Re:Improved Docker Container Integration with Java 10
by danudey on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:14PM
(#16756799)
> they can run it so long as they have the right JVM installed
This is the key. The right JVM, the right classpaths, the right configuration, the right permissions, the right native libraries.
The setup process for every Java app we've used (thankfully just ActiveMQ and Kafka lately) have been incredibly complicated. JAR files in paths, long, convoluted shell scripts to set up all possible variables for every possible JVM, wrappers that wrap launchers, etc.
And then all of those steps are prone to breakage and are difficult to debug.
Shipping a Docker container lets you say "Here is a working environment that needs no configuration and won't suddenly fail until reconfigured when another app you have needs Java 9 and not Java 8".
Re:Improved Docker Container Integration with Java 10
by javier2 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:06PM
(#16757308)
This. Going from java 5 to java 5+n with everything have to use the same JVM, shared on a computer was a nightmare in my large organization.
Re:Improved Docker Container Integration with Java 10
by michaelcampbell on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:31PM
(#16759891)
Yes, when I tell people to start looking at Docker as an "complete application packaging" solution (vs a VM), the light seems to go on for most.
Re:Improved Docker Container Integration with Java 10
by lostmsu on Thursday April 05, 2018 @02:04PM
(#16767329)
Wait until you get to Docker 5 -> Docker 6. I bet it will turn into Java basically.
Re:Improved Docker Container Integration with Java 10
by ivan_gammel on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @04:27PM
(#16758693)
"Right Docker install" - I agree, there will be that problem at some point. But containers are not just some extra layer: they do not solve the same problem as fat jar. JARs are used for the distribution of the code and related assets. With containers you can distribute and isolate the deployment configuration: you can run multiple applications on the same physical server and not worry about conflicts due to different versions of JRE or system libraries. Vulnerability in one app will not affect another one. Security patches and system updates may be tested in isolation in a single container, before propagating the change (in the form of a common base image) to others. And, of course, it's just very convenient to run the whole Linux-based production cluster or test load balancing on your work laptop with Windows. :)
I like docker and use it, but it's not for everything everywhere and is overly-hyped IMO.