News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by walrus01 on Monday March 26, 2018 @10:27PM (#16684653)
The only good Belkin product I have ever seen is their 12 outlet power strip. As a network engineer everything they make with an Ethernet/wifi interface is complete shit. But this is not really news, D-Link, Netgear, many of their competitors are also junk.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by callmekatootie on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:47AM (#16686246)
I did not have any issues with their router. But that's not what I remember Belkin for:

I was in conversation with their customer service on the phone and it disconnected. Frustrated, cause it meant I had to call them back and there was no guarantee that I would get the same agent again, I gave up calling them. However, in 5 minutes, I got a call back from them - the same agent called me back and did manage to resolve my issue.

This was in India and prior to that, such service was unheard of (and not many still have that even today).

The device did not give me much trouble so I don't completely agree with the above.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by fwgwgwgch on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @08:10AM (#16687498)
India or otherwise that's basically rare.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by azernik on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:17AM (#16686379)
That's kind of the curse of the consumer market. When it comes to that kind of appliance, consumers care about sticker price above all. It's a brutal race to the bottom.

I worked at Meraki, and institutionally we were deathly scared of dealing with that market; we were perfectly happy to stay in the enterprise market, where buyers were actually willing to pay for quality.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by duxup on Monday March 26, 2018 @10:58PM (#16684818)
Every Belkin product I owned was garbage... but just like you I ran across a couple power strips that are surprisingly good.

I don't know if they bought someone who knew what they were doing with power strips or what, but .... i'm still using them.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by walrus01 on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:08PM (#16684869)
I have a lot of these:

https://www.amazon.com/Belkin-12-Outlet-Protector-Protection...

My theory is that they are good because electrical safety is something that is actually regulated. UL and CE certification to sell as a consumer device. Whereas there is no penalty or regulation for shitty routers with shit firmware.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by duxup on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:23PM (#16684938)
Yup that is it, the other models are pretty capable too. I like your theory, that makes sense. Guys behind the power strips can pull the old "Nope can't cheap out here, there are standards!" While the guys working on the POS USB hub or dongle or whatever can't say the same.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by chx on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:36PM (#16685004)
> UL and CE certification to sell as a consumer device.

Reminder:

> CE marking does not provide any specific information to the consumer. It is not a quality assurance declaration, it does not show evidence of third-party testing, and it should not be confused with any independent certification mark of the type issued by international or European notified test bodies.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by janekm on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:00AM (#16685386)
That’s not entirely correct. The CE Mark is a representation by the manufacturer / authorised representative that the device conforms to all relevant European directives, including the electrical safety ones (which typically require additional marks and third party verification).
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by walrus01 on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:41PM (#16685030)
You are absolutely right. I meant the TÜV test mark for Europe. I'm more familiar with us-canada stuff.

https://www.esasafe.com/electricalproducts/marks

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by Tepix on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:22AM (#16686099)
There's also the CCC mark for the Chinese market.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by reaperducer on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @12:45PM (#16690307)
I think it's something of a natural progression with accessory companies.

Their core competency is something innocuous like mousepads and power strips. Then they advance into more delicate and complicated electronics and the wheels fall off the wagon.

It reminds me of the early and mid-1980's when office supply companies decided that they should branch out from selling paper to making floppy disks. They were cheap, especially in bulk, but over time they had a much higher failure rate.

Eventually the only brands you could count on to work properly were BASF, 3M, Elephant Memory Systems, and IBM. (And probably a couple of others)

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by thomastjeffery on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @06:31AM (#16686969)
To contrast, every Linksys product I have owned it fantastic, so long as you flash DD-WRT/tomato/etc.

My main complaint with Belkin is that you don't have that option.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by leemailll on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:39PM (#16685020)
Their power strips are pretty good, not so for another stuff I tried
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by aetherspawn on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:59AM (#16685685)
Well, the only Thunderbolt 2 to HDMI adapter I've used that actually worked well (and I tried 2 others .. they're expensive too, I must have spent ~$150 in the process) was the Belkin ones. The others didn't, for whatever reason, work when both Thunderbolt 2 ports were in use and the internal display was also turned on (on my '14 MBP).

Other dongles for example randomly lost one of the color channels, had noisy output, occasionally flickered black or didn't work when waking up from sleep.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by ghostly_s on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @12:28PM (#16690088)
Surely you're talking about MiniDP->HDMI adapters? Thunderbolt2 is also MiniDP, I'm not sure why a TB2>HDMI adapter would even exist.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by thrillgore on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @10:28AM (#16688700)
I actually got good mileage out of Netgear stuff, but two years ago I changed it out with an ASUS Router (AC66U) and I've been happy. They originally weren't aggressive with security flaws, but they've righted the ship on that.

D-Link gear is hot garbage.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by fro0116 on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:19PM (#16684920)
Do you have any recommendations for alternatives?
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by walrus01 on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:25PM (#16684951)
Separate the function of wifi and router. My home office, which is bottlenecked by the docsis3.0 last mile, is on a Ubiquiti edgerouter-x ($46) router. And then a single ubnt UAP-AC 2X2 MIMO, dual band 802.11ac AP ($79).

The OS on the ubnt edgerouter series is a fork of vyatta, which is Debian based.

Also for people who know what they are doing, a mikrotik rb3011 would be a good choice.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by stephen_g on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:07AM (#16685723)
I've generally found the Ubiquiti hardware to be a fair bit better than Mikrotik stuff (way better forwarding speeds with the accelerated Cavium processors in the EdgeRouters - except the ER-X, which doesn't have the hardware offload but is still useful). I find their web UI far less confusing too. I know some guys who have used Mikrotiks a lot and swear by it, but unless you're already experienced with Mikrotik interfaces I'd recommend the Ubiquiti.

They also have a really good command line interface - which is lucky, because the biggest downside with the Ubiquitis is that some (generally more obscure and advanced) features can't be configured through the web UI.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by oneweekwonder on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:44AM (#16685610)
> Also for people who know what they are doing

The recommendation for the rb3011; or winbox and routerOS in general?

While it is not perfect. I do not know of other vendors with open docs like the mikrotik wiki[0].

With winbox, wiki, and not to bad cli. I feel it a good starting point for non network engineers. Better then horrible web interface or arcane cli interface.

Any recommendations for someone that want to learn to know what they are doing?

[0]: https://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Main_Page

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by draugadrotten on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:47AM (#16685626)
Asus+Merlin firmware is what I am running now. Stable, with enough features included out of the box. Compared to the bundled horror from the TelCo I get nearly 3x wifi performance on -ac.

In the ski lodge, OpenWRT and a $20 TP-Link have uptime measured in years by now. OpenWRT is awesome.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by beagle3 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @10:20AM (#16688621)
Uptime in years mean you have no security - there has been a couple of horrible WPA2 faults fixed in the last year.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by chx on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:38PM (#16685015)
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by chrissnell on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @12:41AM (#16685298)
Problem with OpenWRT is that most people run it on garbage consumer-grade hardware.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by wtallis on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @04:03AM (#16686322)
As opposed to what, more expensive Ubiquiti hardware that uses the same processors and radios?
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by walrus01 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @12:46AM (#16685320)
The intentions of the developers are good, but just try getting full kernel level documentation out of a company like Broadcom.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by prolepunk on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @11:14AM (#16689262)
There's a bunch of 'reference' devices that runs OpenWRT well. The list is pretty long

https://openwrt.org/toh/views/toh_available_864

I personally had good experiences with TP-Link Archer C7 and GL Networks mini-routers.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by rhizome on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @12:20AM (#16685207)
That page is impossible.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by wiseleo on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:32AM (#16685547)
I love Asus networking products.

The N generation like the RT-N12 is dirt cheap now. I deploy them in client offices and they have uptime measured in years.

It's not WiFi Ac and I don't care. It stays stable, has guest WiFi networks, and usable firmware.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by chrissnell on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @12:40AM (#16685293)
Netgate router board with a mSATA drive and PFSense for the router. Ubiquiti APs for wireless. Run the Ubiquiti unifi software from a Docker image on your workstation or home server. Cisco SG-nnn series switches.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by jontro on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @11:09AM (#16689202)
Their USB-C docks for macbook pro works great. A lot better than other usb-c alternatives.

We also used the previous version for older macbooks with thunderbolt and never had a problem with them.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by pc86 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @08:21AM (#16687564)
What do you recommend for a simple home network with a few computers and mobile devices?
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by JustFinishedBSG on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @10:00AM (#16688405)
Ubiquiti or Mikrotik

"prosummer" brands

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by illegalsmile on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:12PM (#16690625)
I second Mikrotik. I think my little home AP for my small house was $50 and it's absolutely great.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by prolepunk on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @11:12AM (#16689242)
Everything that runs OpenWRT is usually a good choice. TP-Link?
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by cctt23 on Monday March 26, 2018 @10:36PM (#16684696)
The worst router I’ve ever seen was a D-Link. I was in a position where I had to provide support for it, and in the end I gave up and bought them an ASUS with my own money. It ended up being worth it, just in terms of time and aggravation saved. The software and firmware on the D-Link were garbage, and so was the actual build.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by reaperducer on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @12:28PM (#16690095)
I stopped using D-Link equipment after I had to work with an IP camera that would choke on the cron'ed FTP upload if the server welcome message had more than three lines. Fewer than three lines and everything was great. But when it tired to upload to a server that responded with more than three lines and the camera ate itself.
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by ieo2929 on Monday March 26, 2018 @10:45PM (#16684757)
Ubiquiti ftw

After a brief romance with VyOS and RPi based APs, Ubiquiti came along and swept me off my feet

Currently using their gear throughout a 300-ish person office. Easy to setup, no issues that weren’t our fault in the first place.

Great kit for startup and growing type situations

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by Roritharr on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:45AM (#16685614)
We use the Ubiquity Stuff and are also mostly happy, but it's not really as Enterprise-Grade as it tries to sell itself as.

We use the Ubiquity Security Gateway Pro and have for over a year now issues with it's WAN Fallback. In the beginning it simply wouldn't Fallback at all, after lot's of Customer Service and three patches it actually did it's thing, but since then whenever the fallback happened our whole connection got instable until the USG is restarted. Once we even had issues because the USG thought WAN was down because it couldn't reach Ubiquity's Ping site (It was down) and so the connection started flip-flopping between two stable connections.

Besides that the Ubiquity Needle is now firmly stuck into the arm of our Admins and all the Network Gear we buy is from Ubiquity.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by sitepodmatt on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @06:59AM (#16687100)
Yikes that is poor, you'd think they'd have at least a few big sites (not all on aws either) to validate connectivity problems against, or at least make it configurable. Doesn't Google have a connectivity validation site on an anycast ip replicate across their global DCs?
Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by jmiserez on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:46AM (#16685618)
Haven’t had a single issue with my Ubiquiti AP in 2 years. None of the other consumer-grade APs even came close, I had issues with all of them (Netgear, Linksys/Cisco, AVM, Zyxel, TP-Link, MicroTik, even Apple Airport), and I wasn’t buying the lowend models either.

Most needed reboots as they’d stop working from time to time, many had flaxy Wifi or sudden long network lags for no reason, and the MicroTik even bricked itself requiring a reflash of the firmware.

Things might be different when it comes to enterprise gear.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by ieo2929 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:01PM (#16690485)
Yup, every piece of “home user” gear I’ve tried has needed regular reboots, or failed in ~24 months.

I mean I was purposefully stress testing and can be a heavy user. Maybe it works fine for grandma doing some email and Facebook on an iPad

After great feels using it at work, setup Ubiquiti kit at home two years ago and only rebooted it when I decided to move the APs to improve signal coverage on the far end of our house.

For $100-ish an AP these days (my home units are the UniFi AP-AC Long Range on Amazon), I don’t see any reason to buy anything else

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by bronco21016 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @11:05AM (#16689154)
What was your experience with Raspberry Pi APs? I set one up for Americans traveling abroad on the original Pi B model and couldn’t get any reliability for the life of me. The VPN constantly broke down because of WiFi sleep issues.

Wondering if things are better with newer hardware.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by ktta on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @02:02PM (#16691109)
Raspberry Pis are horrible for that use case. I would suggest getting something like a TP-link WR810N or something from GL-inet if want a larger flash.

If raspberry Pi's CPU performance is absolutely necessary, use an Ethernet cable with WR810N.

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by ieo2929 on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @12:54PM (#16690413)
That was years ago at this point, we were using RPi 2s.

It became rather untenable once that office hit ~30 people.

There were external factors that had us accepting defeat. Picked up some used Ruckus gear on the cheap, which helped but wasn’t that nice to use

Re:Foxconn buys Belkin for $866M by ptaipale on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @08:27AM (#16687607)
Indeed. I've had more failures than I can tolerate with Belkin, Linksys, D-Link, Zyxel, TP-Link, Asus, ZTE, Huawei. They all tire up eventually - even if they work initially, the equipment runs hot and fails in a few months.

Some of them obey the Law of Plastic Box: a device in a plastic box does one thing but not more than that. A Huawei router is OK if I just do routing, no WLAN, and put a TP-Link box as a WLAN beside it. Etc.

The only exceptions I have had in consumer-priced equipment is Ubiquity, which is great, and a small Finnish company called Telewell (which make cheap plastic things in China but strangely has never failed for me). The UI with Telewell is still the typical consumer-grade Web UI.