News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by jacquesm on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:02AM (#16735030)
> I'm a co-founder of https://snips.ai and we are building a 100% on-device and private-by-design platform to build Voice AI assistants

Excellent! How will you guarantee that your devices will not leak data?

Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by oulipo on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:07AM (#16735093)
We are open-sourcing the code, and people can have their own network monitoring to see that there is no data leaking
Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by jacquesm on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:11AM (#16735145)
Please check into 'reproducible builds' and ways to ensure the software is not modified between the point where you build it and the point where it gets deployed. There will most likely at some point be an attempt to use your reputation to achieve the exact opposite of your stated goals so beware of that.
Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by oulipo on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:17AM (#16735217)
We'd love to hear more about what you think of this, perhaps you can contact me [email protected] and I would love to do a Skype with you, if only because I read quite a few of your posts over the year and am curious to know you.

We are providing the source, and people can rebuild it from scratch and ensure that their device is running the open-source code. In theory, it is each user who should deploy his device. If an industrial partners want to ship our software to many devices, indeed it will be needed for them to prove he hasn't modified the software and we are happy to learn about best practices to help them do so, so we will look at this

Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by jacquesm on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:48AM (#16735586)
I'm sorry, I don't do skype or hangouts but I'll be happy to email with you. However, it is probably better if you find someone who is really an expert in the field. But I can definitely see that there is a potential problem here if you are open sourcing your code and industrial partners ship your software without some kind of clear way in which you can ascertain that what got shipped is what you intended and not some kind of perverted variation.

This might be a good starting point:

https://reproducible-builds.org/

Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by ryandrake on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:54AM (#16735661)
> If an industrial partners want to ship our software to many devices, indeed it will be needed for them to prove he hasn't modified the software and we are happy to learn about best practices to help them do so, so we will look at this

Yea, as a privacy conscious user this would be the attack vector that I’d be most nervous about. “Partners” taking the open source engine and loading it up with surveillance. Being able to re-compile and deploy a vanilla version from source is critical. There are a lot of “smart” devices out there that I would buy if only I had root and/or could decide what software ran on it.

Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by craftyguy on Monday April 02, 2018 @12:12PM (#16735857)
Will the device have any components in it which require proprietary firmware? Think long and hard about that before answering.

edit: I thought you were also doing something similar to Mycroft and their 'mark 1' thing. I was wrong.

Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by oulipo on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:03PM (#16736484)
Our platform doesn't require any specific component.

It will be open-source and free for all users to use and create assistants.

If an industrial device maker wants to use the open-source version and add to it proprietary components, it will be his decision and he should inform his customers.

The best we can do when building and open-sourcing our assistant platform is to make it possible for commercial vendors to create state-of-the-art private-by-design voice assistants if they want

Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by entropie on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:27PM (#16736780)
I spent like 60 seconds on your page trying to figure out what exactly you do and failed. Just saying.

Put some of the information of your posts here on your page and things would be much clearer.

Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by craftyguy on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:13PM (#16736608)
So no components in your device (e.g. for wifi) require proprietary firmware to function? Are you sure about that?
Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by jacquesm on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:14PM (#16736618)
They make software, not hardware, they could not make such a guarantee.
Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by craftyguy on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:34PM (#16736861)
Ah, I didn't realize that. I thought they were trying to do something like Mycroft with the Mark 1. Mycroft releases their platform to be installed on other devices, but they also make their own (Mark 1).
Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by josefresco on Monday April 02, 2018 @12:12PM (#16735849)
"and people can have their own network monitoring"

Is this monitoring built into your product? If not, wouldn't a user of any AI assistant have this same ability?

Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by dwighttk on Monday April 02, 2018 @12:55PM (#16736377)
The monitoring is to see if the product is making network connections, you can do that with any AI assistant, yes, but the Google and Amazon products are going to require you to allow them to make those connections. This claim is that you can see that this product isn't making connections. (I think)
Re:Hey, Alexa, What Can You Hear? And What Will You Do With It? by oulipo on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:04PM (#16736490)
You can use a tool like `mitmproxy` to monitor the network requests