News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by rdtsc on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:25AM (#16616327)
The Stasi and KGB would have given everything to have something like Facebook. Here they were installing listening devices, torturing people, following them, getting family members to spy on each other. They just needed Facebook and none of that would have been necessary. People would voluntarily log in and type everything they do, where they travel, what food they are eating, what political parties they support, who their friends are, everything connected nicely in a pretty graph with nodes and edges.

> https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Mark_Zuckerberg

Zuck: I have over 4,000 emails, pictures, addresses, SNS [Redacted Friend's Name]: What? How'd you manage that one?

Zuck: People just submitted it.

Zuck: I don't know why.

Zuck: They "trust me"

Zuck: Dumb fucks

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by dang on Monday March 19, 2018 @05:01AM (#16616988)
This tedious trope jumped the shark years ago. Somehow you managed to combine it with a neo-Godwin. That's an Olympian manoeuvre!

There's much to say by way of critiquing Facebook, but obviously the "dumb fucks" bit is not it. That's merely an excuse to feel superior, and the discussions it spawns are predictable, therefore uninteresting, therefore off topic for Hacker News.

All: if you can't think of something stupid or bad you said as a teenager, dig deeper.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by rdtsc on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:14PM (#16620308)
> This tedious trope jumped the shark years ago. Somehow you managed to combine it with a neo-Godwin. That's an Olympian manoeuvre!

Well, good point. It was pretty provocative.

> All: if you can't think of something stupid or bad you said as a teenager, dig deeper.

But I am not the CEO of a company that has all the intimate details of hundreds of millions of users private life. Those in power can handle a bit criticism, it's different than saying it about a random person on the street. Also 26 is not quite a teenager. While people report wild personality changes after that age, it usually doesn't happen.

> There's much to say by way of critiquing Facebook, but obviously the "dumb fucks" bit is not it.

It goes with the paragraph above on how people volunteer the information and even the designer of the service things is pretty ridiculous.

> and the discussions it spawns are predictable, therefore uninteresting, therefore off topic for Hacker News.

Hmm, fair point. Agree with flagging.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by tomhoward on Friday March 23, 2018 @04:17PM (#16662283)
Also 26 is not quite a teenager.

He was 19.

A normal person's prefrontal cortex (rational brain) is underdeveloped at that age, and is only fully developed at about 25 or even 30 [1].

So your point may be valid if he actually had been 26, but misses badly given the fact that he was 19.

[1] https://mentalhealthdaily.com/2015/02/18/at-what-age-is-the-...

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by dang on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:12PM (#16622043)
It's not a question of whether Zuckerberg can take the criticism (that's his problem), but of the effect it has on discussion quality here (that's our problem).

(I appreciate the polite reply. It's surprisingly rare when there are that many volatiles in the air.)

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by appleshore on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:50AM (#16616394)
People can dismiss this saying he was a teenager, and just randomly chatting to a friend privately.

But I've been developing programs since I was 15, and created my first startup (hardware) at 18 with an engineer 10-years older than me.

Never once did I ever refer to any of our customers or clients as "dumb fucks". Why? What did they do to Zuck?

Although, I did refer to AOL executives, FBI agents, Secret Service agents, federal prosecutors and lame wannabe hackers as dumb fucks. Both then and now. And I work with the federal government, with an agency that's often unfairly demonized by a variety of people.

Which makes me think of a new phrase: dumb zucks.

Quasi wannabe devs who build products and services not to advance the hacker ethos or crypto-anarchy but to get rich being essentially technical marketing partners for the FBI and corporate America.

EDIT- Facebook's address is 1 Hacker Way. Zuck is not a hacker. He is the opposite of one.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by traek on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:13AM (#16616605)
> Never once did I ever refer to any of our customers or clients as "dumb fucks". Why? What did they do to Zuck?

> Although, I did refer to AOL executives, FBI agents, Secret Service agents, federal prosecutors and lame wannabe hackers as dumb fucks. Both then and now. And I work with the federal government, with an agency that's often unfairly demonized by a variety of people.

Your argument against the possibility someone has undergone personal growth is that you yourself have not experienced personal growth?

Some of us can imagine having conversations like that, jokingly or seriously, in our teens while having better taste/a better worldview now as adults.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by smokeyj on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:43AM (#16616697)
Zuck now uses FB to help Pakistan enforce blasphemy laws. Would you be okay helping sentence someone to death for "blasphemy"? Zuck has.

And now he finds the value in religion as he grooms his political career. The dude is a complete snake.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by sgift on Monday March 19, 2018 @04:01AM (#16616761)
> Your argument against the possibility someone has undergone personal growth is that you yourself have not experienced personal growth?

If that's your definition of 'personal growth' its probably better not to have experienced it.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by throwaway84742 on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:33AM (#16616663)
>> Never once did I ever refer to any of >> our customers or clients as "dumb fucks"

Did they ever send you their SSNs? I mean, I’m not going to whitewash what he said, but you gotta agree, sending your SSN to some random dude in a college dorm is pretty darn dumb.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by tritium on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:26AM (#16616480)
Meh, if Mark Zuckerberg has only that one, same, tired sideways quote dragged out and tossed around every time criticism is leveled against him, then Christ almighty if he isn't squeaky clean. A little too clean, if you really wanted my opinion.

His attitude and all-around conduct is pretty much that of a boy scout, and to be honest, I find it boring. Linus Torvalds curses like a sailor, and he doesn't spare anyone's feelings with his criticism, whether it's an individual or a broad generalization. Would you mistrust Linux based on the principal developer's language, or is it more about the project's overall opacity?

Mark Zuckerberg's general demeanor can be read from many obvious tells across all the things he touches. He's not dating super models, he's not buying people Audis, his flagship website has one theme for everyone, two colors (blue & white), five uninteresting emojis, and all the personality of AOL and Yahoo! combined. Yet this reveals nothing about what goes on across Facebook's backplane.

If you're going to criticize his character, you have to criticize the depth and breadth of whatever the faustian bargain is, according to the Snowden leaks. You can compare Zuckerberg to Snowden in terms of choices made, but you really can't fault Zuckerberg for using harsh language in casual conversation. It comes across as whiny and pathetic, like some petulant child. Actions speak louder than words, as they say.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by sillysaurus3 on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:39AM (#16616518)
The fact that it's posted often doesn't change its power. And that you rush to defend Zuck says quite a lot.

One thing is true: Those at the top rarely mean what they say. They are masters of dissembling, because they understand how dangerous it is to reveal one's true feelings.

This was a rare glimpse into raw, unfiltered Zuck. And what we find is that he's just like the rest of those in power. No wonder they love him so much.

We're the dumb fucks to them. And that should be at least a little worrying.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by koko775 on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:57AM (#16616570)
Raw, unfiltered me fifteen years ago was probably a misogynistic "nice guy" on a regular basis. Raw unfiltered me right now is all for feminism and social justice, and hates the shit out of that guy I was fifteen years ago.

If the worst quote attributed to him shows him calling people dumb for throwing their personal info at someone they have no reason to trust...that's not a very strong indictment of his character. And even though it's reasonably bad, there's no way fourteen years of responsibility won't change people.

The idiot who said "dumb fucks" is an entirely alien person to the person now. And the quote calling people dumb for giving some online rando their personal data doesn't exactly demonstrate a conclusive disregard for the value of that data. If anything, it's an insult to people's intelligence because they should care more.

It doesn't make him a hero, but doesn't make him a villain, either.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by blub on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:26AM (#16616640)
I don't think there's a stronger way of stating that your users are dumb fucks than running Facebook or Google.

And indeed, with enough algorithm magic, free stuff and lobbying, it turns out that the majority of us are dumb fucks.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by gear54rus on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:15AM (#16616612)
Yes he's entirely alien person. The one now will hide his sociopathy much better.

And make you disregard the moment when he showed his true self as a thing of the past.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by koko775 on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:24AM (#16616633)
Assuming he's the same person as back then but hides it better, do you think that his true self thinking people are dumb to give an unknown and untrusted online service their information extremely freely is wrong? Or just an asshole at the time?

Point is, as much as it might color his character, so does his observable conduct in all the years since. Reiterating: with context (would appreciate if you don't forget I'm not disregarding it and talk past me) - it really doesn't give much context, though it's an amazingly compelling soundbite.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by blub on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:24AM (#16616634)
Well, besides that quote there's also the part where he's running and expanding the world's biggest (or second biggest?) corporate surveillance machine which might indicate that he is a person of questionable character.

But other than that, I'm sure he's a great guy to have a beer with... most evil people are quite nice when you get to know them.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by Atheros on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:35AM (#16616505)
Zuckerberg called his users dumb for the very act of using his website. Did Linus ever call people dumb for the very act of using Linux as it is intended to be used?

You're focusing too much on the swear word and too little on the meaning of the sentence.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by eksemplar on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:48AM (#16616386)
I don’t think that’s more than a meme. The Stasi collected information you didn’t want to share, and what you put on Facebook willingly is typically the same sort of front you would have put up publicly in the DDR. As in the best version of you.

There is some truth to what you’re saying though, but that’s in the data Facebook collects about you, without your knowledge.

I think the facial recognition program is a good example. Even if you don’t have a Facebook account, or even if you do but didn’t share any pictures of your vacation, Facebook might still know you went. They know by recognizing you in pictures of other people. If you get caught in someone’s Instagram selfie in an airport or at a popular tourist spot, then Facebook knows you where there.

Stasi would have loved that, but that’s not information people share willingly.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by westiseast on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:10AM (#16616445)
That’s the crux of the issue now with Facebook though - it’s become so pervasive that people don’t even realize what they’re sharing:

* It follows you around the internet via the Share/Like plug-ins so your entire internet browsing patterns become exposed

* Via the psychological analytics they’ve been applying, you think you’ve just liked (eg) a sports personality page and a TV show, but that’s actually confirmed a whole host of implied personality traits that are then ‘known’ about you.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by buro9 on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:29AM (#16616489)
> The Stasi collected information you didn’t want to share, and what you put on Facebook willingly

I am not on Facebook though I once had a profile a decade ago.

I don't believe that profile has been deleted, I do believe that facial recognition on the photos has included me, I do believe that they've applied said facial recognition to the historical data, and so I believe that I do have a profile that is alive and well within Facebook, and that even receives fresh content... it is just not public.

I am so looking forward to the GDPR coming into effect.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by blub on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:19AM (#16616622)
Such a security apparatus would collect any and all information it can get its hands on, and then use it whenever it needs it. For instance to protect the state, to protect itself, to influence and manipulate situations to its advantage and to the advantage of those in power, to destroy opponents and of course for fun and profit.

A contemporary Stasi would control Facebook and use all algorithms and all available data sources to figure out who the persons of interest are. Even assuming that the StasiBook app wouldn't auto-upload all pictures and microphone data (why would an upstanding citizen turn off their mic?), they could still correlate many invisible patterns.

So all in all, I think they'd be the biggest fans.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by cirgue on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:48AM (#16616387)
The point of the Stasi wasn't the information. They didn't give two shits about truth or verifiable fact, it was the awareness of survailence and the mistrust it created that was useful to them.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by ahartmetz on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:31AM (#16616654)
I don't know, from their actions it looked quite like they actually wanted the information. They needed it, among other things, to sow mistrust among the right groups.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by product50 on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:31AM (#16616343)
Equifax leaked 142M SSNs alongwith name, email, dob and address for all Americans with credit history. KGB most assuredly already have that data. Why is people's photographs (most of them of which are already public on Instagram) and friend list (which if KGB wanted to get for their targets, they can get in a day) so critical? Google has location data for each and every person globally at almost every minute - I feel that is much more useful than what FB has - if you think from KGB's perspective.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by kerng on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:12AM (#16616451)
You might not fully be aware, but there is much more to tracking, then the information you biblically post. Every website you visit they know know of, messages you send, they have (incl. private) every transaction you make with your credit card is being gathered/received (indirectly) and collected leveraged by Facebook. The amount of information the possess is unbelievable - and those are the things we know about, reality is probably that there are many other sources where they gather intelligence about you.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by product50 on Monday March 19, 2018 @04:13AM (#16616794)
Yeah - but so does Google and I would argue they know far more than FB does given they own a mobile OS, searches, have credit card info including transactions, have major partnerships with publishers who share data etc. Why is the backlash only against Facebook?
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by kerng on Monday March 19, 2018 @04:29AM (#16616860)
I think Google is pretty much under the same scrutiny, it just happens that recently this Cambridge Analytica news brokw lose, and that dataset appears to have its origins at Facebook. So naturally the focus is on them right now.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by MichaelMoser123 on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:29AM (#16616336)
I dunno - with the Stasi the stakes were higher: people could actually end up in jail for stating the wrong opinion. Nowadays facebook is all about pushing adds, so there is less drama in the plot.

However i guess the analogy is more fitting for Baidu. The Chinese state has some very restrictive laws that are applied in practice.

And in Russia you can get sentenced for a wrong repost, so yandex.ru or ok.ru/vk.ru is in the same league.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by some_account on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:55AM (#16616404)
I think you would have to be very gullible to believe companies like this at their word.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by MichaelMoser123 on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:25AM (#16616639)
People did/do take chances: it was not always clear what was allowed and what was crossing the line.

* the allowed range of expression used to depend on the political climate (in better times/under liberal rulers you were allowed to say more)

* the rules are often not clear as they are not stated explicitly. (however the subjects were expected to know them)

* Also some people had more liberties (different degree of toleration, depending on the position in society)

* decision to go after someone used to depend on the arbitrariness of some official.

Disclaimer: my knowledge is based on historical events, i don't know that much regarding the realities of the present day.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by boron1006 on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:40AM (#16616689)
It's mildly ironic that the number 1 criticism against Facebook privacy concerns comes from a leaked anonymous source of the CEO's private texts.

Of course you could say that Zuckerberg is getting a taste of his own medicine, but I dunno, it still seems a bit hypocritical to me.

Maybe someone can come up with a good argument of whose private data we're allowed to post publicly, and whose we aren't?

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by SubiculumCode on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:31AM (#16616340)
This makes a nice story. However, please consider the following. Right now we use Facebook and share personal details, but the USA does not generally act on the information that is shared. People are not being disappeared, shot, or sent to work themselves to death in the Gulag. If activists and political opponents kept disappearing, you and I would surely shut stop sharing on Facebook so freely.
Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by gt_ on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:09AM (#16616443)
It’s very well known that the information being discussed is “acted on” constantly. It informs advertising, political propoganda campaigns, lawmaking, voting districts.

Bullet point comparisons of a historic authoritarian state to a contemporary capitalist society is rarely a helpful exercise but we should remain humble either way.

America maintains the largest prison population per capita of any nation on Earth.

America experiences more than 39,000 gun deaths per year.

At least 750,000 Americans are homeless.

Re:Edward Snowden: Facebook is a surveillance company rebran... by mdpopescu on Monday March 19, 2018 @04:45AM (#16616916)
> the USA does not generally act on the information that is shared

How would you know that?

In any case, the UK does. [1]

[1] http://www.vocativ.com/325190/arrests-for-social-media-posts...