> There were huge advancements in food production technology all throughout history
The current world population could not be fed without Nitrogen fixation and synthetic fertilizers. The Haber-Bosch process is a huge counter-Malthusian point by itself.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused
by thaumasiotes on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:15PM
(#16621318)
No, it isn't, because it's a productivity technology and those are not relevant to the Malthus dynamic. You know what had a massively larger impact than the Haber-Bosch process? Agriculture.
But the development of agriculture made the world more Malthusian, not less.
In contrast, the Black Plague made Europe much less Malthusian by the simple expedient of killing maybe one person in three. This made everyone more productive without any accompanying technology gains. But the point isn't the productivity gain - it's the population drop.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused
by cryptonector on Monday March 19, 2018 @10:58AM
(#16618820)
Most of the tech improvements came well before population growth curve flattening. It's quite clear that we develop realistic technology that we need. It's also true that if we didn't naturally (i.e., without force) reduce population growth by now that we'd be in trouble (there would be no getting off the planet fast enough to prevent collapse), but the tech came first, not the other way around.
These are not good counter-Malthusian points. There were huge advancements in food production technology all throughout history (ploughs / iron ploughs / crop rotation / plants from the new world... the list really is endless), but things were in a much more Malthusian state.
The non-Malthusian state of affairs we enjoy today is entirely a function of people choosing not to have children, not a function of better technology. People who were so inclined could easily wipe out (per capita) the gains from productivity, by increasing the number of capita.