News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by astebbin on Saturday March 17, 2018 @11:13PM (#16610322)
>an improvement in human welfare

Was this generally the outcome of the Roman Empire's collapse? Intuitively, I would expect breakdowns in law and order and the collapse of complex supply chain systems (particularly food delivery) to result in mass human suffering, at least in the short term.

Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by nostrademons on Sunday March 18, 2018 @02:41AM (#16610727)
For whom, and according to what value system?

The histories I've read of the early middle ages corroborate much of your intuition. Trade collapsed; many luxury goods became impossible to obtain at any price; illiteracy rose; population declined and many citizens died from famine and plague.

But there's often a trade-off between freedom and convenience, then and now. The Roman empire was built upon large-scale slavery and wealth inequality. If you were a member of the elite, then yes, the collapse was terrible; you lost access to all the privileges of the empire. If you were a slave, you probably ended up somewhat better off, becoming either a peasant or a bandit. Not being able to obtain pottery or steel doesn't matter much if you couldn't afford it to begin with, and dying at 40 from starvation is an improvement on dying at 25 in the arena.

Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by 1gor on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:17AM (#16610816)
> If you were a slave, you probably ended up somewhat better off

Slavery continued to exist in Western Europe after the fall of Roman empire until at least year 1000 AD.

In other former parts of Roman Empire such as Northern Africa slavery continued to flourish almost until the 19th century.

Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by hcho on Sunday March 18, 2018 @05:19AM (#16611098)
The number of people in slavery would have still decreased. The fact that it continued to exist is immaterial to the point being made.
Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by 1gor on Sunday March 18, 2018 @06:32AM (#16611261)
> The number of people in slavery would have still decreased

On what basis are you making this assumption? "The fall of Rome" was not an anti-slavery uprising. It was gradual disappearance of the central authority (and all its benefits such as roads, law and order etc).

About 10% of England's population entered in the Domesday Book (1086) were slaves. Compare that with the Roman Empire where slave population (including Rome and all provinces) are estimated at 10-15% of the total.

Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by hcho on Sunday March 18, 2018 @07:06AM (#16611352)
The biggest buyer of slaves going down would decimate the market, no? I would imagine it would have played exactly like abolition of slavery in Britain or US. There was still slavery across the world, but the number of people that suffered from it went down.
Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by Trill-I-Am on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:15AM (#16610811)
What if you were a peasant? Did your life get worse?
Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by nostrademons on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:42AM (#16610875)
Probably somewhat better, in the sense that your imperial overlords became spectacularly ineffective at taxing you.
Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by eecc on Sunday March 18, 2018 @06:21AM (#16611230)
Except the local abbot would happily take 1/10 of the fruits of your labor, the landlord even more, and you stood no chance seeking better fortunes away because roads were in disrepair, infested by robbers and patrolled by mercenaries tasked to kill any fugitive...
Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by toyg on Sunday March 18, 2018 @06:22AM (#16611235)
But you died of famine and disease more often - population went way down. It became harder to trade even the most basic foodstuff, since simple roads to the closest market became unsafe. Eventually feudalism happened and a lot of simple peasants were literally enslaved to the land.
Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by zipwitch on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:28AM (#16610968)
I seem to recall one essay I read (long ago back in college and which a modicum of google-fu fails to locate) that argued that average caloric intake went sharply up in the territories of the Western Roman Empire in the decades after it's collapse.
Re:“Peak Civilization”: The Fall of the Roman Empire (2009) by adrianN on Sunday March 18, 2018 @12:56AM (#16610505)
Not to mention infrastructure like public baths and sewers.