In no particular order I was...
- Only picked up an hour late because a different cabbie stopped by the shop I was in front of to shop and took me home after he got his groceries.
- Picked up by a cab that had been in an accident earlier and the steering was in some way totally screwed in a fashion that made the car veer to the side unpredictably when it hit a bump. I thought at first he was blind drunk until he showed me that it took a quarter turn of the wheel to make the wheels turn at all.
- Picked up by a cabbie that was showing his little brother how to maximize revenue by picking up and dropping off as many people as possible along an optimal route while talking about his time in prison along with a colorful story about his friend smuggling cigarettes in his rectum. Kudos for entrepreneurial know how but the trip took waaaay longer than it should have because 5 different people going different places were in the car.
There was one outfit that was technically non compliant after the county I worked in in decided that county specific taxi regulation including requiring outfits to paint their cars was actually going to be a thing. These were the only people that showed up in a reasonable time, provided good service, and actually took a damn card in the cab. They also used to violate the law by dropping me off in the half assed county where I worked.
So long Mr P's taxi and thanks for all the rides.
The regulations that don't keep taxis from ripping people off or threatening their safety but DO ensure that the "investors" in taxi medallions earn some money can collectively burn in the pits of hell.
On the other hand I can get a new, clean, well-maintained and current-year car to myself for an entire day from a rental company for a 25% premium (inclusive of all the taxes and fees) on the cost of a round-trip Lyft between my home and my commute train station. When my family travels the weekly rate on such a vehicle is only about the equivalent of 7-8 such round-trips. That's an incredible value, in my view.
Rentals still come out ahead sometimes, which is why it's great we have both options.
Give someone a ride, let them borrow your car, let them stay over at your house while they're on vacatin, have a one night stand with them. Nobody thinks we need government regulations for this stuff. What is it about commerce that scares us so much?
The things you described are usually just one off things, that a friend will occasionally do for another friend. Once you commercialize it, then it starts getting abused. Take AirBnB: You now have a lot of buildings becoming unofficial hotels. Not only are they driving out regular, long term tenants, but the people who are there did not sign up to live near a hotel.
Some of us will do our best to elect reps who will legislate services you like or something its just life.
Why not? From the perspective of society, they're doing the same thing. Thus the implementation detail of being centralized or not doesn't come in to play.
Speak for yourself.
Funny bit: we trust Uber's driver rating MORE than the fact that official taxi drivers are "pro" and comply with regulations i.e. the value of this regulation is negligible. So enterprise car rentals need to ask following question: where in the process of making money we forgot about delivering value to customers.