News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stack Overflow Culture by kleiba on Sunday March 18, 2018 @01:23PM (#16612990)
Seconding the impression of SO. More than once I saw a question where it was kinda obvious that it was a beginner who was facing a very specific issue. Let's say it's a question that's not very difficult to solve for a seasoned programmer because even if you don't know it right off the batch, your experience can guide you pretty quickly to a solution. So, I spend the five to ten minutes to come up with a solution that works reasonably well -- in parts because I'd like to help out someone but in parts also because it's informative for me as well to learn something I didn't know before -- but just as I'm typing up my findings, the question gets closed. And it's not possible to answer closed questions (the rationale for which does not reveal itself to me immediately).

I mean, I get that SO wants to be a programming resource (as in "archive") where people with a problem should find a solution - not by asking but through googling. And so they want question/answer pairs that have a sort of general value, not an individual answer to just one person.

But then again: why? What's the big deal? Someone has a very specific question, and maybe nobody in the universe will ever have the same question again, but I'm willing to help that person out -- why shouldn't I be allowed to do it? Are they really worried about too much noise on the site? Please, come on.

In the situation I sketched above, I will still walk away having learned something new, but the person who posed the original question is left with a very negative user experience AND is none the wiser regarding their specific problem. At the same time, I was never allowed to help that person which I wanted to do not for the potential credit points but rather for altruistic reasons. Way to go.

Re:Stack Overflow Culture by zoul on Sunday March 18, 2018 @01:54PM (#16613207)
Are they really worried about too much noise on the site? Please, come on.

Is this really so hard to believe? I have been a member of the community for ten years now (https://goo.gl/JZkqSP) and have seen the number of low-quality questions rise to the point where I honestly don’t enjoy answering any more. People don’t care to ask well, they just want to get over their personal issue as quickly as possible and be done with it.

Re:Stack Overflow Culture by mlonkibjuyhv on Sunday March 18, 2018 @02:21PM (#16613376)
I have countless examples of me googling for a very specific issue, and the only relevant hit I can find is a closed SO question.
Re:Stack Overflow Culture by kleiba on Sunday March 18, 2018 @05:02PM (#16614314)
Exactly. We have sophisticated search algorithms, noise is no problem.
Re:Stack Overflow Culture by gnulinux on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:21AM (#16616317)
Rather, noise is not a problem for SO, but it is a problem of someone else.
Re:Stack Overflow Culture by tensor_rank_0 on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:17AM (#16616161)
it has happened to me once or twice as well :(
Re:Stack Overflow Culture by GordonS on Sunday March 18, 2018 @02:27PM (#16613406)
Even with relevant, unique, well-worded questions, there are a number of militant reviewers who will flag it as a duplicate of the first question they find on the same topic (even though its clearly not a dupe).

It may well be true that the number of low-quality questions is increasing (I believe it, some really are just garbage), but the number of low-quality reviewers has unfortunately also increased.

Re:Stack Overflow Culture by Can_Not on Monday March 19, 2018 @08:48AM (#16617932)
I asked a really specific question about redis and one guy just posted this as an answer: You can install redis with sudo apt-get install redis-server
Re:Stack Overflow Culture by gnulinux on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:22AM (#16616318)
I agree with your sentiment, but I'd like to point out that I've seen examples of closed questions that were worded well, and interesting enough for me to answer.
Re:Stack Overflow Culture by tonyedgecombe on Monday March 19, 2018 @09:58AM (#16618361)
Is this really so hard to believe?

When nearly every question I end up on has been closed it seems they don't really care, if they did closed questions would disappear.