News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by madez on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:02AM (#16665802)
Why is the economic and technological rise of China a problem?
Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by foodislove on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:06AM (#16665815)
It's not.

It's the zero-sum thinking of a totalitarian dictatorship that's a problem. For example, simply letting the Taiwanese live their own free and happy lives is too much of "a problem" to let go without threatening invasion on a weekly basis :)

Also, there is geopolitics at play. The Thucydides Trap is real.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by wyattpeak on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:13AM (#16665837)
While I agree that their attitudes towards Taiwan are inappropriate, it's a stretch to suggest that this is an issue of totalitarian government. There's not a major government on earth (and probably not a minor one), of any political persuasion, which hasn't faced and rejected an attempt at secession.
Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by factsaresacred on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:31AM (#16665884)
> an attempt at secession.

Please. Taiwan is not a part of the PRC. What would they be seceding from? They're a sovereign State founded by the losers of China's civil war. (That the Nationalists lost is one of China's great tragedies given the horrors that Mao and the ruling party inflicted on the Chinese people and their traditions).

Anyway, take Japan and the Senkaku islands as another example of Chinese bellicose jingoism fueled by a policy of nationalism designed to detract from threats to its legitimacy.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by wyattpeak on Saturday March 24, 2018 @11:46AM (#16667159)
> Taiwan is not a part of the PRC

According to Taiwan. How does this theory play with the American civil war? The confederate states didn't consider themselves part of the union. Was the North therefore imposing sovereignty on a foreign nation?

They were both fighting for sovereignty of all of China. After the war they both continued to consider themselves to be sovereign to all China. Indeed, to this day they both make that claim.

For what it's worth, I agree that to all practical intents they are separate nations and should be such. I think both nations should drop their claims on each other. But only due to the fact that it's been the de facto situation for seventy years. I see no reason why the losing side of a civil war is instantly granted nationhood on cessation of fighting.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by mafribe on Saturday March 24, 2018 @11:59AM (#16667249)
The ROC is doing itself no favours by sticking to its interpretation of the One China Policy which entails that the ROC leadership is the solve legitimate ruler of the mainland, too! When the PRC was weak, there was probably an opening where the ROC could have dropped its pretensions towards ruling the mainland, in exchange for PRC acceptance of ROC nationhood. But I suspect its too late now, since the PRC is so powerful now.

I also think the real reason why the PRC leadership is bullying the ROC is that the ROC is a clear example that democracy, wealth and Chinese culture are perfectly compatible -- thus falsifying the communist's party's justification of its claim to power.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by wyattpeak on Saturday March 24, 2018 @12:24PM (#16667383)
I agree, I really don't see what they get out of it. It seems only to legitimise the PRC's claim on Taiwan by making it a mutual disagreement.

I don't know about the concerns re democracy, the Chinese people I hear speaking about it don't seem to have much interest in Western democracy whether or not they could live under it, but I don't have a strong enough understanding of the issue to really claim to understand.

And I suppose the fact that their people don't care wouldn't necessarily assuage a sufficiently paranoid government.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by YorkshireSeason on Saturday March 24, 2018 @12:37PM (#16667452)

   what they get out of it
My interpretation is that the ROC sees this as a bargaining chip, to be given up in exchange for something else, at an opportune moment. The ROC doesn't have much else to offer to the mainland at the moment
[dead]
Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by gurkendoktor on Saturday March 24, 2018 @07:07AM (#16665999)
> Talk to the Taiwanese themselves.

I have to ask, have you actually done this? From a random 2017 poll[1]:

>> Three quarters of Taiwanese people think Taiwan and China are two separate countries, while only about 14 per cent believe they are both part of one nation

Or[2]:

>> For Taiwanese younger than 40, pro-independence support reaches 84 percent. Perhaps most startling, 43 percent of the under-40 generation would support independence even if it meant China would attack Taiwan under the risk of war.

Polls conducted by pro-China and pro-Taiwan media typically have slightly different numbers, but the trend across polls is crystal clear, and matches my experience from living there for ~4 years.

It's true that the ROC constitution claims all of the mainland for historical reasons. The thing is, if Taiwan were to give up that claim, they'd probably trigger the PRC's anti-secession law and get sucked into a war. Holding up this territorial claim as a proof that the Taiwanese see themselves as a part of China is extremely cynical.

[1] http://www.scmp.com/news/china/policies-politics/article/209...

[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2017/01/0...

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by dnomad on Saturday March 24, 2018 @07:40AM (#16666112)
To your point I think attitudes have recently shifted a lot. As little as 10 years ago my experience was that many Taiwanese regarded themselves as Chinese even though they regarded the PRC as wholly illegitimate. It's still the case, I believe, that no major political party has declared independence as part of their platform. Whether this is because such a position would be wholly unconstitutional or because China would invade is debatable. As you point out, the Taiwanese government from the very beginning, and as recorded in the constitution, has regarded themselves as the true rulers of China and not viewed themselves as a separate nation state. Given this the PRC position that Taiwan is a breakaway province and is part of China is understandable.
Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by gurkendoktor on Saturday March 24, 2018 @09:08AM (#16666419)
> As you point out, the Taiwanese government from the very beginning, and as recorded in the constitution, has regarded themselves as the true rulers of China and not viewed themselves as a separate nation state.

When the ROC was established in 1912, Taiwan was not a part of China. It's misleading to refer to that as the very beginning of the Taiwanese government.

The ROC government has only been indicative of the will of the Taiwanese people since democratization in the 1990s.

> It's still the case, I believe, that no major political party has declared independence as part of their platform. Whether this is because such a position would be wholly unconstitutional or because China would invade is debatable.

It's a bit of a tautology that declaring independence would be unconstitutional, because the constitution is the key piece of what needs to be updated.

IANAL, but I think it's even possible to achieve independence within the framework of the current constitution since it guarantees the right to referendums. The government would need to change the scope of referendums by passing a law (see [1]), and then the referendum would have to succeed.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_Republic_o...

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by factsaresacred on Saturday March 24, 2018 @08:07AM (#16666223)
> Both the ROC and the PRC view Taiwan as part of China and view themselves as the legitimate government of all of China.

Right, that's not what we're talking about though. The point is that Taiwan is not a part of the PRC and so the idea of 'seceding' from anything is absurd.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by mafribe on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:55AM (#16665960)
Anecdata: I have spent a great deal of time in Taiwan, and have not met a Taiwanese person who wanted to unify with the mainland, especially as long as the mainland was governed by the communist party. Let's not forget that a great deal of Taiwanese fled from the communists.

What is true is that many Taiwanese fear the mainland and think peaceful surrender is preferable to a military invasation by the mainland. Many Taiwanese fear that nobody will defend them if/when the Mainland invades.

Note also that the Taiwanese look to Hong Kong, and observe the slow erosion of the vestiges of democracy there.

[dead]
Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by mafribe on Saturday March 24, 2018 @10:14AM (#16666670)
I'm quite aware of HK's status under British rule. I'm also aware that it was dramatically better than Mao's rule.

What I was referring to was the erosion of rights since the takeover of HK by the PRC. Looking at your commenting history here on HN, I see quite a bit of love for dictatorships, and hatred for democracy. For this reason, I assume that you knew very well that I was referring to the erosion of rights since the takeover of HK, but decided to derail the thread, so as to avoid discussing the anti-democratic nature of the current PRC government, and the threat this poses to Taiwan.

> WHITE governors of HK

I'm a bit unhappy about your blatant racism. Please ponder the following question: how many non-Chinese General Secretaries of the Communist Party of China can you point me towards?

Note that UK governors did a much better job of ruling HK than did Mao and his cronies in China.

Note that it was only when Deng Xiaoping decided to copy the UK model that was trialled in HK and Singapore, that Mainland China stopped being a basket case.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by mafribe on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:34AM (#16665893)
Taiwan did not seceed (or has been trying to seceed) from the mainland in any meaningful sense. It is questionable if Taiwan was ever legitimately governed by the mainland.

Moreover, there are plenty of examples of a peaceful handling of secession, the most famous recent example being Page move-protected the Scottish independence referendum of 2014 [1]. Here are some other examples:

- Saar Statute referendum 1955 [2]

- Gibraltar sovereignty referenda in 1967 [3] and 2002 [4]

- Falkland Islands sovereignty referendum 2013 [5]

- Velvet Divorce of Czechoslovakia into the Czech Republic and Slovakia [6]

- Brexit vote [7]

- The Catalan independence referendum of 2017 [8] is an interesting edge case: it was conducted peacefully, albeit without active support from the Spanish government.

In the 21 century, China should be leading by example, and demonstrate the ability for peaceful conflict resolution, rather than fall back into 19th century power politics.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottish_independence_referend...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saar_Statute_referendum,_1955

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibraltar_sovereignty_referend...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibraltar_sovereignty_referend...

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falkland_Islands_sovereignty_r...

[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dissolution_of_Czechoslovakia

[7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brexit

[8] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalan_independence_referendu...

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by coupdetaco on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:49AM (#16665936)
Do you think there is reason to believe that the thucydides trap would be either mitigated or amplified by global connectivity.
Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by foodislove on Saturday March 24, 2018 @07:27AM (#16666066)
Historically speaking, the only significant peaceful comparison would be the British -> US circa 1950s.

To be fair, people asked the same question in the 1900s. With the world getting so interconnected thanks to steamships and telegraphs, perhaps the age of major conflict had passed (this was right before ww1).

Also, global connectivity doesn't mean much when the great firewall creates 2 distinctly different internets. If you take Chinese state media as a barometer of public opinion, you clearly see there is very little affinity towards the rest of the world. The xenophobia and nationalism, if anything, is more likely to lead to conflict because nationalism is a double edged sword.

Best case scenario is the status quo. Even though China wants a bigger say in global affairs, they realize they have benefited from a peaceful international system over the last half-century and it's in their interest to preserve it largely intact. They have some long-term plays like "one belt" infrastructure, but that's something to supplement the existing system rather than to replace.

Personally I think the most likely risk is economic. No country can escape the laws of economics forever. At some point, the economy will have a downturn. Like with Putins Russia, when things are bad domestically, there is pressure to create conflict abroad (aka Ukraine) to distract their people which if managed badly, could turn out quite ugly

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by adinobro on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:10AM (#16665827)
Which is completely different to the US and Cuba...
Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by adventured on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:16AM (#16665845)
Indeed it is entirely different.

The US isn't seeking to annex Cuba, and Cuba is entirely free to trade with the rest of the world.

China threatens and throws tantrums if Taiwan so much as gets any recognition from other nations. China doesn't even want Taiwan's leader to be able to directly speak to the US, or for their politicians to be able to visit the US.

If Raul Castro gets on a plane and goes to France or South Africa, the US doesn't threaten unspecified severe consequences for just talking to or meeting with Casto.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by dnomad on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:42AM (#16665916)
Yeah, this is dumb. From China's perspective Taiwan is as much a part of China as Florida is part of the US. How would the US react if Florida declared itself independent and began negotiating treaties with foreign governments?

In fact we have good precedent for how the US deals with breakaway states. From that point of view China has shown remarkable constraint when dealing with what most people, including the Tawainese themselves, agree is a part of China.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by westiseast on Saturday March 24, 2018 @08:30AM (#16666282)
The Florida comparison isn’t really apt - indeed a lot of the comparisons/equivalents being drawn in this thread conveniently ignore key elements.

* PRC (the CCP) considers Taiwan to be part of the PRC (and part of ‘China’ the country). At best it’s referred to as a breakaway province.

* The ROC considers themselves to be ‘China’, and part of ‘China’, but not subject to CCP rule or a province of the PRC.

* The CCP has no actual direct rule over Taiwan in practice. Taiwanese people vote for their leaders, have their own laws, don’t follow PRC laws in any sense, hold separate Taiwanese currency and passports, require mainland visitors to acquire a visa, have independent trade deals and defense treaties with other sovereign nations etc etc.

Regardless of what you think should happen, anyone suggesting comparisons with Cuba/USA, Scotland/UK, Florida/USA etc is either ignorant, or deliberately muddying the waters to score an ideological point.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by mafribe on Saturday March 24, 2018 @10:32AM (#16666755)
Why is a comparison with Scotland/UK ignorant, or deliberately muddying the waters? I'd say it would demonstrate great political maturity, if the PRC were to allow Taiwan to conduct a binding vote about independence, and accept the outcome.

It would greatly increase the PRC's standing in the world, and its soft power. Right now, basically nobody trusts the PRC, and their increasing influence is simply a consequence of their spreading money around.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by westiseast on Saturday March 24, 2018 @11:40AM (#16667130)
It’s a bad comparison because the actual, legal and historical situations are vastly different.

eg.

> if the PRC were to allow Taiwan to conduct...

Taiwan is de facto an independent country. The only extent to which the PRC can ‘allow’ or not allow something to happen in Taiwan is with the threat of invasion, which is vastly different to how the UK parliament ‘allowed’ Scotland to conduct an independence referendum.

I’m not saying that it wouldn’t be desirable for the PRC to remove the threat of military action and recognize a fair and binding referendum, but comparisons with Scotland tend to imply that Taiwan/China situation is just like UK/Scotland. Which is isn’t even slightly.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by mafribe on Saturday March 24, 2018 @12:03PM (#16667269)
I agree that the actual, legal and historical situations ROC/PRC vs UK/Scotland are quite different. I was pointing towards the similarity of a (potential) positive, peaceful resolution, -- indeed one where secession was ultimately rejected. Who knows, maybe a peaceful, gentle PRC can tempt the ROC into a peaceful union?

I should have expressed myself more clearly.

> Taiwan is de facto an independent country.

Taiwan should formally be an independent country in a just world, but de facto every political decision in Taiwan in made in the shadow of the immediate threat of PRC violence. Ultimately political power comes "from the barrel of a gun" and the PRC has a lot more barrels than the ROC.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by whatyoucantsay on Saturday March 24, 2018 @09:26AM (#16666483)
> what most people, including the Tawainese themselves, agree is a part of China.

I truly cannot distinguish if you're trolling or serious. You continue repeating the same points throughout this thread and they are not true. Taiwan has never been part of the PRC. Before the KMT invaded, Taiwan was part of the Japanese Empire. Claiming the PRC gets all territory once owned by the Qing Dynasty is roughly equivalent to Germany claiming all territory once owned by Prussia. It doesn't lead anywhere pleasant.

Your comments are reprehensible and I wish for you never have the experience of your home being under constant threat from an increasingly wealthy and aggressive neighbor.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by mafribe on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:49AM (#16665937)
If it was true that "most people, including the Tawainese themselves, agree is a part of China", then mainland China would/should have no problem whatsoever with a binding Taiwanese independence referendum.

It is precisely because mainland China knows very well that the majority of Taiwanese want independence, that the mainland objects to free and fair independence referendum. The mainland assumes they would loose.

   * * *
The secession of US states is clarified in the US constitution [1], and the US Supreme Court, in Texas v. White [2], ruled unilateral secession unconstitutional, while commenting that revolution or consent of the States could lead to a successful secession. Note that Texas v. White happened over a century ago.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secession_in_the_United_States

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_v._White

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by dis-sys on Saturday March 24, 2018 @07:38AM (#16666106)
independence referendum? such as the recent Catalan independence referendum in Spain? Why EU/US both rejected its outcome when the people of Catalan clearly made the case with a successful & peaceful independence referendum?
Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by mafribe on Saturday March 24, 2018 @10:25AM (#16666732)
That referendum is an interesting edge case, as I wrote in my post above. Spain could have handled the Catalan issue much better, that is certainly true. One crucial difference is that neither the EU nor the Spanish government threaten violence and military invasion. This contrasts very favourably with Xi Jinping and his cronys incessant bullying of Taiwan.
Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by sremani on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:09AM (#16665825)
Geopolitically U.S. sees China as a potential challenger but that is not the main problem, an emerging China will make Japan militarize. While the world is focused on Xi's power grab, Abe is taking steps for militarizing Japan.

Its too early to say they are in collision course, but lets put it this way, if the balance of power tilts too fast .. some one will "push the button" of war.

Re:For the U.S. And China, a Technology Cold War That’s Free... by wyattpeak on Saturday March 24, 2018 @06:16AM (#16665848)
What? America's been trying to get Japan to militarise for years. Their reticence thus far is generally described as free-riding, not some move for the common good.