As as example, assume there is a star directly perpendicular to our motion (and that the Earth moves in a straight line). Due to the vector addition of our motion and the light travel direction, it appears to us that the star is located slightly forward of perpendicular (typically by about 1/100 of a degree) Now assume the star were to disappear. During the light travel time the star would have time to move backwards as seen by us (due to our forward motion) so that at the moment it disappears, it appears to be located perpendicular to us.
In the context of gravity, this effect (it's called aberration) exactly cancels and the net effect is that the gravitational attraction is in a direction different from the actual location of the attractor such that it appears that gravity is instantaneous.
This only works for constant velocities, once you have accelerations it becomes more complicated. And it's not a relativistic effect at all, it's present for all waves with finite propagation speeds. You can do this experiment with boats making waves and get the same result.
Edit: And your charge example is not so good. For Galilean invariant theories it's only relative motions that matter. There is no effect if the two are moving with the same velocity. (Plus, once there are relative motions between the charges, there will be induced magnetic fields which affect the dynamics.)
E&M is Lorentz invariant though, not Galilean.
This causes an issue with your starlight aberration example as well. Velocities do not add linearly (though that is a reasonable approximation for low velocities).
Absolutely correct for E&M. This is because it's a vector field, and the velocity of the source is encoded in how the field moves.
For gravity, it goes one better -- this is a tensor field (hence the notion of gravitons having to be "spin-2" if they were described by a quantum theory), and the acceleration is encoded as well, so you need a non-constant acceleration to notice any difference from the position being instantaneously updated.
That means my bootstrap-runaway argument must be flawed in some way, because a scalar field can't encode any velocity information, and as a classical field equation, it would cause a 1/r^2 force law just like everything else, but aimed at the retarded position.
Suppose we have a scalar field.
For Galilean relativity, a sphere expanding at a given speed will remain so after a boost, but will have a net velocity. Densities will remain the same. A moving source shouldn't matter -- any material will itself will set the rest-frame, and must to have a non-infinite propagation velocity. Whereas, emitting particles, these will have the velocity of the source. Ah! if it's a complex wave equation, you can put a varying phase on everything encoding the velocity. But moving to a complex field is in some sense putting more degrees-of-freedom in.
For Einsteinian relativity, a sphere expanding at light speed remains a sphere in any reference frame, but the density along it changes. A moving source should have that same pattern, so it would seem that local differences (i.e. derivatives) could "point out" the velocity of the source. This behaves the same for particles being emitted. Is there a first-order Lorentz invariant scalar wave-equation, or only second-order, using the d'Alembertian? And that seems to introduce another degree-of-freedom as well.
I'm still really confused. How do pions behave? Is it reasonable to consider them as a fundamental scalar field when they're modeled as pairs of quarks? Particularly when they have excited states that are spin-1?
Well, that's mind blowing. Where could I go to learn more about this?
For E&M, the standard way to develop this is to explain magnetism as Lorentz-transformed static electrical attraction/repulsion. Take two wires, and run current through them. Transforming to a frame where the electrons are at rest, but the atoms (and hence protons) are moving, length contraction ends up with the density being different, meaning a net charge in this frame. You then get E&M united as tensor field F, but antisymmetric, meaning the spin-2 components are 0, leaving effectively two spin-1 (vector) components. This lets you do relativistic corrections for a propagating field, and the velocity of the original source gets turned into magnetic effects that act the same as if the source were moving at a constant velocity.
Extremely similar things happen with gravity, if you look at weak-field linearized versions of the Einstein field equations. The actual math ... well, it's rather ugly.
So let's assume once can cause the sun to vanish instantly somehow. If that's the case, would it then be possible to setup a 'gravitational wave' communication system that travels faster than light?
Ie, I would put a whole bunch of stars together, and then have them disappear at certain intervals. My buddy who sits 100 light-minutes away would then detect the changes and decode the message. TADA: Faster-than-light communication.
I feel safe to say that's not possible.
Te end result is that it appears to travel instantaneously since it ends up at the same place. But this only works for constant velocities - if the earth changes direction suddenly this "correction" will not be correct, since it will still "assume" the earth is still headed in the direction it was heading before.
(But no one will ever read this comment because the topic is 5 days old.)
Considering gravity does not have an inverse (a gravitational repulsion) that I am aware of, I'm not certain we can extend your thought experiment to gravity.
I'm almost positive this statement is incorrect.
Relativistic force laws tend to be forced to contain correction factors that ensure that constant velocity motion is "predicted" and the direction of the force is adjusted accordingly - as long as a body is not accelerating, a purely attractive or repulsive force will be pointing at its current position, not its position 8 mins ago.
To see why this must be the case for a repulsive force, at least, imagine two charges riding on frictionless rails that keep them at a constant, finite distance. Suppose they're both moving with some constant velocity (to start, at least) in the same direction - now the place that the force from the other charge appears to be coming from is behind the charge, so if there was no correction factor, each charge would be getting an extra push forwards. This would lead to a runaway "bootstrap" acceleration, and the particles would accelerate to the speed of light. That's a pretty clear violation of the conservation laws, so...
With attractive forces like gravity, there's still a conservation problem, since the charges would slow down to zero speed eventually, but it's always more convincing to cite the runaway solution as a violation of conservation laws than the run-down one, because while the energy could possibly leak out of the charges into the fields, there's nowhere to pull infinite energy from, so it's pretty clear there's a problem if we'd need to.
And this is somewhat different from the runaway self-action solutions that we grudgingly "accept" in E+M, because those tend to involve some limit to infinitesimal size, whereas this is a completely finite situation that we could theoretically set up in the real world with a couple of charged beads or something like that.