Edit: You edited your reply after I started. I think abstinence works fine for something like nicotine. Unlike say sex humans don't have any innate craving for nicotine, I've never consumed it in my entire life and I don't feel like I've missed out on anything.
Btw, do you know if schools in the U.S. sell sweets? (My school used to have a 'tuck shop' for this purpose).
The success rate of quitting is really up to the individual, much like weight loss or other self improvement stuff. But even if it's hard it's the thing you should do.
I'm really not sure what you're arguing. "Quitting is hard and a lot of people fail so .. don't quit." That's some lame mentality right there.
No, I asked: what should vaping be replaced with?
If they're not smoking you don't want them to start vaping.
Obviously the goal is "not inhaling things that aren't air".
Do you mean nicotine gum? Isn't that bad for your gums? Or do you mean plain chewing gum?
Ultimately, all cessation methods are aiming to require 0 nicotine at their conclusion. As for the "best thing" to do when trying to quit, financial loss seems to be a good incentive. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1414293
If it were, then nobody would start smoking.
This is like saying the rhythm method has a 100% success rate. It's only true if you do it perfectly. Nobody does.