News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by ssp on Friday September 03, 2010 @02:46PM (#1660639)
Microsoft has made a bunch of very good products:

- Windows 3.0 and 3.1 clearly hit exactly the sweet spot between DOS and OS/2

- Word and Excel were legitimately better than the competition (and still are, although there is not much competition left).

- Internet Explorer 4 was so much better than Netscape 3 and 4 that it wasn't even funny

- Windows 2000 and XP were very good operating systems

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by walkon on Friday September 03, 2010 @03:55PM (#1660894)
I agree, when you consider when products were released and compare it to similar offerings at those times, many Microsoft products are (or were) "decent". I would add these:

- Windows 95: Not perfectly stable or technically very groundbreaking, but a good enough combination of usability and features to be considered decent in my mind and millions of others at the time.

- IE6: great at the time. Some of the standards it doesn't support didn't exist when it came out. Also, IE5 introduced the Microsoft.XMLHTTP ActiveX control, which was the foundation for XMLHttpRequest. If that wasn’t created by Microsoft at the time, AJAX almost certainly wouldn’t be as ubiquitous as it is today.

- SQL Server 20xx: Perhaps RDMS's aren't your thing, but they're very much needed for now, and Microsoft's can certainly handle most relational db needs.

- .NET 3.5+ and C# 3+: If you want a statically typed language and platform, anything .NET 3.5 or greater are at least ok.

- ASP.NET MVC 2+: Not quit the same as a dynamically-based ROR or Django and they also don’t give you a default ORM; you pick it, but its solid and improving. Source code is available; contribs aren’t.

- Visual Studio 2008+: Again, not some crazy vim/emacs setup, although plugins can somewhat help simulate that, but these definitely don’t suck at all.

- IIS7+: Just because it’s not Apache doesn't mean it isn't decent. It is quite powerful and secure.

- Windows Server 2003+: Never had bad experiences with these.

- Microsoft Security Essentials: Very good and free antivirus.

I’m sure there’s more, but it is an exaggeration to say Microsoft hasn’t made any decent products. Certainly some of these don’t seem as good overall when accounting for the licensing costs and associated culture/stigma that comes with working in Microsoft shops, but many of products in and of themselves are decent.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by plnewman on Friday September 03, 2010 @05:57PM (#1661306)
I always bring up Flight Simulator whenever there's some MS bashing going on. I miss the Microsoft of my youth,
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by rbanffy on Friday September 03, 2010 @09:20PM (#1661684)
Sublogic made Flight Simulator. Microsoft later bought Sublogic.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by plnewman on Monday September 06, 2010 @12:15AM (#1665837)
I didn't know that. Still kudos to them for keeping the product going, and keeping it good.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by watmough on Friday September 03, 2010 @11:02PM (#1661873)
MS Access 1.0 was fantastic when it came out. I can almost taste that box arriving in my office.

23 freakin' floppies though! Awesome piece of software.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by dfox on Saturday September 04, 2010 @11:15AM (#1662823)
I view all 32bit PM versions of non-NT windows (ie. 386, 3.1, 9x...) as amazing technical feat, because they do something that almost should not be possible. Like ability to transparently use realmode DOS drivers from windows programs and vice versa (althought at huge performance and stability penalty).
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by mcosta on Friday September 03, 2010 @05:06PM (#1661160)
"decent" is the perfect name. Better than the crap the anterior version was is a better description. Perfect for milking the cash cow.

-Windows 95? Come on, your memory fails. It was utterly usable and crashed hard everyday. Any other OS of the time was better. It was so basic... paint? notepad? a big pile of shit. And they have been budling the same crap more than 10 years until Windows 7.

-IE6 was good at the time. It's sad it was so many time without new versions.

-The first usable SQLS was the 2000, and sincerely, until 2003 oracle ran circles around it.

-.NET and C# is OK, fine lenguage.

-ASP.NET I do not know.

-Visual Studio is OK, but almost because it has no competition.

-IIS7+: I do not remember the last version I touched, but I had to clean my hands with bleach after. Oh! and it came with W2000, and obligatory for some SQL Server stuff, for no aparent reason.

-Windows Server 2003, better than the 2000, yes. And grey.

-Microsoft Security Essentials: no please.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by TeHCrAzY on Friday September 03, 2010 @05:36PM (#1661243)
Microsoft Security Essentials: Not sure what you have against this. I happily suggest it for all my friends and family when they ask for anti virus. Its free, and effective, and doesn't cause headaches (ala Norton, etc).
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by shadowsun7 on Friday September 03, 2010 @08:17PM (#1661588)
I'm not sure what his beef is with Microsoft Security Essentials, but I just tell my friends and family to get a Mac.

It's too tiring keeping up with antivirus offerings, and constantly needing to clean up after their messes.

I'd recommend Linux, to be honest, because it's a cheaper alternative. But because there's still no good way of using it without needing to open Terminal at some point - the Mac is, I suppose, a good compromise.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by wwortiz on Friday September 03, 2010 @08:36PM (#1661621)
You can use ubuntu without opening the terminal, and have been able to for a while, the problem with linux is not the terminal it is whether or not the hardware is supported and software people need is supported.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by shadowsun7 on Friday September 03, 2010 @11:47PM (#1661952)
I recommend that you sit behind a non-technical relative or friend, and watch them use Ubuntu without offering them any help.

There are quite a number of things that they'd like to do that isn't clearly expressed - or even easily findable! - though Ubuntu's GUI. They will struggle with it for a bit.

Plus: even if we set that aside, there will be certain bits of hardware you'll want to use that would require opening the Terminal to configure/install.

Because my objective is to minimize my time spent on helping my friends/relatives with their computers, Ubuntu simply isn't a good enough alternative to Windows. You merely trade the time spent on making the computer virus-proof with time spent teaching them where to find things (which is funny, because most of the time I'm finding things for the first time myself, seeing as I prefer the Terminal).

As opposed to the Mac - I send them away to buy one, and they never come back to me for help.

PS: Why the downvotes? I expressed a justified assertion, backed up with some evidence, and people react to the fact that I'm dissing Linux? Tsk, HN, I expected more of you.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by smokinn on Saturday September 04, 2010 @10:24AM (#1662744)
I recommend that you sit behind a non-technical relative or friend, and watch them use a Mac without offering them any help.

There are quite a number of things that they'd like to do that isn't clearly expressed - or even easily findable! - though OSX's GUI. They will struggle with it for a bit.

--

Really, it's just a learning curve and it's the same for any new OS.

Most non-technical people don't have the habit of figuring out what to do. They have the habit of doing what they're used to. For most, if you change even the smallest thing in their interface it can be catastrophic. (My mom often calls me for things like not being able to use internet at all anymore because the bookmarks bar is gone because someone accidentally hit ctrl+b or something).

I think the whole "Apple just works" thing is majorly overblown. Every time I have to use an OSX laptop I cringe because I have to look for stuff in the weirdest places and it takes me so long to figure out how to do things that I often just give up (if I'm using an OSX laptop it's usually because I don't have much time and just bummed the first laptop that was around). I can't imagine my mom magically finding everything intuitively if I can''t.

Also, you say you backed your assertion up with evidence. What evidence? I see none at all. The plural of anecdote is not data. (I'm not saying I'm providing evidence either, I'm simply providing a counter-example to your anecdote.)

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by shadowsun7 on Saturday September 04, 2010 @01:32PM (#1663024)
Evidence != data. Evidence = data and/or examples and/or anecdotes. Evidence is also most effective when backed up with analysis/logic (otherwise you get ping-pong debating, where both sides toss counter-examples around, proving nothing)

Note too that I said some evidence.

>I think the whole "Apple just works" thing is majorly overblown.

I suppose the simplest way to prove this is to consider the alternative: of what other operating system, taking into account everything that a non-technical user needs, can this be said to be true? Perhaps it is not true of all our current operating systems, but if it is more preposterous to claim that Windows or Linux 'just works', then Apple takes the cake and my point is justified.

Whether it is overblown or not is not my concern - it is currently the best that we have, and I have to make do. Perhaps iPad-like devices would prove to be better, but that future is still two-three years away.

Anecdotal evidence seems to support this: I wince whenever I see the Macs my friends and family use - the desktop is cluttered beyond repair, the dock is stretched across the screen, and they don't know how to use various core features (expose, frontrow, etc). But they don't complain, and they don't ask me for as much help as they did before, and this is the only metric that matters to me.

I'm happy, they're happy. What's not to like?

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by Someone on Sunday September 05, 2010 @05:15AM (#1664260)
"Plus: even if we set that aside, there will be certain bits of hardware you'll want to use that would require opening the Terminal to configure/install."

Change your mindset from hacker to 'non-technical relative or friend', and that problem goes away.

"There will be certain bits of hardware you'll want to use that will not work with you new system." is how they would phrase it, and oftentimes, it does not really bother them at all.

Even if it would bother them, getting a Mac likely would not help, as it would get them the same results for some of their old hardware.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by bmelton on Wednesday September 08, 2010 @05:00PM (#1673481)
I think you could say the same about any foreign operating system and any user, regardless of how technical. The more technical have better guesses at where to find things (e.g., Oh, it's not under 'System', maybe it's under 'Administration') based on familiarity with OS patterns, but if you sat me down in front of a Gentoo box running XFCE, I'd look just as much the fool as the next guy for the first 20 minutes or so (except I'd drop down to shell -- though the same applies for BSD even there.)

The best synopsis I heard (I can't remember who said it, nobody famous) was that "The hardest part about learning Linux is UNlearning whatever else you know first."

I think that correctly asserts that yeah, you won't find things in the "Control Panel", and you won't be able to "Win+R" for a run dialog, etc. Otherwise, I personally have had nothing but positive feedback from my less technical friends that I've turned on to Ubuntu, except for the usual complaints, or when they have to give up foo application because it doesn't exist (Photoshop, World of Warcraft, whatever.)

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by Nitramp on Saturday September 04, 2010 @05:07PM (#1663392)
Hardware support on Linux is a red herring. There are some few devices that don't work all that great, like some horrible sound chipsets and softmodems, plus the very latest in WiFi used to have problems (I think that's less of an issue nowadays).

Some years ago there was a project set up to fix those Linux hardware issues, and they effectively didn't do any work, because they couldn't find reasonable hardware that wasn't supported by Linux.

I have a (crappy) scanner that has no working drivers for any Windows beyond 98 and Mac OS beyond version 9, but it works just fine under Ubuntu/Linux. I haven't seen any mainstream, reasonable hardware that doesn't work under Linux for a long time. Really, from my perspective, hardware support under Linux is significantly better than under any other operating system.

Where it indeed gets spotty is the software to use the features of the hardware. E.g. Xsane rhymes a lot with insane, the various photo organiser tools are of varying quality, to say the least, and so on. Ubuntu is making progress, but there still are a lot of use cases where the GNU/Linux/Ubuntu desktop doesn't provide good alternatives.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by malnourish on Friday September 03, 2010 @09:36PM (#1661710)
The most difficult thing with Ubuntu that I have noticed is properly configuring and using a scanner.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by MrRage on Friday September 03, 2010 @03:56PM (#1660895)
> Windows 2000 and XP were very good operating systems

I by no means am some Microsoft hater, but I'm amused about this tinted rose glass nostalgia for XP. It's easy to say XP is a good system now with the maturity of three service packs and the bad taste of Vista still in our mouths, but I remember all those years ago much dislike of XP around the internet. Among other things, it was a security nightmare that wasn't even fixed until SP2. You put release day XP on your machine and put it on the internet and you're machine will be probably hacked within the hour.

On the other hand not to many people stuck with Vista. A fully patched Vista installation works just fine nowadays. It still has higher system requirements, but those requirements are now 4 year old systems.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by megablast on Friday September 03, 2010 @09:18PM (#1661681)
You are remembering it backwards. 2000, and XP (because it was the consumer version of 2000) were much better than Windows 98, Windows ME and NT. This is why the poster says they were good OS, they were so much more stable, you could actually leave your machine on for a while.

Vista is and always will be a dog.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by zenocon on Friday September 03, 2010 @10:29PM (#1661822)
who cares? you can say this about any major release number OS. go ahead and throw out netbsd stats all you want. no one tries to hack that b/c no one cares. stats are a funny game, my friend.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by seunosewa on Friday September 03, 2010 @10:29PM (#1661824)
I remember really loving XP when it first came out. It was much better than 98 and Me and faster than 2000.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by narrator on Friday September 03, 2010 @03:59PM (#1660905)
Win2k being released was a huge blow to Linux at the time. Redhat 9 was so awful in comparison. I remember how a lot of developers I knew who had been Linux users actually switched back.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by rbanffy on Friday September 03, 2010 @09:28PM (#1661698)
IIRC, the Linux of the time had trouble with multiprocessors and ran on ext2. Nevertheless, I cannot imagine someone giving up a fully functional Unix environment to go back to a Windows box. Lots of mouse clicking for much less power.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by ido on Friday September 03, 2010 @03:52PM (#1660883)
Almost all releases of the NT line were good (including Win 7).

Was there any OS contemporary to NT 3.51 that was better than it at anything (beside win 95 when it comes to compatibility with more software & hardware)?

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by rbanffy on Friday September 03, 2010 @09:55PM (#1661758)
Solaris 2.5 was a very solid OS and better than NT 3.5 in most respects unless a defining criteria for "better" is "runs well on PCs", which it didn't.

OS/2 was also a good OS for x86 PCs. At least as good as NT, unless, again, you want it to run software designed for Windows.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by ido on Saturday September 04, 2010 @10:56AM (#1662789)
I wasn't really into OS/2 but I concede that it was probably about as good as NT at the time.

I would, however, much rather use NT 3.51 as a desktop OS than Solaris 2.5 with CDE and its 80s-style command line utilities (luckily it seems they are using GNU stuff nowadays?).

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by rbanffy on Saturday September 04, 2010 @02:47PM (#1663151)
You always could get the GNU stuff and compile it yourself. My own installs felt very GNU-ish at that time.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by hga on Friday September 03, 2010 @07:01PM (#1661436)
Perhaps; I thought it peaked in quality of releases after 3.51 SP1.

Better than SCO Unix of the period as a desktop.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by Luyt on Friday September 03, 2010 @04:40PM (#1661074)
I quite liked NT 3.5 as a development platform back then. I came from WfW 3.11 and used Borland C++ 4.5, and nasty programming bugs would hang 3.11, but not NT 3.5.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by sprout on Friday September 03, 2010 @04:15PM (#1660969)
Not on the desktop, though when it comes to the server pretty much all of them beat and still beat NT on stability and filesystem support.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by Keyframe on Friday September 03, 2010 @11:34PM (#1661921)
IRIX (RIP)
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by philwelch on Friday September 03, 2010 @04:21PM (#1660990)
Windows 3.0 and 3.1 were pale imitations of the Mac OS of the time. 95 was the first "good enough", and it was still not the equal of System 7.

For commodity hardware, they might have been the best available, but that's an adequacy criterion, not a "very good" criterion.

Most of the others I have no disagreement with.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by kabdib on Friday September 03, 2010 @10:21PM (#1661810)
The /Mac/ was a pale imitation of itself, by those standards. Developing a Mac app was just as gnarly as developing a Windows 3.1 app, but by 1995 Microsoft had Visual Basic (to Apple's HyperCard, which was virtually moribund at that point) and MS took off and /owned/ the database client market.

Apple never really believed in its development tools group, and the market share they lost in the 90s shows that. They are still paying for lost opportunity.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by ido on Saturday September 04, 2010 @11:05AM (#1662804)
I used System 7 (and OS 7.x & 8.x after that) as well as win 95, and IMO win 95 wasn't just equal but in fact better than system 7.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by gaius on Friday September 03, 2010 @03:49PM (#1660875)
Add to the list SQL Server 2000 and above, and Visual Studio.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by joe_the_user on Friday September 03, 2010 @05:55PM (#1661301)
Nice list.

Continuing the "Microsoft and Apple are different" theme, the thing that's worth considering is that the "goodness" of these products is the goodness of well engineered compromises.

Current Word is actually a fusion of DOS word and the original Windows Word and while it has a huge feature set, this set is not terribly consistent. It's an achievement to make thing feel as good as it does. Similarly for the others and very different from producing a clean, "just works" app from the ground up (not necessarily a better or worse achievement imho).

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by eru on Saturday September 04, 2010 @09:32AM (#1662649)
Maybe a "Worse is better" achievement?

(Not meant derogatory. Just in the sense of http://www.dreamsongs.com/WorseIsBetter.html)

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by CWuestefeld on Friday September 03, 2010 @03:00PM (#1660677)
Mostly you're right, but I object to the claim about Excel being better.

While Word was better than anything else I had found to use at the time (Word Perfect was a buggy mess).

However, I claim that there were better spreadsheet products available. Certainly the one I used, Enable, was quite robust, and was more capable than Excel.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by bad_user on Friday September 03, 2010 @03:22PM (#1660761)
Office 95 bundled Excel along with Word, Access and Powerpoint.

When people make choices they also look at convenience and price ... having these products packaged and nicely integrated with each-other was genius.

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by stcredzero on Friday September 03, 2010 @05:29PM (#1661224)
There is a lesson here for language designers!
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by coin on Friday September 03, 2010 @03:52PM (#1660880)
Excel for Windows was much better than Lotus 123 for Windows. Lotus basically took the DOS version of 123 and added some menus for it. It never did feel like a fist class GUI app.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by rbanffy on Friday September 03, 2010 @09:58PM (#1661768)
Lotus took Microsoft's word seriously when Gates proclaimed OS/2 was the future and Windows was an interim step. Lotus invested a lot in 123 for OS/2 (123/G, IIRC) and, when the IBM/Microsoft divorce made evident they chose the wrong side, they had to port it to Windows all over again (with lots of different and conflicting APIs). Microsoft had no such problem.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by Paulomus on Sunday September 05, 2010 @04:13PM (#1665075)
Their Macintosh products tend to be really great. I really loved IE5 for Mac and was sorry when they discontinued it. MS Word on the Macintosh always seemed well designed too. I assumed this was because their Macintosh division was long established and very good at what they did, or designing for a platform they did not control brought Microsoft's true design talents.
Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by stan_rogers on Saturday September 04, 2010 @07:06AM (#1662480)
Word? There are still things that were a piece of cake to accomplish in WordPerfect (5.1 for DOS; I never used WPWin) or AmiPro[1] (3+ for Windows) that are impossible, or extremely difficult, in Word.

[1] I say this despite having once written a piece (c. 1993) based on a Dr. Suess book that featured the lines "I could not merge 'grneggs' with 'ham'. I do not like you star dot sam."

Re:Bill Gates: "Someone decided to trash the one part of Win... by duck on Friday September 03, 2010 @11:07PM (#1661881)
And made so many other competitor products better too. We wouldn't be where we are now without them.