Re:MIT's Soft Robotic Fish Explores Reefs in Fiji
by spraak on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @10:59PM
(#16645304)
This is completely flippant to say, since I've never built anything like this and don't understand the complexity behind it, but I'm surprised at how awkwardly it looks swimming. It's clear to my eyes that it's not a real fish.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:MIT's Soft Robotic Fish Explores Reefs in Fiji
by harperlee on Thursday March 22, 2018 @08:16AM
(#16647911)
I think the reason is that they tried to minimize the number of actuators (due to both dollar and energy costs), so more refined, undulating movements cannot be flexibly reproduced - instead, they are built-in in the hardware design.
Re:MIT's Soft Robotic Fish Explores Reefs in Fiji
by kurthr on Thursday March 22, 2018 @11:21AM
(#16649371)
Maybe it's intentional, but the tail looks much too heavy. It only looks remotely natural during transitions where it starts to dive. The motive tail is providing significant lift. As a later commenter (ibnjmn) mentions... it looks like the center of gravity is too far back.
Maybe they designed this so that the robo-fish could stop quickly, but it certainly doesn't look efficient for something that is nominally neutrally buoyant.
Re:MIT's Soft Robotic Fish Explores Reefs in Fiji
by jonathanyc on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @11:09PM
(#16645363)
I wonder if other fish will interpret it as injured and attempt to eat it :)
Re:MIT's Soft Robotic Fish Explores Reefs in Fiji
by Mononokay on Thursday March 22, 2018 @03:00AM
(#16646392)
It's doubtful - it's swimming more powerfully than other fish, not less. It's why it looks so odd to humans - the tail strokes are far too heavy. Fish have a lot more subtlety in their own.
Re:MIT's Soft Robotic Fish Explores Reefs in Fiji
by harperlee on Thursday March 22, 2018 @08:12AM
(#16647889)
But the fact that it spends more energy, and it is less efficient, should be interpreted as a sign that something is wrong, isn't it? The gestures are powerful but the fish does not advance a lot.
Limping on one leg is a more extenuant exercise precisely because you need (and show) more power (and that is less sustainable). I don't think a lion would see it as a warning signal!
Re:MIT's Soft Robotic Fish Explores Reefs in Fiji
by ibnjmn on Thursday March 22, 2018 @09:24AM
(#16648388)
I know next to nothing about submarine dynamics, but I am an RC plane pilot, and it looks to me like this fish swims in a constant stall. If it was a plane, I'd be inclined to say that its center of gravity was too far back.
The video states that it can control its own bouyancy, yet it looks like it's constantly fighting to swim level instead of sinking. If it could achieve a neutral bouyancy then I bet it would glide along much more like a real fish.