Re:GrayKey iPhone unlocker poses serious security concerns
by robin_reala on Saturday March 17, 2018 @03:40AM
(#16605965)
Is this not automatically illegal under the DMCA? Well, assuming the company in question is based in the US.
Re:GrayKey iPhone unlocker poses serious security concerns
by matthewmacleod on Saturday March 17, 2018 @04:29AM
(#16606060)
The DMCA specifically criminalises the circumvention of copyright protection methods, not all access controls.
Re:GrayKey iPhone unlocker poses serious security concerns
by robin_reala on Saturday March 17, 2018 @05:44AM
(#16606198)
I’m not a lawyer, but quoting from the Wikipedia article the DMCA “also criminalizes the act of circumventing an access control, whether or not there is actual infringement of copyright itself.” You could argue that you hold copyright on for example a photo you’ve taken, and the passcode is the access control method.
Re:GrayKey iPhone unlocker poses serious security concerns
by matthewmacleod on Saturday March 17, 2018 @06:42AM
(#16606342)
I’m also not a lawyer, but I have no reason to believe that would be an arguable case; the fact that an access control method incidentally makes gaining access to copyright materials harder doesn’t make it a copyright protection method.
Re:GrayKey iPhone unlocker poses serious security concerns
by corrideat on Saturday March 17, 2018 @11:15AM
(#16607307)
Not a lawyer, but copyright protections methods may be implemented as an access control system. For example, I could sell content to iPhone users under the assumption that third parties won't be able to copy or access said content. More to the point, things like Apple Music, the App Store or the iTunes Store all could be argued to rely on the access control mechanisms as part of the DRM system.
All they have to do is discretely obtain the device in question and have a few good engineers quietly pick it apart for a few weeks to figure out how it works. They then patch the vulnerability in a regular update claiming they discovered it as part of normal procedure and nobody takes notice.
Edit: the legality of the device itself is kinda interesting to me. Like, even if it is doing something illegal (like using stolen code or something), how would Apple prove it as long as it was only sold to law enforcement? If the police aren't asking too many questions and Apple can't legally acquire one, how do they prove it? I suppose they'd have to gather enough circumstantial evidence to get a judge to issue a subpoena, but things get a bit dark and fuzzy.