Re:The Worst U.S. Maritime Disaster in Decades
by cloakandswagger on Thursday April 05, 2018 @09:51AM
(#16764870)
In this case the blame is deserved though. The Coast Guard's report places the blame fully on the captain.
Re:The Worst U.S. Maritime Disaster in Decades
by blub on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:09AM
(#16771243)
I don't believe it does place the blame fully on the captain, where did you see that?
The report conclusions mention several events and dozens of contributing factors.
If you want to think in terms of blame, which is not helpful to avoid future accidents nor for nurturing a safety culture, the report "blames" the ship owner, captain, crew, National Hurricane Center and the coast guard...
Some actions of the captain were a contributing factor, notably bridge resource management/communication.
Re:The Worst U.S. Maritime Disaster in Decades
by cloakandswagger on Friday April 06, 2018 @11:36AM
(#16774035)
"Coast Guard investigators virtually placed all of the blame on Michael Davidson, the El Faro's captain. Davidson underestimated the strength of the storm and the ship's ability to ride it out. He did not take enough measures to evade the storm, even though most of his crew raised concerns about the increase in strength of the storm. Investigators had stated that if Davidson had survived the storm, his actions would have been grounds for the Coast Guard to revoke his captain's license."
The article probably emphasises the captain's safety consciousnes to prevent people from "blaming the operator", which is an instinctual and often wrong conclusion to jump to.
The NTSB report says: Performance. The chief mate's performance evaluations were consistently positive. His evaluation from June 2015 stated that he was “passionate” about his work and “an excellent instructor for the inexperienced.”