter on Saturday April 07, 2018 @04:20AM (#16779907)
> People who use violence to obtain power are fascists.

So, the American Revolutionaries were fascists?

Fascists, even in the lose sense theat doesn't refer tons particular historical Italian political group, are a much narrower label.

> All fascists suck, whether left or right.

There are left wing tyrants (tyrants, while broader than fascists, are still narrower than you have attempted to paint fascists), but they aren't fascists.

But anarchists aren't that, either (some of the subelements of the antifa movement, particularly the Maoist ones, might be inclined in theat direction, but Maoists and anarchists, even anarchocommunists, aren't the same thing.)

> Civil rights activists aren't primarily known for violence. Anarchists are.

During the period of major activity, most anti-estsblishment groups are tarred with the violence of their most extreme subcomponents (which may actually be provocateurs) or even the most extreme groups with similar objections, even if they are outside the main group. This was absolutely the case with the civil rights movement.

> Saying their actions have nothing to do with the principles of fascism

They have nothing to do with the defining characteristics of fascism, either. The only association is that fascism is broadly accepted as a negative label and you wish to brand anarchists negatively.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by nailer on Saturday April 07, 2018 @08:27AM (#16780442)
People are defined by their actions not by their own propaganda.

Civil rights activists fight against power systems, revolutionaries fought for representation: anarchists are violent thugs who pretend to be activists to justify violence towards anyone who doesn't share their ideology.

Understanding the obvious discrepancy between the words of anarchists and their actions is important part of being politically mature.

Anarchists already have a negative label: edgy people who pretend to be brave by wearing a mask and beating people / phone boxes because there's something wrong in their lives. If you don't believe that fine, trying to convince you of anything would be like trying to convince any other (moon landing / flat earth / building 7) conspiracy theorist. Enjoy your early twenties.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by perl4ever on Saturday April 14, 2018 @08:01AM (#16836960)
I think that when you draw a distinction between civil rights activists and anarchists, you are using hindsight. These days everybody claims MLK was a peaceful giant who was on their side all along. Republicans say he was a Republican, libertarians say he was a libertarian, anarchists say he was an anarchist, etc. But before he had become a safe historical figure, he was held responsible for violence and very seriously accused of being a communist/anarchist by those in the government and on the right who thought those categories were the worst thing possible to be. So one must be skeptical of such name calling today.

Left of center people attack libertarians these days using parallel rhetoric, identifying them as equivalent to the worst right wing types and responsible for everything about capitalism that can be criticized (e.g. the body count from everything bad). Are you on the same page, or do you reject that as invalid nonsense? Do you agree libertarians are fascists too?

Have you ever noticed how ubiquitous the fasces is in Washington, DC, on statues (e.g. Lincoln) and things? That doesn't make our government fascist to be sure, but it's about as good an argument as the one you are making about other people.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by marnett on Thursday April 05, 2018 @06:44PM (#16769454)
this is a gross misrepresentation of quite a well defined school of thought.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by nailer on Thursday April 05, 2018 @07:25PM (#16769684)
Not discussing the school of thought, just self defined anarchists, as mentioned in the post.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by hermitdev on Thursday April 05, 2018 @10:02PM (#16770367)
I don't think it's a misrepresentation at all, especially if you consider the anti-Fa movement. anti-Fa is ironically using very fascist tactics in their protest of fascism.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by icebraining on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:12AM (#16771255)
That's what I was thinking when I said "beware of the news bias". Regardless of what one thinks of specific actions of the Antifa movement, it's not necessarily true that those represent even Antifa members as a whole, and it's completely specious to assume they represent anarchists as a whole. Antifa is not even an anarchist-only movement.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by thechao on Thursday April 05, 2018 @08:54AM (#16764401)
All the anarchists I’ve met think citizens will spontaneously combust^W form committees, chosen by their peers using the Australian method, and those committees will cause work to happen by raising funds from interested peers. Like Mad Max, but with smiles.
Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by logfromblammo on Thursday April 05, 2018 @10:52AM (#16765417)
Committees in anarchism are more like the PTA, band boosters, rotary club, or your HOA--everything that has no statutory authority, and no power to tax. They form whenever someone thinks it might be even worse to not have one, everyone hates attending the meetings, and they are almost entirely dependent on one to five people devoting too much of their own energy to holding it all together. There might be a contract in place, and it might mandate that dues be paid.

In lieu of mandatory dues, they will always be strapped for cash and either begging for donations or coming up with annoying fundraiser ideas. They might fork, and one or both parts of the fork will fail, because some of the critical support went to the other part of the fork.

And some of them will actually be more like organized crime families or street gangs than the PTA.

In other words, anarchy is happening right now, and you can see how it works right now. A bunch of crazies devoted to renegade pothole repair is a perfect example. They come together because of potholes. They fix potholes. People pay attention to them as long as they care about potholes. When the pothole problem is fixed, everyone forgets they ever existed, then stop paying attention and giving money. They either drift away to find something else to do, or become the lonely, ignored crusaders against potholes that people remember hearing about that one time, but had no idea they were still around and still fixing potholes.

It doesn't scale, though. Anarchy can only exist at the local level because governments tackle many of the big problems and force people to pay for the solutions with taxes. Imagine if your city government operated like the mafia (Chicago!), or if your state government operated like a giant PTA meeting. It might get as far as agreeing to set a budget of $500 for the spring graduation party before removing someone from the gallery for shouting about invading foreign armies, and would still be answering stupid questions about the dress code for service dogs when the soldiers started dragging everyone out.

Mr. Humungus (a reasonable feller) is president of the Juicetakers Committee, Toecutter vice president, Feral Kid as secretary, Gyropilot as treasurer, and someone that looks exactly like your Mom covered in warpaint as the member-at-large. The president has advanced a proposal that you just walk away and give us your juice. We took a vote, and it passed unanimously. We are also selling cookie dough as part of our fall fundraiser. So give us the juice, and please buy some cookies on your way out into the desert.

I'd prefer it if they were shooting guns at me.

Re:Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (... by Zak on Thursday April 05, 2018 @09:00AM (#16764450)
They are currently providing one of the services that the municipal government is expected to provide. Presumably, they would like to expand that and provide the rest using the same volunteer model.