Re:Ask HN: Does HN respect the GDPR?
by Dylan16807 on Friday March 23, 2018 @03:52PM
(#16662027)
> no ability to append explanations to previous posts
Nobody can reply to posts that are more than a month old anyway. And the edit window is only a few hours.
I feel like Hacker News should auto-delete threads that old, anyway. Chances are there's nothing there people will care about, and if they do, they can make their own archive.
Re:Ask HN: Does HN respect the GDPR?
by aaron-lebo on Friday March 23, 2018 @03:14PM
(#16661631)
Not to devalue privacy (at all), but if the GDPR is so far reaching that anonymous posts are expected to comply with this, that destroys much discussion. Don't see why that's a reasonable expectation. That's no longer private but public data.
If you contribute to public knowledge/discussion, then taking your ball and going home leaves huge gaps in history, the same way you see [deleted] throughout many Reddit threads.
Is the GDPR that far reaching?
> Is the GDPR that far reaching?
No.
This will after May 25 be illegal for services offered in the EU, but I kind of think that the same courtesy should apply to non-europeans.