Re:Research finds repressed memories don't exist
by rimantas on Monday September 06, 2010 @03:04PM
(#1667208)
If anything it seems to suggest that repression would be a
successful strategy if it could be managed.
Eveolutionary memory repression would be a bit like feeling no pain: increased risk to get hurt again.
Re:Research finds repressed memories don't exist
by Groxx on Monday September 06, 2010 @03:34PM
(#1667258)
That argument can go both ways. If the pain of the memory is causing you to be hurt more, then repressing it is to your benefit.
Given what depression does to people, based on that argument alone, I'd say evolution strongly favors repression of any rare trauma.
I don't see how this contradicts the notion that there could be people who would repress memories. If anything it seems to suggest that repression would be a successful strategy if it could be managed. By their argument there could be a substantial population or 'successful repressers' that never seek therapy and could resist all efforts to stimulate memory of repressed events. It would only be the population of 'unsuccessful repressers' that they would ever get to see. That could, of course, then be further confused by a population of people who, for whatever reason, experience faked memories.