News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by amarkov on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:32PM (#16691430)
It was my understanding that Netflix wanted to show their movies in French cinemas, but French regulations would prevent them from doing that while also streaming the movies for subscribers.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by leggomylibro on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:45PM (#16691538)
>Netflix and Amazon are going to continue their quest to destroy cinemas, and in this case, French business.

If true, that quote from the comment you're responding to is probably a good representation of the attitude that France approaches that regulation with.

Hearing an argument like that uttered unironically can be baffling, but it is how the thought process can go in France. Those cinemas, they might well argue, are French businesses which inherently deserve to exist - and damn the consequences.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by Jesus_Jones on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:08PM (#16691763)
Remember that netflix also wanted to put a movie in us theaters. One chain said okay. Then the other movie companies said we will blacklist you and not send you an movies to show. This is just about commercial competition, the 'real movie theaters' are trying to block netflix et al. Netflix should just buy their own damn theater in LA and show movies there to get them on all the awards shows.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by clintonb on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:55PM (#16692653)
> Netflix should just buy their own damn theater in LA and show movies there to get them on all the awards shows.

That's what used to happen. The Fox and Paramount theatres in Oakland, CA used to be owned by Fox and Paramount, respectively.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by extralego on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:32AM (#16696083)
I wonder what is preventing them from doing that, other than fear that it’s patrons would rather stay at home. I wouldn’t be so fast to assume that, though. Many people, including myself, love viewing films in theatres.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by brmgb on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @05:43AM (#16696541)
> I wonder what is preventing them from doing that

The 1948 USA vs Paramount antitrust decision might play a role. Content producers used to own theaters until they were forced to sell them to avoid excessive vertical integration.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by TomMarius on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:57AM (#16696172)
I would definitely go see a Netflix movie in a cinema, most probably even often, e.g. 3 times a month.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by paulgb on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:39PM (#16692012)
Just as no business inherently deserves to exist, no distribution model inherently needs to be allowed to submit films to Cannes.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by leggomylibro on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:07PM (#16692257)
Sure, Cannes can do whatever they want, but it hardly makes me feel like they are an institution whose opinions are likely to have much relevance to my experience.

Their recommendations get colored by their pettiness, sort of like how the Academy's presentations tend to feel disingenuous. It feels like the quality of the work often isn't what is being judged, so...who cares?

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by kodablah on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:45PM (#16692089)
Of course. We should just reduce the value of winning since it's against an arbitrarily culled list of competitors.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by Retric on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:25PM (#16692412)
Exactly Cannes just became irrelevant IMO. I personally doubt any streaming service movie would win, but restricted rewards are meaningless. At the extreme, I can always offer an award that only I can win, but why would anyone care.

PS: Same thing IMO happened to the Emmys's when Shrek was prevented from winning 'best picture'. With one simple choice they became a joke.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by fenwick67 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @06:36PM (#16693436)
Can you elaborate about Shrek? I can't find anything on that (also the Emmys is for TV not movies).
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by Retric on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:18AM (#16696659)
Ops. Oscars sorry that's how little I care ;)

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academy_Award_for_Best_Anima... Has some er public history, but it was added specifically for Shreck.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by ieo2929 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @06:02PM (#16693159)
You’re conflating physics with human social organization.

If people want to organize around a certain set of ideals that’s up to them. Codifying it in their law is also up to them.

No one social organizational structure has an inherent right to exist unless the people seem to support it.

Argue brainwashing or propaganda is what maintains it, the reality is: thems the rules in France.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by chomp on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:49PM (#16691579)
Yes. The CNC wanted Netflix to show their movie in more than a measly 6 cinemas since it was showing at Cannes, and the windowing regulations require 3 years before a movie can go from cinema to streaming. This is mostly a protectionist cinema regulation, though there are talks to reduce it going on right now.

I'm not at all a fan of regulatory capture, but I do understand that you can't pay lip service to the spirit of Cannes - celebrate film and cinema, don't promote your streaming services.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by kodablah on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:40PM (#16692025)
> I don't understand where this cheerleading [...] started [...] these companies aren't banned at all. They are free to show them [...] regulations require [...] regulatory capture

After reading, I think it's clear why this "cheerleading" is occurring and it doesn't matter size. Most people probably think like I do and think that film should be judged on its own merits. If film celebration was really the primary goal, these types of rules would not be in place and they really would be "free to show them"...but we know that's not the case which means that film celebration is not the primary goal.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by mmanfrin on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:42PM (#16692048)

  and the windowing regulations require 3 years before a movie can go from cinema to streaming
I'm confused as to how you think this is acceptable and that Netflix is in the wrong for "promot[ing their] streaming service"?
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by s2g on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:54PM (#16692160)
So you watch it at home and suddenly it’s not art anymore.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by tlholaday on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:09PM (#16692270)
What you watch at home is `video`. What you watch in a movie theater is `cinéma`.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by thirdsun on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:03AM (#16695980)
Speak for yourself. Surely you understand that there's a wide spectrum between watching a film on a laptop with built-in speakers and the true theatre experience you mentioned.

Personally, I use a good projector and a high quality audio system in my living room and while not typical, I'd consider it far from unusual. Degrading any media consumption that happens at home in a blanket statement really doesn't add anything to the discussion.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by lsaferite on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:48PM (#16692596)
Was there a "/s" hidden in there somewhere?
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by openforce on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:20PM (#16692361)
I feel that difference will blow in the next decade. It will just be content, wherever you watch.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by openforce on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:16PM (#16692323)
Which company that creates content does not promote itself? By your logic, warner bros and other production houses should not display their signs before the movie starts. You seem to fail to see these streaming services as production houses, which is what they seem to have become.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by guelo on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:44PM (#16691530)
That's right, France actually has a law that after a movie is shown in a theatre it can't be streamed for 36 months.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by robotpony on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:59PM (#16692201)
This is the crux of the issue: that cinema hasn't caught up with streaming services. There's no reason to force people to wait to stream a movie, i.e., they could show movies and stream simultaneously, maximizing consumer choice (rather than maximizing cinema profits).
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by bunderbunder on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:53PM (#16692641)
> There's no reason to force people to wait to stream a movie

Wait, what, really?

> maximizing cinema profits

Ah, no, there it is.

This is a fight for survival. Cinema can't catch up; it's an industry that was built for business conditions that existed in a bygone world, back when the equipment for distributing and viewing high-quality video recordings was so prohibitively expensive that it didn't make sense for people to have it in their homes. It's going to (largely) disappear, but it can maybe squeeze out a few more years of existence by trying to use regulation, business deals and whatever other tricks to try and create a simulacrum of the conditions its existence is based on. Like for any middleman, those conditions are precisely a lack of consumer access via alternative channels.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by tracker1 on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @01:36AM (#16695609)
There's something fun and social about seeing some movies in the theater. I think options like ipic, AMC cinema suites and others, not to mention real IMAX are things you won't ever get at home.

That said, I can see the decline. I cringe every time I think of how much more concessions get priced upwards, in addition to ticket pricing. I don't think the market will bear too much more.

Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by robotpony on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @08:57PM (#16694233)
I should have said that there is no technical reason for delaying a streaming release, nor does it really affect the quality of the watching experience (assuming people have good streaming setups).
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by tanilama on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:38PM (#16692515)
Wow, that is really backwards. How could any French streaming service survives the law? I am surely don't want a service that only has movies 3 years old.
Re:Banning Netflix, Amazon from Festivals and Awards Is Wrong by mc32 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @10:49PM (#16694842)
I think the problem is explained by this[1] post in the previous discussion.

Essentially, you have to wait some time [36 mos.] before you can contractually stream after initial theatrical showing, which of course, is contrary to Netflix's whole money making model.

[1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16678392