News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by jgh on Saturday March 31, 2018 @08:21PM (#16725943)
interesting that they have pretty much no idea where it will end up, i thought they'd be able to estimate that a bit.
Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by simonh on Saturday March 31, 2018 @11:08PM (#16726483)
To estimate that they’d need very precise information about the atmospheric drag on the station. That depends on many factors including the precise geometry of the station and all it’s peripheral parts and attachments and their relationships to each other, it’s attitude, It’s rotation and angular momentum in every axis, it’s precise weight distribution, then there’s the atmospheric characteristics at every point through its trajectory across multiple latitudes, over sea and land and with varying underlying weather and temperatures. Then there is varying gravitational strength due to geological factors, and possibly even the influence of earths magnetic field on the structure. Bear in mind the vehicle is grazing through the atmosphere at an extremely shallow angle.
Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by inopinatus on Saturday March 31, 2018 @11:10PM (#16726494)
The possible trajectories are quite specific: https://twitter.com/Marco_Langbroek/status/97903409781211136... because it will re-enter basically over its own ground track. So although we don't know exactly where this will happen, we have a very good picture of where it won't happen (and that is most of the planet).

The alternatives occur because it is losing speed only very gradually with each orbit through the upper atmosphere. Tiangong-1 goes around the planet every 88 minutes, and one of those orbits will lose enough speed and altitude that the vehicle disintegrates due to heat or drag. It's just that due to variations in the upper atmosphere, we don't know which orbit exactly will finally tip the balance.

This is in contrast to a controlled re-entry vehicle e.g. Soyuz that washes off something like 150m/sec in a single engine burn to place it on an known and specific sub-orbital trajectory to get home.

Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by sephamorr on Sunday April 01, 2018 @02:35AM (#16727062)
I think the best analogy is a roulette wheel. You know about when it's going to stop, but that doesn't help much to analyze where.
Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by Lozzer on Sunday April 01, 2018 @09:47AM (#16728224)
I think you'd enjoy the book "The Newtonian Casino".
Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by greglindahl on Saturday March 31, 2018 @11:03PM (#16726469)
It's a timescale problem. They can figure out when it might fall to within a couple of days, but, it orbits once every 90 minutes. As the descent becomes steeper the error bars become smaller than a day, but it's still orbiting about once every 90 minutes.
Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by saagarjha on Saturday March 31, 2018 @08:37PM (#16726000)
Probably because it's hard to predict where it will reach an altitude after which it starts rapid reentry. This could basically happen anywhere in its orbit, since the station is uncontrolled, so there's not a whole lot of confidence in where it will end up.
Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by Turing_Machine on Saturday March 31, 2018 @09:24PM (#16726168)
> Probably because it's hard to predict where it will reach an altitude after which it starts rapid reentry.

I'd think there would be significant variation in that simply due to weather. If I remember right, the atmosphere expands quite a bit on a sunny day.

Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by jvm_ on Saturday March 31, 2018 @10:59PM (#16726454)
But every day is a sunny day in space? Or does the ground vs. clouds make a difference.
Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by teraflop on Saturday March 31, 2018 @11:53PM (#16726612)
"Space weather" is actually a thing. It doesn't really have anything to do with clouds, though. Most of the influence on the extreme upper atmosphere comes from solar phenomena, and their interactions with the earth's magnetic field.

Solar flares and other similar events happen all the time. They're not really noticeable at ground level, because they don't appreciably affect the sun's visible brightness, and the density of matter involved is tiny compared to the atmosphere at ground level. But at the heights where satellites orbit -- where the atmosphere is already extremely tenuous -- solar and geomagnetic phenomena can have a huge relative effect.

Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by Turing_Machine on Sunday April 01, 2018 @12:25AM (#16726717)
> It doesn't really have anything to do with clouds, though.

The expansion of the earth's atmosphere due to heating effects has very much to do with clouds.

Re:Falling Chinese Space Station to Crash This Weekend by Turing_Machine on Sunday April 01, 2018 @12:24AM (#16726714)
But we're not talking about space. We're talking about the earth's atmosphere.

The proportion of reflected light is called the "albedo", which ranges from a theoretical maximum of 1 (a perfect mirror, or a theoretical white surface with no absorption) to 0 (a theoretical "black body").

White clouds reflect a lot of the incoming sunlight (have a larger albedo). Light that strikes the ground from a clear sky causes more ground heating, which causes more air heating, which causes the atmosphere to expand.

ATW, the Earth's albedo can range from about 0.9 (fresh snow on the ground) to about 0.06 (open ocean). White clouds can approach about 0.8.

Edit: the height of the tropopause (the boundary between the troposphere and the stratosphere) varies from about 9 km (over the poles) to 17 km (over the equator) due largely to the greater temperature in equatorial regions. So that layer of the atmosphere, at least, is nearly twice as thick in warm regions than it is in cold regions. See:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tropopause