Re:The mythic associations of “dark matter”
by martinpw on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:23PM
(#16613736)
> While some point to galaxy cluster work by Fritz Zwicky in the 1930s, dark matter was truly “discovered” in the 1970s by Vera Rubin, who was studying the rotation of spiral galaxies. Rubin found that galaxies were spinning too fast for the matter we could see in them, yet they weren’t flying apart.
And Zwicky found that galaxies were moving too fast for the matter we see in clusters yet the clusters weren't flying apart. This seems exactly analagous to Rubin's discovery so it is not clear why the author considers it not the true "discovery".
Re:The mythic associations of “dark matter”
by Avshalom on Sunday March 18, 2018 @01:31PM
(#16613046)
>dark matter was truly “discovered” in the 1970s by Vera Rubin
as a nit: dark matter was actually discovered in the 50's with the first direct detection of neutrinos, which is why-in the 70's- "maybe there's just a bunch of matter not interacting with photons" wasn't laughed out of the room.
Re:The mythic associations of “dark matter”
by Avshalom on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:12PM
(#16613675)
Neutrinos aren't the dark matter responsible for the bullet cluster, rotation curves etc... But dark matter as a term is just a catch all for particles that don't interact with photons, hence hot (neutrinos) and cold (what we need for galaxies)
Re:The mythic associations of “dark matter”
by rflrob on Sunday March 18, 2018 @12:42PM
(#16612776)
The headline writer here has evidently decided to take an article about one of physicists’ pet peeves and include a biologist pet peeve—saying something is “in our DNA” to mean it’s an apparently inherent part of our cultural legacy, without making any reference to actual biology.
Re:The mythic associations of “dark matter”
by rflrob on Sunday March 18, 2018 @01:10PM
(#16612929)
I don’t think so. It is in the headline on Nautilus, and while I think there’s room for yet another article where a scientist carps about how the lay press misuses scientific terms, this whole article is about why “Dark Matter” as a term is evocative, and “in our DNA” has also come to mean something beyond “is encoded in the sequence of our chromosomes“.
And Zwicky found that galaxies were moving too fast for the matter we see in clusters yet the clusters weren't flying apart. This seems exactly analagous to Rubin's discovery so it is not clear why the author considers it not the true "discovery".
as a nit: dark matter was actually discovered in the 50's with the first direct detection of neutrinos, which is why-in the 70's- "maybe there's just a bunch of matter not interacting with photons" wasn't laughed out of the room.