News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by krick on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:29AM (#16616645)
Of course it is, it's funny that there even is any arguing about that in the comments. Since when it's even a question? The real question is: so what can we do about that? I, for one, don't really see an answer to that. All this babbling by Snowden or anyone else for that matter is worth nothing. If there is any war going on, FB is hopelessly winning and I don't see any attempts (or even possible attempts) to change anything. Fuck, nobody even uses any somewhat "secure" messenger, people use WhatsApp and Telegram (and even dare to speak about them in terms of "privacy", which is mind boggling) and nobody gives a fuck about anything — and "somewhat secure messenger" isn't even that hard to achieve if people would really want it. And here you are talking about FB or Android being evil — yeah, of course they are, but they don't even have any plausible alternative to cover people's needs, so what do you expect…
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by anonytrary on Monday March 19, 2018 @04:27AM (#16616854)
> what can we do about that?

But you do know the answer: Quit Facebook. We all have time, so we should vote with it.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by toss1 on Monday March 19, 2018 @09:47AM (#16618292)
Yes, but you not only have to just quit -- you also must do more.

Before deleting your account overwrite everything with garbage data. If you simply close or delete your account, FB saves everything (in case you might come back, they can offer you a better experience, don'tcha' know?). At least overwriting garbage may give you a slightly better chance.

You also need to use NoScript or the like and deny all FB scripts. FB tracks and maintains profiles on everyone, even whether or not you are members. They are being sued over this in the EU.

Also find and delete their hidden Super-cookies; 200kb of data, including all your other browsing habits, Amazon purchases, etc. Several tutorials are searchable online.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by Erlangolem on Monday March 19, 2018 @09:50AM (#16618307)
Don’t forget that all of your friends and family who use Facebook are potentially leaking your data as well. FB has become quite the tentacled monster!
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by mrhappyunhappy on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:01PM (#16619420)
Had to explain this to my now aging mother who likes to post photos of me without my permission. She gets it in the moment but weeks later back to the same behavior haha. I can't control it if I tried.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by hutzlibu on Monday March 19, 2018 @04:40AM (#16616895)
"Fuck, nobody even uses any somewhat "secure" messenger, people use WhatsApp and Telegram (and even dare to speak about them in terms of "privacy", which is mind boggling) and nobody gives a fuck about anything"

So I was wondering, why you did not mention Signal or Diaspora then?

It is easy to bitch, but there are actual things you can do. Even it is only tell people of alternatives. And while I by myself don't even tried Diaspora yet, I like that it exists and getting more mature. And Signal I do use and see no downside compared to WhatsApp, except most people beeing too lazy to change or having, oh my god, 2 installed messengers.

And my main issue with signal, that it uses Google Servers, is something that could be changed in the future, as far as I know, but till then, it is still 100% open source and private

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by krick on Monday March 19, 2018 @08:11PM (#16624717)
I would like to mention Matrix/Riot instead. It's not good enough still, but if anything will be in a foreseeable future, I believe it has the biggest chance.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by runeb on Monday March 19, 2018 @04:33AM (#16616874)
Could you expand on WhatsApp? You are conflating privacy and "secure" and I am confused. I thought WhatsApp had end to end encryption, even if FB can probably see who chats with who.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by matheusmoreira on Monday March 19, 2018 @05:11AM (#16617031)
WhatsApp does have end-to-end encryption. It integrated Signal's features a couple years ago. It's enabled by default.

https://signal.org/blog/whatsapp-complete/

I'm not sure if it's good enough to foil the US government agencies and their boundless stockpile of zero days. It did, however, make some judges here feel very impotent and powerless. They really, really wanted the messages in order to investigate some crime and couldn't understand why WhatsApp was resisting their requests. They ended up ordering ISPs to block the messaging service for a while as punishment.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/parmyolson/2016/05/03/whatsapp-...

Sure, it's true that people won't be able to audit the thing... But I think it's significant that a huge number of people are using end-to-end encryption by default without even realizing it. That's gotta count for something. It's a lot better security-wise than whatever it is we used before, and most certainly objectively a lot better than facebook messenger or SMS.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by krick on Monday March 19, 2018 @08:09PM (#16624699)
> I think it's significant that a huge number of people are using end-to-end encryption by default without even realizing it > most certainly objectively a lot better than facebook messenger or SMS

Sure, I wouldn't argue with that. Doesn't make up for making me use Google Services (or a phone & a phone number, for that matter) and sharing all my contacts with FB though. It might be even making me angrier about whole situation: it's so close to being good that it makes it obvious, how much technologically possible it in fact is to have a sane messenger. We don't have it though. And no surprise, because who would pay for it, if money cannot be made out of our metadata?

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by krick on Monday March 19, 2018 @07:59PM (#16624624)
Please see my answer to @kruczek in the same thread. This might be quite broad (maybe unconventional) definition of "secure" I'm talking about here, but the point is: everything that leaks important personal data to the 3rd party (I mean "not me and not the person I'm talking to", so FB is a 3rd party) leaking which is not absolutely mathematically necessary to perform its most basic functions — is not "secure" in my book. It doesn't matter if data end ups leaked because of using ROT13 for message encryption, or because it shares it with FB by design. Sharing my whole contactbook with FB, using proprietary closed-source app and protocol, requiring to have a real phone number (and sharing my access code via SMS with my mobile network operator on the first login — this is truly brilliant for a "secure" app, although I don't quite remember if it was WhatsApp or something similar) is not absolutely necessary for its most basic features and thus is not secure.

I want to be clear that `conflating privacy and "secure"` is intentional — violating my privacy automatically harms my security in most direct way. If something quite literally puts me in danger it shouldn't be considered "secure" by definition, no matter how good its crypto is on paper.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by crtasm on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:38PM (#16621620)
FB can definitely see who chats to who (and from what kind of device, and from what IP address, etc.) - they own Whatsapp. While the content is secured by end-to-end encryption the metadata is still incredibly valuable.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by mmjaa on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:03AM (#16677586)
> Since when it's even a question?

We roll through new generations of computer-using society every year, and every 4 - 5 years, after some intensive studying, new waves of developers and "computer people" evolve from being clueless teenagers, to clued-in members of society.

This is of course, of benefit to society at large - but there is a deleterious effect at play here, as well. While cramming hard to graduate, people keep their heads down - and/or in the sand - and tend to ignore the wider, broader aspects of society in the meanwhile.

And this is why we must continually rehash themes that we - living in the static world - consider to be 'old news'.

Always remember - ALWAYS - that there is a generation of kids on the cusp of making their way into society, and no matter what we adults do, no matter how hard we try and cry and pound our fists on the table, these kids were NOT paying attention to the important issues in the last few years.

So this is why we must consistently push key social issues to the forefront, no matter how tiresome it becomes. Its the kids who are coming to this scene who can do something about it, before its too late - before they too, become jaded adults who just want to pay the mortgage.

Between these two worlds is a no-mans land of social issues, and a war being waged by all the special interests to obfuscate and confuse and devolve the issues, such that the powerful young new adult elite don't put them in their spotlights.

"Since when its even a question?" - every day, there are people learning the extent to which our society has devolved. It is ALWAYS a question.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by kruczek on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:53AM (#16616725)
> people use WhatsApp and Telegram (and even dare to speak about them in terms of "privacy", which is mind boggling)

I don't know about WhatsApp, but from what I recall about Telegram, its main criticism is the fact that it isn't using secret chats (i.e. private conversations) by default. However when using secret chats, the communication is end-to-end encrypted. Is there anything else wrong with it?

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by 215163831328308 on Monday March 19, 2018 @04:25AM (#16616850)
The main criticism of Telegram is that it created it's own cryptography. It does not use a well established cryptographic scheme. Instead the creators of Telegram created their own scheme, and that has not been checked as thoroughly. The mostly strict rule in these things is, don't roll your own crypto. This is reiterated in [1] and an attack on telegram [2]

[1]: https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/49782/is-telegr... [2]: https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/49782/is-telegr...

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by krick on Monday March 19, 2018 @07:28PM (#16624398)
First off, I consider no e2e enryption by default a big deal, given even WhatsApp does that. In Telegram it's so inconvenient — "they" obviously don't want you to use it. So yeah. But for me all these apps are broken on more fundamental level. First, as somebody else already noted that I'm "confusing security and privacy" let me introduce my custom definition (or rather a trait) of "security" for the sake of this argument: no 3rd party can access any data of mine without explicit permission, unless it's absolutely necessary for the app to work. So any messenger that must use a phone number for a log in without giving me any choice is shit, regardless of whether its crypto is broken or not. Any messenger that can non-locally access all of my contacts without asking me which contacts I agree to share — is shit. Any messenger that won't work without Google Services or cannot be installed without Google Play account — is shit. And so on.

That said, Matrix/Riot probably is the only messenger out there that has any chance of becoming not-shitty messenger. But nobody uses it.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by pigeons on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:51PM (#16621785)
not only not default, secret chats are not even available on linux.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by jhasse on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @06:11AM (#16636739)
They are (e.g. https://github.com/Aseman-Land/Cutegram), but not with the official Desktop client.