News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by RobertoG on Monday April 02, 2018 @06:04AM (#16733430)
It's a complicated issue, but it seems to me that, without tariffs, a good way to make profit, is to do arbitrage between the different prices of labour in different countries.

Tariffs make more expensive to invest abroad than locally and investment is the crucial part of growing an economy.

As consumers, the people of an importing country could win in the short term.

If you think that the economy is global and that it doesn't matter where the productive capacity is, then tariffs are a bad thing. Otherwise, if you are worried about unemployment and that your country could become only a "services" country, maybe tariffs make sense.

Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by evanpw on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:44AM (#16733761)
But US unemployment is at historic lows [1], and US manufacturing output is at historic highs, so why now? It's also notable that tariffs are one of the few policies that economists are almost in universal agreement about [3].

[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE [2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OUTMS [3] http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/steel-and-aluminum-tariffs

Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by Consultant32452 on Monday April 02, 2018 @09:12AM (#16734165)
>But US unemployment is at historic lows

Meanwhile the wealth gap is at historic highs. Increasing demand when supply is already low should bring up wages.

>It's also notable that tariffs are one of the few policies that economists are almost in universal agreement about [3].

Tariffs will not generally improve the welfare of Americans, removing the tariffs after our global competitors have ceased their own unfair trade practices, improved worker conditions, stop polluting so much, etc. may improve the welfare of everyone.

Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by evanpw on Monday April 02, 2018 @09:32AM (#16734291)
> Meanwhile the wealth gap is at historic highs. Increasing demand when supply is already low should bring up wages.

Tariffs are an extremely inefficient form of redistribution. If you want to fix the wealth gap, just make the pie as large as possible and redistribute directly.

> Tariffs will not generally improve the welfare of Americans, removing the tariffs after our global competitors have ceased their own unfair trade practices, improved worker conditions, stop polluting so much, etc. may improve the welfare of everyone.

I'm not sure what to make of this. It sounds like the plan is to make ourselves worse off in the hope that it also damages China? Most of the difference in labor practices comes from the fact that the US is much richer than China. It's unlikely that we can convince China to stop being poor by taxing ourselves.

Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by Consultant32452 on Monday April 02, 2018 @10:16AM (#16734629)
>Tariffs are an extremely inefficient form of redistribution. If you want to fix the wealth gap, just make the pie as large as possible and redistribute directly.

It's hard to make the pie as large as possible when your second largest trade partner isn't playing fair.

>I'm not sure what to make of this. It sounds like the plan is to make ourselves worse off in the hope that it also damages China? Most of the difference in labor practices comes from the fact that the US is much richer than China. It's unlikely that we can convince China to stop being poor by taxing ourselves.

China has weird rules that restrict foreign companies from doing business there, which is a defacto tariff on all US corporations who want to sell to China. There's a lot of other industry-specific ways in which China is not playing fair. Of course American corporations want to manufacture in China to avoid paying for an American standard of living. And I get that poor countries are going to have lower wages. But these people are working in factories where suicide nets are necessary. We can pressure them to do better. Then of course there's environmental concerns which we're increasingly aware are an international problem, not an localized one.

We can't enact law in China, but we can pressure them to make changes which are more fair to American competitors and healthier for the entire planet.

[dead]
Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by Consultant32452 on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:31AM (#16735384)
>Hey! Stop blaming other countries because your domestic system is so fucked up. That your politicians passed a 1.5 trillion dollar tax cut which will benefit mostly the wealthy, instead of increasing taxes and using them to fund education, healthcare and other social programs. There seems more than enough pie to keep everyone happy, but some Americans seem hell bent on keeping the benefits of a wealthy society away from the neediest of you.

What you said has nothing to do with whether we should be a doormat for China's unfair trade practices. If you're really concerned about the wellbeing of the poor I don't understand how, in this context, you could be more upset at American corporations than you are at Chinese corporations.

>This is a straw man argument, please don't rationalize these tariffs as something that were meant to do anything but to right an imagined wrong in the mind of an Insane POTUS who thinks the trade deficit is an indication that other countries are "cheating" the US.

I suspect you and I feel similarly about Trump. I don't have particularly strong feelings of support for these tariffs, but it's been clear to me since the 80s that we needed to fight back in the trade war China has been fighting against us since then. There aren't a lot of levers to pull here, there's tariffs, sanctions... I dunno what else. The biggest problem with these tariffs is the fact that it's unilateral. Stuff is fungible so it's stupid unless we can get the rest of the world to participate and push China to behave.

Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by pm90 on Monday April 02, 2018 @12:37PM (#16736162)
> What you said has nothing to do with whether we should be a doormat for China's unfair trade practices. If you're really concerned about the wellbeing of the poor I don't understand how, in this context, you could be more upset at American corporations than you are at Chinese corporations.

I thought the point you were making was that it is not possible to have enough resources ("pie") to benefit all Americans (rich and poor) unless the "unfair trade practices of China" were somehow reigned in. So it absolutely has everything to do with trade. If there is already more than enough wealth (which I argue there is) and the problem is one of unequal distribution of it, then trying to tweak trade seems like an suboptimal strategy.

> I suspect you and I feel similarly about Trump. I don't have particularly strong feelings of support for these tariffs, but it's been clear to me since the 80s that we needed to fight back in the trade war China has been fighting against us since then. There aren't a lot of levers to pull here, there's tariffs, sanctions... I dunno what else. The biggest problem with these tariffs is the fact that it's unilateral. Stuff is fungible so it's stupid unless we can get the rest of the world to participate and push China to behave.

China has made the jump from developing to developed in a shockingly short period of time. In the process, they have managed to mostly solve the problem of providing food to millions of Chinese and also providing a path to middle class for the same folks. I don't agree with authoritarianism and Chinese trade policies either; but to characterize that as a trade war is being much too hyperbolic. They are and always have been protectionist; every developing economy is. The reason previous US administrations didn't impose tariffs weren't because they weren't brave enough or never thought of them, its because the worldview was that once China made the transition to developed country, it would gradually loosen the protectionism as well.

And I don't think any country will join with the US on anything significant with this caustic and highly incompetent POTUS ripping up longtime diplomatic goodwill with allies and heaping praise on authoritarian rivals...

Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by soVeryTired on Monday April 02, 2018 @10:28AM (#16734735)
> It's also notable that tariffs are one of the few policies that economists are almost in universal agreement about [3].

Does anyone know of a good nuanced article or discussion on tariffs? The standard argument that I've seen is to invoke comparative advantage and call it a day. I've never really bought into that argument, so I'd love to see a less theoretical review of the effects that tariffs can have.

Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by mistermann on Monday April 02, 2018 @02:45PM (#16737821)
I'd also like to read a comprehensive non-partisan discussion on the matter. HN is one of the more intelligent forums I'm aware of, yet on certain topics like this, I assert that it is plagued by the same one dimensional, emotional, absolutist thinking we accuse others of on other topics.

I strongly believe, and constantly test this theory as I am reading the news and forum discussions, that if there is an aspect of gender, sexuality, race, culture, and probably a few others involved in a given scenario, there are very strong subconscious mental processes that interfere with the thought processes of otherwise very logical and perfectly well-intentioned people.

Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by DataWorker on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:22AM (#16735279)
What about the male labor force participation rate?
Re:China Slaps Tariffs on U.S. Products by 0x445442 on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:49AM (#16735615)
Also, what seems to be missing from the comments is the questioning of labor conditions.

What about working conditions in some of these countries the U.S. trades with? Is it all cool so long as we benefit from cheap labor?

Furthermore, there's an imbalance between capital and labor in terms of arbitrage opportunities. Capital can easily take advantage of labor arbitrage but labor is not mobile and thus, cannot take advantage of cost of living arbitrage.

I get the sense that most folks that support minimum wage increases don't really think much about the labor conditions of those making most of the stuff they consume.