I think the thinking is that Tariffs will be one way to keep China from abusing that. In any case I think the assumption you're making is that it hurts consumers because it destroys consumption of cheap foreign goods. But I think what you're missing is that it increases consumption of domestic goods made by domestic workers. Obviously analogies are bad for discussing the actual nuance of matters.. but think Walmart in a small town that funnels profits out of the local economy versus small town businesses generating and circulating wealth locally.
1.) http://www.businessinsider.com/r-senator-warren-in-beijing-s...
1. When a protectionist market is created, global companies generally tend to avoid competing in them. What this means is that the local companies producing the protected goods are generally one-market only. They're only interested in the protected market and know they're shielded from foreign competition... less competition == less incentive to make world class products. And new firms will not generally target the captive market created by regulation unless they know the regulations will stay that way for many decades to come.
2. If you can create regulations to keep foreign competitors out, you can also use regulations to keep domestic competitors out. This is a favorite strategy used by bigger corporations in countries with lax implementation of laws, but strict laws on paper. Just threaten smaller firms that they will be sued and take them over.
As an example making a PCB with a nominal impedance spec. A domestic company will take that to mean you want full testing and careful analysis. A foreign company will quickly rough out a stack up and send you the boards.
Because my impedance spec was nominal and not critical the foreign company is the correct approach.
Assembling iPhones in the US would mean more crappy domestic jobs paying near minimum wage. It would also make iPhones more expensive, not just for US consumers, but worldwide. So fewer iPhones are sold. Meaning fewer high paying design and engineering jobs at Apple, at app developers, etc. And more of those jobs in South Korea, at Samsung.
Free trade is a wonderful thing that makes everyone better off in the long run. A lawyer who fires his secretary to do his own typing because he can type faster than her is a fool.
If one of the participants has an absolutely massive population, a unified mono-culture known for being incredibly hard workers, doesn't lack any particular disadvantages, and is run my (what seems to be) and incredibly smart communist dictatorship, how do you guarantee that in one thread of possible outcomes that this dictatorship isn't able and willing to spread its wings to largely bring the entire planet under it's dictatorship. I'd hope you don't deny that the US as de facto world leader exercises a little global influence, if all the pieces fall into place and China with it's massive advantages over the US, how do you guarantee this outcome will not (and can not) come to pass?
A typical response to this question is that a free democracy always beats a dictatorship (this belief is so pervasive and unbending in the West, it's almost like a religion), but this is in no way whatsoever(!!!!!!!!!) guaranteed to always be true, in fact even with our incredibly small historic sample sizes, things were looking pretty iffy with Germany back in WW2, and they are tiny compared to China.
And I suppose I should make it explicit: no, I am not guaranteeing this outcome, I am warning of it as a possibility - but those who say it can not and will not happen are making a guarantee.
It's GDP is about half the US. And their "communist" system is being run entirely off the back of a mostly free market economy. Free markets always beat communism and socialism.
And if you believe that none of this matters, that China is a real threat, the last thing you want is to impose tariffs on them that hurt us more than they hurt China.
You may find this article interesting:
https://reason.com/archives/2017/10/26/the-fragile-generatio...
Note that Apple is not required to create robots to build in the US. It is an option they have, but there are other options as well. I would expect Apple to be smart enough to consider all options. The obvious alternatives to consider are move the factory to some other country; or have consumers vote against the tariff by showing how much cheaper the iPhone is elsewhere; there are probably more options I haven't thought of.
Why do people trust a lawyer's opinions when they so clearly don't understand the underlying principles?
Please get a book on tariffs and their history and read it. Please. Literally any of them.
But that obviously wouldn’t meld with your free trade boner very easily
This is laughably false. The postwar US hegemonic sphere is built on trade liberalization. Please read up on GATT, the WTO, OECD, and the 1934 Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act.
Prewar, the 1930 Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act[4] is widely viewed as one of the worst economic decisions ever made, badly exacerbating the Great Depression by collapsing global trade. The US has been the world's main driver of trade liberalization since that protectionist mistake was reversed in 1934, for the entire duration of its superpower status.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Agreement_on_Tariffs_a...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Trade_Organization
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OECD
Protectionism was very effective in developing economies. Once your economy dominates and functions mainly by extracting value from submissive developing nations (who are not allowed to enact the same proteionist rules that allowed the US to become so powerful) free trade becomes beneficial to you (but not the other party)
The effects of the Smoot-Hawley Act as well as a hundred years of economic consensus are quite clear on this: protectionism is bad.
>Protectionism was very effective in developing economies.
Care to cite any sources? The infant industry argument is not widely supported by economists[0] and is mostly parroted by heterodox/Marxist economists like Ha-Joon Chang.
>Once your economy dominates and functions mainly by extracting value from submissive developing nations (who are not allowed to enact the same proteionist rules that allowed the US to become so powerful) free trade becomes beneficial to you (but not the other party)
This shows a fundamental misunderstanding of the purpose and effects of international trade. Comparative advantage creates a mutual benefit for both parties to trade. The postwar liberal order has been associated with astonishing increases in standards of living across the globe.
[0] http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0973801010005001...
Clearly this discussion is going nowhere if you believe this is a good description of Ha-Joon Chang.
Please stop and consider that trade is a very complex situation with dependencies on many things, human psychology being one incredibly important but not very obvious one.
Turning a complex system into a binary, as you are doing, is not an optimal form of analysis. It introduces significant risk, because you are constraining your ability to consider possible outcomes of various policy decisions. Furthermore, you are basing your beliefs on recorded human history, which is an incredibly small sample size, and you are only looking at the average outcome. There is a tremendous amount of uncertainty and luck in human history, but the tone of your writing is that you have an utterly perfect understanding and indisputable conclusion.
At the very least, can you consider the possibility that while free trade is undoubtedly superior on average, that there can be negative individual outcomes in smaller time or regional frames?
EDIT: Also don't forget:
a) History is written by the victor
b) A lot of the studies you may cite (or other may use against you) are written by imperfect human beings, may be not perfectly correct or comprehensive, may contain bias (may be sponsored by someone looking for a particular conclusion) if not outright lies (lies, damned lies, and statistics and all that), and are not guaranteed to play out the same under different conditions.
The above would help explain why there are differences of opinion on such matters as this, and many other things. There seems to be this incredibly pervasive sentiment on both sides (yes, even yours!) of the political divide particularly in Western cultures, that the Ultimate Truth is blatantly obvious, if only the other side wasn't too uneducated to see it. This style of thinking strikes me as very ironic.
EDIT (to Rory, as I am throttled):
> I'm happy to consider exceptions to that rule or reasons to believe it is flawed.
Based on your tone and words, you certainly don't seem to have an open mind on the matter. I don't mean that as a snipe, I mean it is a fact that unfortunately you may find offensive. Keep in mind, people aren't perfect, and you are a person.
Above you said: "The effects of the Smoot-Hawley Act as well as a hundred years of economic consensus are quite clear on this: protectionism is bad."
You didn't say protectionism can be bad, or tends to be bad, you said it is bad. This is the very point of my criticism, it is an absolutist, one-dimensional conclusion on an incredibly complex system, based on a tiny sample size. If this statement offends you, you should stop and think about that for a little while, and I mean that sincerely and as non-offensively as possible.
> However, there is substantial theoretical and empirical work to support this point. Are you proposing an alternative or just handwavingly dismissing it as "science is wrong sometimes"? Unless you'd like to point to evidence that protectionism is good or at least a theoretical framework under which it can be good, the claim is little different from "evolution is just a theory, why don't you consider alternatives?"
Based on a disciplined reading what I've written, without subconscious interpretation and extrapolation, can you try to think of how this statement might be less than perfect? I could easily point out some flaws in this statement, but that tends not to be an effective way of communicating on these topics. Are you able to see any flaws in it, at all? (And, feel more than free to point out logical errors in my thinking, I encourage it!. But in good faith, before doing that please address my reasonable points.)
I'm happy to consider exceptions to that rule or reasons to believe it is flawed. (Certainly there are game theoretical reasons to impose protection in the short term in the hopes of coercing the other party into agreeing to lower overall protection in the long term. Though all indications are that the administration gives lip service to that at best — they are fundamentally opposed to free trade.)
However, there is substantial theoretical and empirical work to support this point. Are you proposing an alternative or just handwavingly dismissing it as "science is wrong sometimes"? Unless you'd like to point to evidence that protectionism is good or at least a theoretical framework under which it can be good, the claim is little different from "evolution is just a theory, why don't you consider alternatives?"
> But that obviously wouldn’t meld with your free trade boner very easily
http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/free-trade
You believe your feelings over the consensus by professional Economists.
As for the rest of your argument:
A) WWI/WW2 onward is related to Free Trade and the other economies being destroyed.
B) Pre-1900s Protectionism was largely due to continuous trade wars with other powers that is universally agreed to have been detrimental for all involved.
Literally everything you are saying is not fact-based.
Tariffs make more expensive to invest abroad than locally and investment is the crucial part of growing an economy.
As consumers, the people of an importing country could win in the short term.
If you think that the economy is global and that it doesn't matter where the productive capacity is, then tariffs are a bad thing. Otherwise, if you are worried about unemployment and that your country could become only a "services" country, maybe tariffs make sense.
[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE [2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OUTMS [3] http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/steel-and-aluminum-tariffs
Meanwhile the wealth gap is at historic highs. Increasing demand when supply is already low should bring up wages.
>It's also notable that tariffs are one of the few policies that economists are almost in universal agreement about [3].
Tariffs will not generally improve the welfare of Americans, removing the tariffs after our global competitors have ceased their own unfair trade practices, improved worker conditions, stop polluting so much, etc. may improve the welfare of everyone.
Tariffs are an extremely inefficient form of redistribution. If you want to fix the wealth gap, just make the pie as large as possible and redistribute directly.
> Tariffs will not generally improve the welfare of Americans, removing the tariffs after our global competitors have ceased their own unfair trade practices, improved worker conditions, stop polluting so much, etc. may improve the welfare of everyone.
I'm not sure what to make of this. It sounds like the plan is to make ourselves worse off in the hope that it also damages China? Most of the difference in labor practices comes from the fact that the US is much richer than China. It's unlikely that we can convince China to stop being poor by taxing ourselves.
It's hard to make the pie as large as possible when your second largest trade partner isn't playing fair.
>I'm not sure what to make of this. It sounds like the plan is to make ourselves worse off in the hope that it also damages China? Most of the difference in labor practices comes from the fact that the US is much richer than China. It's unlikely that we can convince China to stop being poor by taxing ourselves.
China has weird rules that restrict foreign companies from doing business there, which is a defacto tariff on all US corporations who want to sell to China. There's a lot of other industry-specific ways in which China is not playing fair. Of course American corporations want to manufacture in China to avoid paying for an American standard of living. And I get that poor countries are going to have lower wages. But these people are working in factories where suicide nets are necessary. We can pressure them to do better. Then of course there's environmental concerns which we're increasingly aware are an international problem, not an localized one.
We can't enact law in China, but we can pressure them to make changes which are more fair to American competitors and healthier for the entire planet.
What you said has nothing to do with whether we should be a doormat for China's unfair trade practices. If you're really concerned about the wellbeing of the poor I don't understand how, in this context, you could be more upset at American corporations than you are at Chinese corporations.
>This is a straw man argument, please don't rationalize these tariffs as something that were meant to do anything but to right an imagined wrong in the mind of an Insane POTUS who thinks the trade deficit is an indication that other countries are "cheating" the US.
I suspect you and I feel similarly about Trump. I don't have particularly strong feelings of support for these tariffs, but it's been clear to me since the 80s that we needed to fight back in the trade war China has been fighting against us since then. There aren't a lot of levers to pull here, there's tariffs, sanctions... I dunno what else. The biggest problem with these tariffs is the fact that it's unilateral. Stuff is fungible so it's stupid unless we can get the rest of the world to participate and push China to behave.
I thought the point you were making was that it is not possible to have enough resources ("pie") to benefit all Americans (rich and poor) unless the "unfair trade practices of China" were somehow reigned in. So it absolutely has everything to do with trade. If there is already more than enough wealth (which I argue there is) and the problem is one of unequal distribution of it, then trying to tweak trade seems like an suboptimal strategy.
> I suspect you and I feel similarly about Trump. I don't have particularly strong feelings of support for these tariffs, but it's been clear to me since the 80s that we needed to fight back in the trade war China has been fighting against us since then. There aren't a lot of levers to pull here, there's tariffs, sanctions... I dunno what else. The biggest problem with these tariffs is the fact that it's unilateral. Stuff is fungible so it's stupid unless we can get the rest of the world to participate and push China to behave.
China has made the jump from developing to developed in a shockingly short period of time. In the process, they have managed to mostly solve the problem of providing food to millions of Chinese and also providing a path to middle class for the same folks. I don't agree with authoritarianism and Chinese trade policies either; but to characterize that as a trade war is being much too hyperbolic. They are and always have been protectionist; every developing economy is. The reason previous US administrations didn't impose tariffs weren't because they weren't brave enough or never thought of them, its because the worldview was that once China made the transition to developed country, it would gradually loosen the protectionism as well.
And I don't think any country will join with the US on anything significant with this caustic and highly incompetent POTUS ripping up longtime diplomatic goodwill with allies and heaping praise on authoritarian rivals...
Does anyone know of a good nuanced article or discussion on tariffs? The standard argument that I've seen is to invoke comparative advantage and call it a day. I've never really bought into that argument, so I'd love to see a less theoretical review of the effects that tariffs can have.
I strongly believe, and constantly test this theory as I am reading the news and forum discussions, that if there is an aspect of gender, sexuality, race, culture, and probably a few others involved in a given scenario, there are very strong subconscious mental processes that interfere with the thought processes of otherwise very logical and perfectly well-intentioned people.
What about working conditions in some of these countries the U.S. trades with? Is it all cool so long as we benefit from cheap labor?
Furthermore, there's an imbalance between capital and labor in terms of arbitrage opportunities. Capital can easily take advantage of labor arbitrage but labor is not mobile and thus, cannot take advantage of cost of living arbitrage.
I get the sense that most folks that support minimum wage increases don't really think much about the labor conditions of those making most of the stuff they consume.
If all we do is rebalance $100 billion in trade away from China and back to US production (out of the ~$300 billion deficit), that is money going into the US economy and not to enrich a foreign economy. If it net costs the US economy 15% more to do X domestically, we keep the rest of that value gain that comes home instead of sending the majority of it over to China.
The majority of consumers in the US have jobs. Those consumers all benefit from a tighter labor market and increased wage competition. And consumers are connected in numerous ways, both distant and local. That job producing domestic steel instead of buying it from Russia, may employ a wife or a husband in a family of consumers, bolstering wages within a household.
They also hurt businesses that consume X. Steel tariffs hurt automakers, for example, who now must pay more for the metal and deal with supply chain issues.
Many US automakers have factories in Mexico as well as in the US, and some models for the US market are built in those Mexican factories.
Question: will steel tariffs in the US encourage these automakers to shift more production to Mexico?
Tariffs on X generally help domestic X producers and hurt domestic X consumers. For most values of X, production is done by companies which are mostly owned by a small number of people, whereas consumption is done by a much broader group. So one would generally expect tariffs to help businesses at the expense of workers. And aren't tariffs usually advertised as helping American businesses? To say now that it hurts them seems like a weird change of tack.