News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by jdmichal on Monday March 26, 2018 @03:51PM (#16681911)
> AI is not preprogrammed to monitor a known input from a sensor to take a predefined action.

I guess one of my outstanding questions, which reading this only confirmed, is why this is the case? I mean, humans are pretty good examples of intelligence. And yet we still have and use these anti-collision systems. Because, in the end, when wrong decisions are made these systems save lives.

Why would AI-driven vehicles not have dedicated, single-purpose subsystems such as anti-collision? I mean, are we going to also remove ABS, because the AI could learn to modulate the brakes itself? How much are we going to push into AI, when the purpose-built systems are both functional and effective?

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by SlowRobotAhead on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:08PM (#16682050)
>I mean, are we going to also remove ABS, because the AI could learn to modulate the brakes itself?

This is the topic that I feel SDC enthusiasts forget. Not everything HAS TO BE AI. And we could maybe make steps towards SDC, not fantastic leaps that get people killed and really just get government involved where it doesn't need to be yet.

We could replace the ABS/ESP/traction control systems in current vehicles with a machine learning / deep learning system absolutely - that's not sexy though!

No one wants increments, they want whole self-driving cars right now - and while I have opinions about that, there is no doubt it's driving (pun intended) the industry.

Ideally, at first, we'd see components in consumer vehicles, and completely automated long haul trucks from A to B determined routes - but like I said, not sexy.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by couchand on Monday March 26, 2018 @10:10PM (#16684576)
> Ideally, at first, we'd see components in consumer vehicles

We do, though. Look at the cruise control or auto-park on a vehicle produced in the last few years. The totally autonomous car may make headlines, but these sorts of features will be what really make the technology ubiquitous.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by SlowRobotAhead on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:23AM (#16685501)
I work on ECUs like this. High end stuff is doing computer vision, but 99% of what is on the road is pre-calibrated motor/solenoid control and that’s all.

Even adaptive cruise, steel camera object “detection” are just pretty simple systems. Almost nothing is doing even pieces of what the whole-package SDCs are.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by phaedrus on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:19PM (#16682157)
This is a design trade-off that comes up all the time in automotive engineering. I own a couple of 90's-era Honda vehicles and what's interesting is although the cars are computerized, they also employ a number of semi-independent systems such as instrument gauges which directly connect to their own sensors even though a similar sensor connected to the engine control unit is right next to it, mechanical choke and coolant temperature modulators to intake air despite fuel injection, an "hydraulic computer" controlling part of the automatic transmission even though there is also a dedicated transmission control computer (which is itself redundant to making the transmission control an integrated feature of the engine control module).

To me this seems to make no design sense; why not bring all of the inputs into one central box with one computer control, and drive all of the outputs from this central box? But then who am I to argue that the separate / bespoke approach is not better, given Honda's reputation for reliability?

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by majormajor on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:31PM (#16682285)
Seems like classic, prudent, avoiding of single points of failure. Sounds reasonable, especially since computerization in cars was still pretty new back then.

For something like ABS, or emergency braking, we have established algorithms for this already, so why be in a hurry to offload that to a machine-learning black box? Is the math behind "we need to stop this car" so complex that AI is needed?

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by jvanderbot on Monday March 26, 2018 @06:39PM (#16683316)
> Why would AI-driven vehicles not have dedicated, single-purpose subsystems such as anti-collision? I mean, are we going to also remove ABS, because the AI could learn to modulate the brakes itself? How much are we going to push into AI, when the purpose-built systems are both functional and effective?

This makes me want to pull my hair out. No reasonable system relies on AI from top to bottom. Take this article with a grain of salt, it is attacking a straw-man.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by martinrebane on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:11PM (#16682633)
Author here :) I cannot answer for Uber, but the grand reason why we cannot put deterministic parts into the AI is the same as for humans - we do not control the internals of it, the complexity is too high. Although we can build systems that are composed of both AI and deterministic collision avoidance (as seen on new cars today). It is what I also suggested in the article.
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by wnoise on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:52PM (#16682978)
Ah, then I should complain to you that "AI" is a broad suite of techniques and goals, rather than a specific black-box technique which has these flaws.
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by andreyk on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @12:27AM (#16685236)
Yes - you really seem to be talking about Machine Learning (a subset of AI). And as another comment says 'This makes me want to pull my hair out. No reasonable system relies on AI [or ML] from top to bottom. Take this article with a grain of salt, it is attacking a straw-man.'
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by andreyk on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:27AM (#16686137)
"Why would AI-driven vehicles not have dedicated, single-purpose subsystems such as anti-collision? "

The answer is that they will. And probably already mostly do (at least for Waymo/Cruise/most of them). It's not clear why Uber's vehicle did not brake.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by mulmen on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:11PM (#16682081)
I don't know much about AI or ML and even less about how it relates to automotive engineering but I imagine this is already how it works. I don't think there is one model for everything as much as there are models for individual components of driving. Something for steering, something(s?) for identifying obstructions, etc.

In this case maybe letting a model modulate brake pulses based on conditions like temperature and velocity makes more sense?

Hopefully someone with more experience in this domain can enlighten us.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by skgoa on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:19AM (#16686077)
It is exactly how it works. There ~40-115 different computers in a modern car that often have completely walled-off modules running on them. Most 'models' you will find in a car's software aren't even generated through machine learning, but tried and true engineering/statistics.

No one in their right mind is proposing to replace those with one big AI monolith. That's marketing BS from the likes of NVidia, who would stand to gain from it.

AI is being used in certain subfunctions like visual object detection. In the future, AI will be used to make higher level decisions like trajectory (lane choice, overtaking etc.) and route planning. But it will only hand those higher level plans down to the mostly 'dumb' computer systems of the car to be carried out just as with a manually driven car.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by CardenB on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:50PM (#16682963)
The false positive rate of this system could be very noisy. At what point should you brake, even if the AI says not to? When you might collide with a lidar point? You want to collide with lidar points all the time (the ground beneath the vehicle, for example, or any reflective noise). The AI is there to tell you what lidar points are actual obstacles that you can't collide with, otherwise it's not really meaningful.
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by jdmichal on Monday March 26, 2018 @07:24PM (#16683658)
This line of argument doesn't mean anything when we already have cars with intelligent, independent drivers, and these systems. And yes, their purpose would be to override the AI control when they trigger. Exactly the same as they do right now.
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by jmalicki on Monday March 26, 2018 @07:15PM (#16683592)
" I mean, are we going to also remove ABS, because the AI could learn to modulate the brakes itself?"

I think that's a reasonable definition of ABS - an AI (in most cases for ABS, an expert system AI) that knows how to best mediate the brakes, with levels of performance that exceed the vast majority of humans.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by ams6110 on Monday March 26, 2018 @09:08PM (#16684267)
The conventional ABS system is not AI in any sense. It is a few sensors and maybe some look up tables of what to do under various speed / brake pressure / wheel rotation situations
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by randomdata on Monday March 26, 2018 @11:36PM (#16685005)
Does that not fit the definition of artificial intelligence? The system makes decisions – ones that would be otherwise done by a human – based on its perception of the world. That is what I have always understood AI to mean. To be sure, a conventional ABS system does not use machine learning, but machine learning is only a subset of AI.
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by lolikoisuru on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @05:58AM (#16686828)
By this definition almost all software would be an AI.

Making decisions or reacting to stimuli does not necessarily require any form of intelligence. You probably meant automation instead of "AI".

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by skgoa on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:22AM (#16686103)
The core of this debate is the matter of what intelligence actually is. We don't really know, but the most common definition I have heard/read is that intelligence is the ability to generate new solutions when presented with previously unseen input. An ABS would not qualify under this definition, because its output is predefined rigorously for all possible combinations of input values.
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by randomdata on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @08:51AM (#16687771)
On the other hand, artificial intelligence is not actual intelligence. The definition of artificial intelligence is the ability to perform a task that would normally require human intelligence. An ABS system would fit into this definition as it is a task that normally would require human sensing the conditions to know how to apply the breaks.

Although I can see why some point out that AI is a moving target, representing only what still seems 'magical'. If you showed an ABS system to someone in the early 1900s, I truly believe they would see it as some kind of intelligence. Now that we have acclimated to the technology, we don't see it the same way.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by lolikoisuru on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @09:11AM (#16687932)
>The definition of artificial intelligence is the ability to perform a task that would normally require human intelligence.

Do you have any specific sources that define it as that?

>An ABS system would fit into this definition as it is a task that normally would require human sensing the conditions to know how to apply the breaks.

Responding to stimuli does not require any intelligence, let alone human intelligence.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by randomdata on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @10:37AM (#16688802)
> Do you have any specific sources that define it as that?

Several definitions as provided by a Google Search.

> Responding to stimuli does not require any intelligence, let alone human intelligence.

Which is why we call it artificial intelligence instead of intelligence. If these systems were actually intelligent, there would be no reason to add the artificial moniker. We specifically call the types of systems artificial intelligence on recognition that it is not actually what we consider real intelligence.

I agree, there is nothing intelligent about an ABS system, and nobody is labeling it as intelligent.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by jdmichal on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @11:16AM (#16689278)
"Artificial" is opposed to "natural", not "genuine". It's a synonym of "machine intelligence". It's a comment on the fact that the intelligence has been artificially created in a machine. It is not in any way about the current capabilities of artificial intelligence.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_intelligence

> Artificial intelligence (AI, also machine intelligence, MI) is intelligence demonstrated by machines, in contrast to the natural intelligence (NI) displayed by humans and other animals.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by lolikoisuru on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:02PM (#16690495)
>I agree, there is nothing intelligent about an ABS system, and nobody is labeling it as intelligent.

Artificial intelligence is intelligence, just made artificially instead of organically. You clearly have no understanding of the term so you should probably shut up.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by 8note on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @08:18AM (#16687550)
You wouldn't consider it AI because it's good at it's job. We only consider things to be AI while they suck at making decisions.
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by wnoise on Monday March 26, 2018 @10:17PM (#16684610)
That doesn't make it not an AI -- it makes it a very simple, explicable AI. Unless you follow the definition that AI is whatever we don't know how to program yet.
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by lolikoisuru on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @06:02AM (#16686843)
What definition of AI do you use that would qualify ABS as an AI but wouldn't also include majority of all software ever written?
Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by wnoise on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:41PM (#16692039)
There is no sharp line, just as there is no sharp line for "intelligence". Lot of software can indeed be classified as (very weak) AI, because it makes decisions in service of a goal.

Because there is no sharp line, where to draw the line depends on context, and the point being made. I have found that "AI" is a good term to apply when it is more useful to take the intentional stance[+] to explain an artificial system's behavior than to trace the actual low-level implementation.

At the very lowest end I could include some closed-loop control as AI (a simple proportional controller wouldn't count, a PID might). The more complex the model it has of the environment, and it's own effect on the environment, the more useful it is to call it an AI.

A slightly more complex example are computer games, whose simple AIs are generally readily explainable from their code. In an RTS game with good AI, it's not useful to look at how computer opponents (or my own units) do pathing, only where they're trying to go, and the obstacles they'll encounter.

ABS is lower than I would normally consider AI to be a useful descriptor because of how little information processing occurs (basically just wheel speed and brake pedal trajectory). In this context it's worth not excluding precisely to emphasize that AI is not just machine learning, but just about anything that autonomously makes intelligent decisions in response to changing environments.

[+] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intentional_stance

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by lolikoisuru on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @01:00AM (#16695414)
So in your mind the difference between AI (which you define very loosely) and any other program is just the scope and complexity.

>Lot of software can indeed be classified as (very weak) AI, because it makes decisions in service of a goal.

So take GNU make for example. It makes decisions of what to build in service of the goal of building some target you specified. Is GNU make an AI? By this definition it would be.

>At the very lowest end I could include some closed-loop control as AI (a simple proportional controller wouldn't count, a PID might).

Why would artifical intelligence have any requirement of runnig continuously? Is this a requirement for intelligence or is it just an arbitrary requirement you came up with to narrow down your very loose definition of AI? Now is Nginx an AI? It runs continuously and makes decisions of what to serve over HTTP. How about Bays spam filters? Those run contiuously (at least some of them) and make decisions of what to classify as spam.

>The more complex the model it has of the environment, and it's own effect on the environment, the more useful it is to call it an AI.

Making the complexity a requirement for AI is a bit silly as well. What if someone comes up with a very simple way of building an artificial intelligence? Just smells like you want to be able to use "it's not complex enough" as an argument for things that would otherwise fit your definition of AI. The problem with your definition seems to be that it doesn't include intelligence.

>ABS is lower than I would normally consider AI to be a useful descriptor because of how little information processing occurs (basically just wheel speed and brake pedal trajectory).

This is exactly what I mean.

>anything that autonomously makes intelligent decisions in response to changing environments.

So now you're trying to bandaid the definition even more. In the beginning of your comment your AI didn't require any intelligence but now it has to make intelligent decisions. How about you define intelligence before you start defining artificial intellgence? But this still wouldn't disqualify an ABS from your definition of AI since it most certainly does make intellignet decisions autonymously in response to changing environments.

Re:Why collision avoidance is harder for an AI-based system by wnoise on Thursday March 29, 2018 @02:36PM (#16709788)
I'm not patching up the definition -- I'm refusing to give a definition. As a consolation prize, I'm giving examples and discussing the degree to which they fit the central concept.

My stance is that "AI or not" is not an inherent way of dividing up systems in the universe. The best attempt to answer will provide a degree, rather than a binary yes/no. Further, the degree is based on utility to humans to think about the system that way. Thus no bright line, and a multitude of context-dependent factors that weigh towards or against it. If you must force a cut-off somewhere, then that threshold is context-dependent too.