However, the fact remains that my health insurance options have generally been worse and more expensive since ACA passed. This year, thankfully, I am on employer healthcare plan instead. Because in my area, with the ACA, there is one provider only, and none of the plans are good, and they're all more expensive than before, and at least 2x what I was paying pre-ACA and with MUCH MUCH higher deductables.
Your options are fewer now because you have to be bigger to able to absorb the costs of the extremely high cost individuals such as those with anemia and premature babies and cancer patients.
Everything you’re experiencing is because more people are getting access to healthcare, and instead of everyone paying for it via higher taxes, we’re paying for it via higher premiums and deductibles.
Only way to bring relief is through more supply of healthcare, which means more doctors (they lobby against that) and more medicine (they lobby against that too).
One solution is to marry a doctor so you can take advantage of the situation.
e.g. the US as more doctors per capita than the UK and Canada - both of which have much lower healthcare costs than the US.
Later, after some health issues <cough> first child diagnosed with T1D <cough> we were grandfathered into the private plans and the premiums did not change but the deductible was pretty high and the network was not great.
Later, and this was still pre-ACA - California had guarantee issue health insurance with little or no rating factor adjustment (surcharge) for companies with 2-50 employees. So I hired my wife and we switched to one of those plans. Premiums around $800/mo and $2k deductibles. That was about the time when our 2nd child was diagnosed with T1D.
When ACA passed all CA guaranteed issue small business plans disappeared and everything switched over to marketplace. Silver plans for $2,000/mo for the family and $2,000 deductibles with $12,500 our of pocket max. Basically every spare penny went to healthcare, and then some, and we were slowly drowning in debt because of it.
Finally, I stepped off the treadmill, stopped taking a salary, and we switch to Medicaid. And went from spending $35,000/yr out-of-pocket after tax on healthcare to spending $0.
ACA unquestionably increased premiums and total cost for my family substantially, until I stopped taking a salary and went on Medicaid at which point ACA was a god-send due to Medicaid expansion / cost-sharing reductions.
For a healthy family of 4 ACA is horrifically expensive and acts as an extraordinary tax on middle class families who start earning too much for the subsidies. The marginal effective tax rates are so high, the CBO doesn’t have the guts to publish them with the ACA subsidy phase-out included in the calculations.