According to Taiwan. How does this theory play with the American civil war? The confederate states didn't consider themselves part of the union. Was the North therefore imposing sovereignty on a foreign nation?
They were both fighting for sovereignty of all of China. After the war they both continued to consider themselves to be sovereign to all China. Indeed, to this day they both make that claim.
For what it's worth, I agree that to all practical intents they are separate nations and should be such. I think both nations should drop their claims on each other. But only due to the fact that it's been the de facto situation for seventy years. I see no reason why the losing side of a civil war is instantly granted nationhood on cessation of fighting.
I also think the real reason why the PRC leadership is bullying the ROC is that the ROC is a clear example that democracy, wealth and Chinese culture are perfectly compatible -- thus falsifying the communist's party's justification of its claim to power.
I don't know about the concerns re democracy, the Chinese people I hear speaking about it don't seem to have much interest in Western democracy whether or not they could live under it, but I don't have a strong enough understanding of the issue to really claim to understand.
And I suppose the fact that their people don't care wouldn't necessarily assuage a sufficiently paranoid government.
what they get out of it
My interpretation is that the ROC sees this as a bargaining chip,
to be given up in exchange for something else, at an opportune
moment. The ROC doesn't have much else to offer to the mainland at the
momentI have to ask, have you actually done this? From a random 2017 poll[1]:
>> Three quarters of Taiwanese people think Taiwan and China are two separate countries, while only about 14 per cent believe they are both part of one nation
Or[2]:
>> For Taiwanese younger than 40, pro-independence support reaches 84 percent. Perhaps most startling, 43 percent of the under-40 generation would support independence even if it meant China would attack Taiwan under the risk of war.
Polls conducted by pro-China and pro-Taiwan media typically have slightly different numbers, but the trend across polls is crystal clear, and matches my experience from living there for ~4 years.
It's true that the ROC constitution claims all of the mainland for historical reasons. The thing is, if Taiwan were to give up that claim, they'd probably trigger the PRC's anti-secession law and get sucked into a war. Holding up this territorial claim as a proof that the Taiwanese see themselves as a part of China is extremely cynical.
[1] http://www.scmp.com/news/china/policies-politics/article/209...
[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2017/01/0...
When the ROC was established in 1912, Taiwan was not a part of China. It's misleading to refer to that as the very beginning of the Taiwanese government.
The ROC government has only been indicative of the will of the Taiwanese people since democratization in the 1990s.
> It's still the case, I believe, that no major political party has declared independence as part of their platform. Whether this is because such a position would be wholly unconstitutional or because China would invade is debatable.
It's a bit of a tautology that declaring independence would be unconstitutional, because the constitution is the key piece of what needs to be updated.
IANAL, but I think it's even possible to achieve independence within the framework of the current constitution since it guarantees the right to referendums. The government would need to change the scope of referendums by passing a law (see [1]), and then the referendum would have to succeed.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_Republic_o...
Right, that's not what we're talking about though. The point is that Taiwan is not a part of the PRC and so the idea of 'seceding' from anything is absurd.
What is true is that many Taiwanese fear the mainland and think peaceful surrender is preferable to a military invasation by the mainland. Many Taiwanese fear that nobody will defend them if/when the Mainland invades.
Note also that the Taiwanese look to Hong Kong, and observe the slow erosion of the vestiges of democracy there.
What I was referring to was the erosion of rights since the takeover of HK by the PRC. Looking at your commenting history here on HN, I see quite a bit of love for dictatorships, and hatred for democracy. For this reason, I assume that you knew very well that I was referring to the erosion of rights since the takeover of HK, but decided to derail the thread, so as to avoid discussing the anti-democratic nature of the current PRC government, and the threat this poses to Taiwan.
> WHITE governors of HK
I'm a bit unhappy about your blatant racism. Please ponder the following question: how many non-Chinese General Secretaries of the Communist Party of China can you point me towards?
Note that UK governors did a much better job of ruling HK than did Mao and his cronies in China.
Note that it was only when Deng Xiaoping decided to copy the UK model that was trialled in HK and Singapore, that Mainland China stopped being a basket case.
Please. Taiwan is not a part of the PRC. What would they be seceding from? They're a sovereign State founded by the losers of China's civil war. (That the Nationalists lost is one of China's great tragedies given the horrors that Mao and the ruling party inflicted on the Chinese people and their traditions).
Anyway, take Japan and the Senkaku islands as another example of Chinese bellicose jingoism fueled by a policy of nationalism designed to detract from threats to its legitimacy.