The answer is that you need some kind of vetting and certification of the people contributing to your traceability database. So you need a trusted 3rd party to coordinate all that. So you don't need a blockchain. Instead why not just have the trusted 3rd party issue certificates like a CA on the web for instance? People would digitally sign the paperwork and you could collect the documents and their signatures in a central database. If somebody notices something wrong you can show that somebody made a fake or erroneous document and hold them responsible. Then you can publish dump of the database at regular intervals for people to mirror so that they can see if you attempt to rewrite history. There, problem solved using good old 1990's technology.
>very bullish !
Interesting that you finish your technical argument with trading lingo. Hodl, am I right?
I could generate a PGP key for Bill Gates right now, distribute it to the keyservers and sign a message saying that "I owe simias on hacker news one billion dollars". You could verify that the message was signed by my key beyond a doubt but so what?
Bitcoin doesn't have this problem thanks to PoW, when a miner submits a newly mined block the network doesn't need to check the miner's credentials, the block itself proves (statistically) that the miner did a certain amount of work to come up with the block. That's all that matters and the coins/fees are credited to the miner's address. That works because all the data necessary to create the consensus are available "objectively" on the blockchain for all to see. It doesn't matter if the miner pretends to be Abraham Lincoln, that's not what the blockchain works with.
Most problems don't have these properties, if I tell the blockchain "I have a brand new PS4 and I'm going to send it to X in exchange for n bitcoins" the blockchain has no objective way to track this transaction.
I think people raising these objections have not worked in a physical supply chain in the floor plant? I don't know, I have a difficulty to wrap my head around the objection. I am receiving a truckload of parts that I ordered - these parts have a barcode or a RFID identifier that tracks their provenance - the only change in the system would be that when I acknowledge the reception of the truckload, another block is appened to the blockchain-based history of the parts : Supplier + me the manufacturer. And so on across the supply chain.
I don't understand, are we talking about a scenario where a rogue actor would send me for fere a truckload of parts I have not ordered or something like that ?
Take for instance the blockchain De Beers (the diamond cartel) says it wants to create to track diamonds. Things like country of origin, quality etc... Tracking diamonds is especially important because you want to make sure that the diamonds you buy are not from a conflict zone, the so-called "blood diamonds".
Now imagine that you have a completely trustless bitcoin-like blockchain to track this. What prevents an African warlord from pretending to be Canadian and create fake entries for its diamonds into the blockchain pretending that they were mined in America? Then he can trade them without issue. The blockchain is unable to detect that a user hasn't the right nationality, nor can it track the physical origin and location of a diamond without having to trust somebody to tell it. Ergo your trustless blockchain is no more valuable than a random file on pastebin.com.
To solve this issue you'd need some trusted certification authority that would audit miners and grant them access to the blockchain once they've asserted that they are who they pretend to be. But if you do this then you have a trusted 3rd party and the blockchain can advantageously be replaced by any regular database of your choice managed by this 3rd party.
You can apply this reasoning to any physical good, from organic produce (how do you make sure that the producer isn't lying about making organic oranges?) to paper rolls (how do you know the producer isn't lying about using sustainable foresting techniques?). You need trusted third parties certifying and controlling these things to weed out cheaters.
Anyhow. I do think you are right. The integrity of the data has to be questioned. But I question why we have to assume that its useless just because it cannot be trusted? This paper trail is immutable. That is valuable. Future evidence can expose prior lies. Once you know that you have to maintain a lie for life, suddenly you are questioning if its really worth making.
You can amend it and publish new versions but you can be sure that somebody somewhere will have a copy. You want to make your paper trail immutable? Sign it and publish it widely using any medium you want. Burn it on CDs and mail them to random addresses. Tie them to balloons and release them.
Or just use a merkle hash tree like CT logs do: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certificate_Transparency#Certi...
Funnily enough, CT was devised around four years after bitcoin and mentions it in their introduction article: https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=2668154
It is only valuable on the blockchain if its cost to maintain is less than, say, a mid-sized country worth of electricity.
Who will be the miners required for this blockchain? Who will pay for the mining? Who will ensure there is no 51% attack on the blockchain?
You mean Kickstarter, which has nothing to do with blockchain?
"Anyhow. I do think you are right. The integrity of the data has to be questioned. But I question why we have to assume that its useless just because it cannot be trusted? This paper trail is immutable. That is valuable. Future evidence can expose prior lies. Once you know that you have to maintain a lie for life, suddenly you are questioning if its really worth making."
Says who? Both Bitcoin and Etherium have gone through forks of their chains.
Blockchain is having all of the functionality (and more) of Kickstarter with 10-20x more reach. Also, explain how you would use kickstarter to crowd-fund a gold-backed digital currency without Blockchain?
>Says who? Both Bitcoin and Etherium have gone through forks of their chains
The whole point if a Blockchain is you can tell if it's been forked, and really forks are just the exception proving the rule of immutability. Meaningful forks have happened a handful of times and they've been heavily publicized. How many times has a bank issued a chargeback?
I do not have the answers to your objections. I was replying to the common theme of "this is a solution is search for a problem". I am stating that there is a problem in search for a solution
It's the only one where the substantial additional overhead and complexity of blockchain is actually still less than the alternative, as your example clearly illustrates.
To attempt to answer a question from sibling comments: these systems are private or closed blockchains, not public. You have a traditional credentials database (the blockchain itself could also be used for this, but that won't usually have inherent benefits) to track who is allowed access to read or submit transactions. Those parties may run a node or you may have one independent third party run all the nodes. It's so different from cryptocurrency setup that it's hard to apply too much of the stuff we've learned from Bitcoin et al to these setups.
At least that's my understanding.
When receiving an item you want to check the provenance of, you need some way to securely identify the product in the log. Otherwise some bad actor along the way could unlink the actual product from the ID in the log, for example by duplicating and stealing a known-good ID, yielding all the provenance information useless.
I guess this could work for electronic products where you could deeply embed something like a TPM that could provide this ID securely (which would be to expensive to extract to make it worth duplicating), but for something like a shipment of steel or even worse coal/oil/grain etc, I don't see how this would work.
If you need to prove that life-saving drugs have been kept at the correct temperature throughout their shelf-life, you can probably afford a RFID tag per pack, with a unique ID.
On the other end of the spectrum, if you are talking about low-criticality tracability of shipments of bulk materials, you can probably admit supplier-defined batch numbers. You could imagine that a rogue manufacturer would try to cheat and re-use a batch number from a "premium" raw material while using a cheaper one. Blockchain would not provide a protection against false declaration, it would on the other end provide an immutable papertrail in case of later legal investigation / certification audit (ie "you purchased X premium parts and Y inferior parts, but you logged using X+Y premium parts, how do you explain that?")
The problem is, how do you know I didn't ship you a fake replica and keep the original for myself, sell it to someone else on the sly, etc.? Sure, you could have a TPM which securely holds some data linking the physical smart card to the blockchain provenance record... but what links the physical smart card to the physical painting? Couldn't I just give you the fake painting + real smart card?
You could get an art expert to authenticate the physical painting, of course -- but that's exactly the same reliance on a trusted third party that art collectors have today, and blockchain has done nothing to improve the situation...
To express it in an analogy with current services, I would like the blockchain to be a database, exposing a universal API. I don't really see a private blockchain allowing this, but I may be wrong. And indeed there will be the thorny authentication issue... I don't know the solution, really !
For example, we could have had an identity verification protocol, bound to our browsers, that would have logged us in websites. We would not have needed FB oauth for ex. But it was not prioritized, and now that the Web has been taken over by closed garden, individual companies have very little incentive to contribute to these general-benefits protocols.
Token can be seen a way to incentivize adoption of these general-benefits protocols
If they throw out a signature they don't like, the system works perfectly fine - it's treated like any other untrusted product.
No one should trust a system that has a "don't trust this, it's bad" flag, it should always be "trust this, it's clean".
Courts. Laws. Governments.
Do you really want an immutable ledger for that? Fat fingers and data entry errors can happen.
https://medium.com/@jimbreyer/announcing-our-vechain-advisor...
I had professional experience in an industry where we had to go to the plants to ensure rolls of paper certified from suppliers using responsibly-managed forests were physically separated from the non-certified ones. We needed the paperwork coming from China, then another one from the transformation plant in Morocco, then in customer warehouses across Europe.
An external protocol that would provide universal tracability, usable by any actor of the chain, seem like a great solution to a real problem. Blockchain provides some "neutrality", ie no need for each actor to find its own certificate provider (I imagine that service shops would help larger companies set up their systems, but the back-end would be common across all actors).
I'm not very convinced by pseudo-decentralized apps in most domains, but in logistics... very bullish !