Why help an ad company when you can help a constant warrior for privacy, freedom, and open source technology? Why is Google trying to create their own instead of joining Mozilla's work?
Re:Open Speech Recording
by ocdtrekkie on Friday March 23, 2018 @12:08PM
(#16659513)
Note that the other licenses listed lower on that page are for other data sets. Mozilla's data is CC0, which shouldn't be a problem for Google, because it doesn't include the "noncommercial" part.
CC0 appears to have most of the legal text expected in a proper license including clear allowance of modification and distribution, and lack of warranty or liability.
Re:Open Speech Recording
by woodson on Friday March 23, 2018 @07:46PM
(#16663653)
Sadly, Mozilla's effort is somewhat flawed in its current iteration. There are only very few different sentences (tokens) used as prompts, leading to a lot of repetitions of the same spoken utterance instead of greater coverage of possible utterances, and there is near complete overlap in the sentences spoken in the training set and those in the development and test sets, making it nearly impossible to generalize results from performance evaluations to utterances not contained in the training set. See https://discourse.mozilla.org/t/common-voice-v1-corpus-desig...
Some suggestions for improvements were made in a discussion on the Kaldi Github (https://github.com/kaldi-asr/kaldi/issues/2141), but the bottom line is that it's not clear what the exact use-case of the corpus is. It's not command recognition, there's no particular domain, just more or less random English sentences collected from CC0 sources. Use cases should drive corpus collection.
Re:Open Speech Recording
by iooi on Friday March 23, 2018 @01:03PM
(#16660199)
Especially since they're calling it "Open Speech Recording" you would think that they would be more interested in joining forces with the industry.
It's also interesting that the agreement states, "Google may use the clips ... share the clips with others, including the general public, for example, as part of a public dataset to facilitate research" instead of Google will share the data.
Compare that to Mozilla's Common Voice project which has no agreement.
- You're equivocating on the word "may". You're reading it as declaration of intent—i.e., as a synonym for the word "might" and def 5 as listed on Wiktionary[1]. In reality, it's being used in line with the most common tendency for things like TOS, RFCs, etc, which is as a synonym for the word "can", i.e., to acknowledge what one is allowed to do (in this case Google), as in def 2.
Re:Open Speech Recording
by iooi on Friday March 23, 2018 @02:01PM
(#16660856)
Then why do you have to agree to Google before contributing compared to Mozilla's, where you can contribute right away?
As to "may", you're incorrect. I'm implying that they should have used stronger language, as in "should" or "will", since otherwise the data contributed to this project may not be made public.
Re:Open Speech Recording
by jsgo on Friday March 23, 2018 @03:16PM
(#16661652)
While it is probably hard to understand, the other poster's interpretation is legit as it is referencing an acknowledgement of rights. Without such language, you could provide your voice to this and then when they release, you could say "hang on, I never agreed to give you permission to release this to the public, use for your own purposes, etc."
As far as "may" vs "should"/"will", that'd be very unlikely for them to put into the terms: what happens if they decide tomorrow to abandon the project and just leverage a different data set? They'd now be beholden to release something.
Re:Open Speech Recording
by danso on Friday March 23, 2018 @04:06PM
(#16662186)
Mozilla is a large enough of an organization to have the resources and wisdom to not depend on “Most people won’t even notice” when it comes to legal issues.
Why help an ad company when you can help a constant warrior for privacy, freedom, and open source technology? Why is Google trying to create their own instead of joining Mozilla's work?
A HN headline yesterday explained which licenses were prohibited by Google:
https://opensource.google.com/docs/thirdparty/licenses/#bann...
Most of the licenses on the Mozilla page are either restricted or banned at Google, based on a cursory crosscheck.
https://voice.mozilla.org/en/data
Text of CC0 for discussion purposes, is here: https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/legalcode
CC0 appears to have most of the legal text expected in a proper license including clear allowance of modification and distribution, and lack of warranty or liability.
Some suggestions for improvements were made in a discussion on the Kaldi Github (https://github.com/kaldi-asr/kaldi/issues/2141), but the bottom line is that it's not clear what the exact use-case of the corpus is. It's not command recognition, there's no particular domain, just more or less random English sentences collected from CC0 sources. Use cases should drive corpus collection.
It's also interesting that the agreement states, "Google may use the clips ... share the clips with others, including the general public, for example, as part of a public dataset to facilitate research" instead of Google will share the data.
Compare that to Mozilla's Common Voice project which has no agreement.
- Common Voice does have a TOS. It's here:
https://voice.mozilla.org/en/terms
- You're equivocating on the word "may". You're reading it as declaration of intent—i.e., as a synonym for the word "might" and def 5 as listed on Wiktionary[1]. In reality, it's being used in line with the most common tendency for things like TOS, RFCs, etc, which is as a synonym for the word "can", i.e., to acknowledge what one is allowed to do (in this case Google), as in def 2.
1. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/may#Etymology_1
As to "may", you're incorrect. I'm implying that they should have used stronger language, as in "should" or "will", since otherwise the data contributed to this project may not be made public.
As far as "may" vs "should"/"will", that'd be very unlikely for them to put into the terms: what happens if they decide tomorrow to abandon the project and just leverage a different data set? They'd now be beholden to release something.
(Hint: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zVgWpVXb64)
That's almost same thing you say to vocally authorise yourself with HMRC in the UK...
It's something like "My voice is my password".
I wouldn't want me saying that phrase released into public...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15808124
https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2017/11/29/announcing-the-init...