At some point, stellar converted lumens to stellar. Anyone know if that would be considered a taxable event? Did that change my basis?
You're citing existing precedents/case law that has been decided. The cryptocurrency cases have not yet been adjudicated by the tax court, so as an individual filer, I would be comfortable taking any reasonably justifiable position and defending it in audit if needed.
I would put more weight on the possibility of considering it a 1031 like-kind exchange, than a tax free merger/reorganization . Although I don't have a lot of exposure to the 1031 rules to know if there's a clear objection there.
Holy crap do we need reform.
It seems perfectly reasonable to me that income is income regardless of whether it is dollars or magic beans and that gains on investments are taxed largely without regard for the form of the investment.
[1]: if we're pragmatic about it, cryptocoins can't be used for much on their own
1. Wash sale rules (where buying a substantially identical security within 30 days before or after a sale-for-a-loss disallows the loss)
2. Section 1031 exchanges
The only reform I see needed is that exchanges could help facilitate reporting these transactions.