Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency
by wpietri on Monday March 26, 2018 @03:42AM
(#16677302)
> Also, the onus to prove the claim that digital marketing has an effect is not logically on the interlocutor, but on the claimant.
No, not really. You're making the extraordinary claim that it has no effect, that millions of businesses are independently making the same mistake.
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency
by tomrod on Monday March 26, 2018 @09:44AM
(#16678776)
No, I'm asking for proof that it works over alternative baselines. If people already decided to purchase a product offered, the ad sets up a costly, unnecessary channel.
As was stated by another in this thread, prisoner's dilemma leads to unintuitive economic outcomes.
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency
by wpietri on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @07:16PM
(#16693701)
If you're saying it's an arms race, sure, nobody's denying that. But that doesn't mean that it doesn't work, it just means that in general and over time particular markets are mostly at equilibrium.
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency
by stale2002 on Sunday March 25, 2018 @06:24PM
(#16674996)
What he is saying is, the fact that hundreds of billions of dollars get spent on advertising IS the proof.
That's the evidence. Companies don't waste money for no reason. And so the only reason that they could be spending this amount of money is because it works.
So yes I'd say that this type of argument counts as a "proof".
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency
by verylittlemeat on Sunday March 25, 2018 @06:32PM
(#16675035)
It's not really any kind of proof. I don't want to clutter up the thread with identical content so I'll just link you to my reply.
Re:It’s time for a digital protection agency
by wpietri on Sunday March 25, 2018 @08:41PM
(#16675641)
I agree entirely that it's a total waste from the societal perspective (which is why I say we should ban it). But it can be very effective from the individual advertiser's point of view. That's true of any arms race.
I believe that tomrod is claiming the latter is also false.
[0] https://courses.cit.cornell.edu/jl2545/4550/materials/lewisr...
Also, the onus to prove the claim that digital marketing has an effect is not logically on the interlocutor, but on the claimant.
Knowing many marketing folks across many industries, their incentives aren't usually tied to incremental lift but rather gross channel volume. So if they can cannibalize from more effective sales or advertising channels they do so, without qualms.
I've heard the claim like grandparent comment has made before for years. Yet, when pushed, it is suddenly a golden cow. This is concerning, precisely due to the figure you cite of billions of dollars.