News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by neo4sure on Thursday March 29, 2018 @07:53PM (#16712343)
I would like to know how this technology will affect the great firewall of China, does anyone have any ideas?
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by unepipe on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:30PM (#16712571)
It will not affect it in any way. They have released their plans for Starlink and there will be a "blackout" zone over China, so China doesn't shoot down their satellites. In 2007, China shot down FY-1C as a test of a kinetic kill vehicle (leaving tons of high speed space debris). Unless they receive approval from China to broadcast, they won't over China.

Source: http://www.businessinsider.com/spacex-internet-satellite-con...

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by greedo on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:29PM (#16712881)
China won't shoot down commercial satellites, they'll just either jam the signal, or block ownership of the ground terminals. Shooting down satellites is very expensive, and would cause an incredible hue and cry internationally. It's one thing to shoot down one of your own defunct satellites, quite another thing to shoot down someone else's.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by larkeith on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:59PM (#16713047)
China might or might not shoot down the satellites, but the FCC would absolutely not have authorized the satellite network had SpaceX been so blatantly antagonistic towards China as to provide service there.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by lev99 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:55PM (#16713018)
> Shooting down satellites is very expensive

It's less expensive than launching satellites, and the Chinese goverment has enough money to do it if they want.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by positr0n on Friday March 30, 2018 @12:28AM (#16713677)
> It's less expensive than launching satellites

I doubt it, since a single Falcon Heavy launch would carry dozens of Starlink satellites but the existing anti-satellite technology can only hit one at a time. Keep in mind they have said the final constellation will be 12,000 satellites!

edit: and BFR could theoretically carry 300 when it is operational. https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/25525/how-many-spa...

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by lev99 on Friday March 30, 2018 @02:23AM (#16714120)
I'm not sure that it is cheaper, but I am sure there is a cheaper way to shoot something down than to keep it up. Idon't know if the tech and economics are correct, but the physics says it should be.

Moving something to the same altitude as Leo requires much less energy than moving something to Leo. Rockets don't fire straight up because the need their momentum to be at an angle. In addition, the payload of a communication satellite is more expensive than the payload required to throw it either disable the satellite or put it into a declining orbit.

Maybe Elon's rockets are just so cheap he can make it up in margin, but we are really talking about we aren't talking about marginal amount of difficulty difference, but an entire order of magnitude.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by positr0n on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:23PM (#16740386)
Yeah I completely agree it could be done cheaper because physics, my comment was about the current economics.

I'm not sure how efficient China's military industrial complex is, but I wouldn't trust the US's military to be able to build a weapon system that could destroy SpaceX satellite's more efficiently than SpaceX can launch them, haha.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 29, 2018 @10:32PM (#16713225)
> It's less expensive than launching satellites

Are you sure? If China knocks out one of ours, we’ll knock out at least one of theirs. We’ll also likely implement a suite of sanctions. Shooting down a satellite is an act of war.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by jessaustin on Friday March 30, 2018 @10:00AM (#16716102)
Why am I ever surprised at the constant expansion of justifications for war?

Wars kill lots of people. You knew that, right?

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by reaperducer on Friday March 30, 2018 @02:50AM (#16714236)
>If China knocks out one of ours, we’ll knock out at least one of theirs.

No, we won’t. We’ll impose several decades of meaningless tariffs and embargoes with tons of loopholes so it looks like we’re doing something until everyone forgets what everyone was mad about in the first place.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by vatueil on Friday March 30, 2018 @08:07PM (#16720827)
The linked source says nothing about a "blackout zone" over China. More likely SpaceX won't sell ground receivers in mainland China and/or the PRC will simply ban Starlink receivers.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by 52-6F-62 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:37PM (#16712612)
> shot down FY-1C as a test of a kinetic kill vehicle (leaving tons of high speed space debris)

Do you have more info on this? Or anyone?

That's so crass. It's plain indefensible. I really want to know more.

edit: Thanks for the links.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by djrogers on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:46PM (#16712659)
Googling the phrase "China shot down FY-1C" came up with a bunch of stuff, the first of which was the wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_Chinese_anti-satellite_mi...
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by rhcom2 on Friday March 30, 2018 @02:08AM (#16714061)
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by solarengineer on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:47PM (#16712660)
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by psisbwvaiia on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:46PM (#16712657)
Why is it indefensible to defend your nation’s sovereignty. Many nations have google maps blur out their military bases for example.

I’m sure lots of North Americans wouldn’t want Chinese satellites overhead for concern of privacy.

I mean, generating tons of space junk is not cool. But what else are you going to do if others are lurking on your airspace?

It is going to be shift is policy though. We are going to need to update space law.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by jonknee on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:54PM (#16712716)
> I’m sure lots of North Americans wouldn’t want Chinese satellites overhead for concern of privacy.

Umm, there are of course Chinese satellites overhead and they have excellent imagery of all of our military bases. As we do for theirs (and every other country!). Orbits aren't very friendly to avoiding airspace.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by 52-6F-62 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:53PM (#16712708)
I mean specifically generating high-speed shrapnel in orbit. That's going to have implications for a very long time.

If there is a willingness to do it once, it tests the barrier of what's acceptable.

It's bad for everyone—present, and future.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by tarlinian on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:55PM (#16712722)
National sovereignty over airspace does not extend into orbit. Otherwise nearly every earth science satellite in polar orbit would be in violation of international law.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by walrus01 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:55PM (#16712720)
shooting down shit and generating orbital debris in polar orbits is incredibly dangerous to the commons that is low earth orbit, generally.

accidental example:

https://www.google.com/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=iri...

no nation-state wants to start the game of shooting down another's satellite, either military or commercial, because everything up there is so vulnerable. it would open china to retaliatory strikes taking down their own polar orbit LEO, inclined LEO (35-45 degree) molnia, MEO and GEO satellites. satellites are fragile things and can be killed with one 200g chunk of tungsten at a closing velocity of 18,000 km/h.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by sambull on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:56PM (#16712727)
Why is a Chinese sattelite less private than a sheriffs helicopter, private imaging plane running grids or an American satellite? Or my neighbors drone?

Your defining 'space' as airspace is odd also

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by mirimir on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:59PM (#16712751)
How far does "airspace" extend? I can see that for low orbit, but geostationary?
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by aphextron on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:25PM (#16712860)
The SpaceX satellites won’t be in GTO, they will be in LEO, around 600 miles altitude. Well within kill range for ballistic missiles.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by seatotree on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:59PM (#16712744)
If China shoots down a SpaceX satellite, that is an act of war against the United States. China wouldn’t risk it. This is a great opportunity to break the great firewall and finally give the Chinese people access to unfiltered information.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by zpr on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:17PM (#16712823)
Which might be seen as a provocation by the Chinese Government of the US to destabilize it's citizens.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by seatotree on Friday March 30, 2018 @08:57AM (#16715686)
Not illegal under international law. We did this all the time to the Soviets. This is what Voice of America does today.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by btian on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:19PM (#16712830)
China absolutely will. And if SpaceX were to beam internet over North Korea, then NK will shoot it down too.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by windexh8er on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:25PM (#16712864)
Your comment implies they could successfully destroy said satellite. It might be a better distraction to tell NK there's one overhead, "leak" it's orbit, position, etc. and watch the fireworks month over month.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by freehunter on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:27PM (#16712876)
I know NK has made some major advancements in their missile capabilities but shooting down a satellite is pretty advanced stuff... any indications that they're capable of doing what you claim they would do?
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by mrep on Friday March 30, 2018 @12:20AM (#16713646)
> If China shoots down a SpaceX satellite, that is an act of war against the United States.

These are not government satellites and china owns the airwaves over their nation. I highly doubt the US government would retaliate whatsoever against China if they shot down a satellite that illegally interacted with their airspace.

> China wouldn’t risk it. This is a great opportunity to break the great firewall and finally give the Chinese people access to unfiltered information.

Take this with a grain of salt since this is mostly based on what I have heard hearsay, but they can jam the signals and/or monitor who transmits back and go after the citizens using said signal (and china is not a country where you want to poke the government). I doubt this will have any effect on the great firewall.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by seatotree on Friday March 30, 2018 @08:56AM (#16715682)
Airspace extends 12 miles. Satellites are governed by space law. It would be the same as sinking a commercial American ship in international waters.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by nradov on Thursday March 29, 2018 @07:59PM (#16712382)
Not much effect. The Chinese government will prohibit import and possession of the ground terminals. Smugglers will bring in a few but not enough to really bypass the Great Firewall for many people.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by drcross on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:28PM (#16712555)
>bring in a few

Bring in a few from where? Where do you think these devices will be manufactured anyway? ;)

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by TeMPOraL on Friday March 30, 2018 @02:21AM (#16714112)
Exactly.

Also, even if they were manufactured in the US, China is literally the best country to reverse-engineer electronics and produce knockoffs ;).

That said, AFAIK those satellites aren't meant to be dumb routers/repeaters - so China might just politically/economically pressure US to tell SpaceX to pretty-please don't service connections to/from China.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by cryptoz on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:35PM (#16712604)
Probably the US.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by Retric on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:22PM (#16712519)
If you can get a 1Gbps up-link and VPN within China that's going to be harder to track down and could service a lot of people.

However, I suspect SpaceX will however allow China to monitor/limit connections. Further, China has a lot more power to crack down on purely internal operations would deter many.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by walrus01 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:26PM (#16712540)
The problem is twofold from a China perspective:

a) the rooftop CPE needs to be reasonably large and have high gain to be used effectively, and needs clear unobstructed line of sight to as much of the sky and horizon as possible.

and

b) It needs to transmit, it will transmit in very known frequency ranges, and the chinese authorities have plenty of budget to buy portable spectrum analyzers, horn antennas and to reach people how to use them. It only takes a couple of hours maximum to reach somebody how to use a portable spectrum analyzer to physically locate and identify transmitters in almost any band.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by Retric on Thursday March 29, 2018 @10:47PM (#16713301)
A) A thin tarp or pant etc could obscure the shape without blocking radio waves.

B) These things need to transmit up, so you can reasonably block most signals in other directions. Aircraft would work, but again not cheap.

The real issue is more on the human side and network monitoring. Lots of encrypted network traffic to a ransom location would be suspect.

PS: For once tinfoil might actually be useful vs government spying :)

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by walrus01 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @11:39PM (#16713500)
A) all radome materials have some degree of loss. Ideally you want no loss at all. The path loss in higher than 10GHz frequencies to LEO is already extreme.

B) not just up but to the sides and toward the horizon as well. This will be a non moving phased array antenna that can talk to two LEO satellites moving across the sky at the same time. I predict that any reasonable amount of blockage to the sides will not be a good idea for their network architecture.

C) all Tx have some sort of sidelobes and nothing has a perfect f/b ratio. Will still be detectable by spectrum analyzers from the side.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by Retric on Thursday March 29, 2018 @11:50PM (#16713545)
A) 1% signal attenuation is not going to kill this and that's plenty to work with.

B) Depends on how many satellites are in the constellation. Ideally you want a lot of them as there is vastly more atmosphere the lower your angle to the horizon.

C) detectable at say 50 feet sure, but a signal you can detect from 10+ miles in a van doing 60mph without a lot of false positives is another story.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by walrus01 on Friday March 30, 2018 @01:20AM (#16713874)
the threat model for hiding from spectrum analyzers is not 10+ miles in a van doing 60 mph. With the resources of a nation-state at the disposal of the spectrum analyzer operators (Iran, China, Ethiopia) it will look more like a person walking around a neighborhood with a portable spectrum analyzer and horn antenna. Multiply by however many people are needed to canvass a metro area in a reasonable amount of time.

With the resources of China, spending $15,000 per spectrum analyzer kit x 8 kits, plus training, is a tiny drop in the bucket compared to the amount of money and effort they are currently spending on IP cameras that feed into facial recognition systems, etc.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by Retric on Friday March 30, 2018 @07:59AM (#16715382)
I was more thinking a FSO link ~2km into the middle of nowhere vs having one of those sitting in someone's house. But directional wifi is probably safer as it's also not going to look strange to a spectrum analyzer.

However, if you want to catch individual usage in urban areas, with guys on for that's going to easily be into the 10's of of billions as users don't need to keep them on 24/7. AKA within the capability of nation states, but not without significant effort.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by TeMPOraL on Friday March 30, 2018 @02:25AM (#16714127)
> Aircraft would work, but again not cheap.

s/Aircraft/Drone/. Now it's cheap.

Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by wongarsu on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:26PM (#16712541)
And those people who would be interested in smuggled ground terminals will already be using VPNs. Maybe this will be more convienient and possibly somewhat safer, but not it won't be a game-changer for even a minority (at least not in the firewall problem, general internet connectivity in rural China is another issue)
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by pmorici on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:12PM (#16712465)
Probably not really a factor. Countries were the government wants to control the Internet or communications in general will outlaw the possession of sat-com equipment if they can't get adequate control over it through some other means.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by dsparkman on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:06PM (#16712768)
Just like India does.
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by glax on Friday March 30, 2018 @12:08AM (#16713607)
Can you elaborate ?
Re:FCC Authorizes SpaceX to Provide Broadband Satellite Serv... by walrus01 on Friday March 30, 2018 @01:54AM (#16714003)
I can, basically anything that transmits needs an indian license from their version of the FCC. No license, it might get taken away by men with guns. You can't even bring a handheld Iridium satellite phone into India without a license. It is not rigorously enforced, because the Indian version of the FCC is certainly not fitted out with Sprinter vans equipped with $60,000 of spectrum analyzers, but it is occasionally enforced. The more traffic you move or the more significant your thing becomes in your local area's telecom infrastructure, the more likely it is to be noticed.