News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by fulafel on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @12:30PM (#16585928)
How much CO2 per kWh does it come to when you divide the total CO2 footprint of the battery manufacture and materials over the charge cycles of the battery?

edit: One study[1] indicates the figures are 150-200 kg CO2 equivalent per 1 kWh of battery. So for 1000 cycle durability, that would make 150-200 g per kWh even without counting the CO2 effects of charging power[2]. Diesel engines emit 250 g per kWh[3] of energy produced. Doesn't sound like such a great tradeoff.

[1] http://www.ivl.se/download/18.5922281715bdaebede9559/1496046...

[2] Even if Norway produces low emission hydro electricity, the same electricity could be used to displace dirty power if exported to Denmark etc.

[3] https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/co2-emission-fuels-d_1085...

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by sov on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @03:03PM (#16587365)
I think you're rather far off the mark here. NB: I work in this field, so, take that for what it's worth.

Yes, material recycling could be better from a pyrometallurgic perspective, but that's only an issue once a significant amount of batteries approach their EOL, so, 20+ years down the road.

It's clearly incorrect to compare the sum emissions of battery construction + lithium acquisition + cell fab + energy cost + implementation to just the diesel engine's CO2 during its burn. This is not even close to the same ballpark, as you're neglecting the costs associated with the extraction, transport and chemical treatment of the fuel.

Further, you're comparing the CO2-eq to out of date fab processes and cell chemistries, which, while based on a study published in 2014, means that it actually ignores significant industrial advances over the past decade. But, even granting little advancement in cell fab/chems, the comparison is wrong because the quality of energy available during manufacturing (the lions share of the CO2-eq) is better than the quality of energy available when the ship actually wants to use it (eg: at sea).

Lastly, comparing CO2-eq from the batteries to 100% efficient diesel is misguided. Ships don't typically use diesel--they use bunker fuel (with much worse CO2-eq than diesel), and the actual energy conversion is nowhere near 100% efficient. Inefficiencies made even more pronounced once you take into account regenerative effects on the batteries and the energy-availability delay of the fuel (lithium is on-demand, burning fuel has latency).

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by fulafel on Thursday March 15, 2018 @05:31PM (#16596685)
By "not in the same ballpark", do you mean that diesel co2 emissions are hugely bigger vs the co2 released from its combustion? I don't know the figures but this sounds surprising.
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by Robotbeat on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @02:50PM (#16587265)
This is incorrect. Diesel engines are not 100% efficient, with passenger vehicles (especially lacking regenerative braking that is standard in all production EVs) being closer to 25-33% efficient. So increase the diesel emissions to about 750 to 1000g_CO2/kWh.

From your third source (engineering toolbox): https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/co2-emission-fuels-d_1085...

"Note! Heat loss - 55-75% - in power generation is not included in the numbers."

.

EDIT: US CO2 emissions per kWh produced is now about 430 grams. So even including battery construction emissions (which are lower than your figure), EVs still win (by nearly a factor of 2).

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by fulafel on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @02:59PM (#16587331)
Indeed, good catch. Still, it leaves close to half of the co2 emissions, at current marine propulsion efficencies, 40-50% per https://www.wartsila.com/sustainability/environmental-respon...
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by Robotbeat on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @03:20PM (#16587508)
...half is still much better. Besides, there's a lack of local emissions (and therefore no increased asthma risk, etc) which is often under-rated IMHO.

And you're investing in a capability that will help further reduce emissions on the grid.

Think about the Tesla Gigafactory. At first, it'll be run with electricity from the grid. That means the first batteries cost 100-200 grams of CO2 per kWh cycle (well, significantly better than that as the NMC cells last for many thousands of cycles). But as you upgrade to buffered solar (and cut off from the grid to save the monthly fee), the input energy becomes cleaner, so the next round of batteries may be just 50 grams of CO2 per kWh. And by using /those/ batteries in the next Gigafactory, its effective emissions are even less.

That's why trying to electrify everything possible while greening the grid is so important: the effects compound each other. Ultimately, no emissions are required at all. Compare that to mere efficiency improvements on conventional fossil fuel tech: sometimes the lower costs enabled by greater efficiency can actually perversely lead to GREATER emissions as demand increases non-linearly.

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by clvcooke on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @01:04PM (#16586282)
I believe comparing engines to batteries is misleading. As you are comparing _capacity_ to _energy_, and although the units are the same the meaning is very different. The emissions to produce the initial capacity may be similar (200g vs. 250g), however those emissions are spread over the life of the battery (~1000 cycles). So ignoring power input (which is a bad assumption) batteries would be 0.2g/kWh vs. diesel at 250g/kWh. Of course ignoring power isn't fair, but it shows the manufacturing emissions are neglible compared to diesel engine emissions when spread over the batteries lifetime.

Edit: Power --> energy

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by fulafel on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @02:10PM (#16586936)
I think you got the emissions of a charge cycle mixed up with emissions of battery production per capacity unit.

For the CO2 per 1 kWh capacity, the emissions of battery production are 200 KILOgrams. I got the 200 grams from 200 kg by dividing by a supposed 1000 charge-cycle life of a battery.

So my calculation showed that per 1 kWh power charged/discharged, the emissions come out at 200g per kWh. Which is comparable to using diesel to produce the same amount of power.

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by Reason077 on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @02:35PM (#16587165)
"For the CO2 per 1 kWh capacity, the emissions of battery production are 200 KILOgrams."

I don't know if that's true, but if it is, it will be largely due to the CO2 footprint of the grid. Battery manufacturing is energy-intensive.

A battery factory powered by 100% renewable energy, on the other hand, would have a greatly reduced carbon footprint. And producing more batteries enables more renewable energy sources, getting us closer to that goal.

I also believe that in this application (short-haul Norwegian ferry), the expected life of the batteries is far greater than 1000 cycles. These ferries do multiple trips per day, every day, and recharge each time. Since they've been in service since 2015, they will already have a lot more than 1000 cycles on the batteries.

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by Robotbeat on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @02:47PM (#16587246)
An example of a battery factory powered (eventually) by 100% renewable energy is the Gigafactory using a combination of wind and solar. Even today, it is entirely powered by electricity. It doesn't even have a gas line (as would be common for any large building, especially an industrial one). Its solar roof is eventually going to be 70MW. They've just started installing part of it, and from satellite and aerial imagery it looks like they have a few Megawatts already installed.

And assuming the vast majority of the energy used in battery production is electricity, then the figure for emissions that you used is highly dependent on grid mix. For instance, coal is roughly 1kg of CO2 per kWh. The current US grid is less than half of that (~430grams/kWh by my calculations using data through December 2017). If your study assumed coal power for battery production and assuming the Gigafactory is no more efficient (doubtful), then even today before the solar roof is installed, the CO2 emissions is already closer to ~90kg of CO2 per kWh of capacity. The grid is improving roughly 4% per year, and the Tesla Gigafactory roof and wind turbines coming online should drop that even more.

...especially as the Gigafactory starts buffering its own electrical load with its own batteries to reduce the cost of its grid connection and transportation of the batteries and components is increasingly done with Tesla Semis.

EDIT: Source: https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-gigafactory-1-solar-rooftop-...

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by clvcooke on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @02:43PM (#16587226)
I see your point, my mistake. However there are still many arguments to be made for this strategy. First of all, in terms of carbon capture it is much easier to capture carbon at a factory then on a boat, or any mobile vehicle for that matter. Secondly, arguing that diesel is equal is ignoring that diesel needs to be transported to and from the fueling station, and extracted from the ground, this should be factored into it's emissions (I'm not sure how). As far as I know moving electricity is far easier than moving liquid fuel, as long as you are in a preexisting industrial zone.

So I do agree, perhaps on a pure emissions standpoint they may be more equal than most think, however in terms of environmental impact batteries seem to be able to cater to technological advances (carbon capture and better manufacturing with scale) much better than diesel (which you NEED to burn to use).

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by jernfrost on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:11AM (#16591135)
Refining oil also requires substantial amounts of power. From what I’ve read the power to refine a litre of gasoline e.g. requires as much power as an electric car would need to go the distance 1 litre of gasoline gives you.
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by bonesss on Thursday March 15, 2018 @08:59AM (#16592409)
If refining 1 liter of gas took the energy potential of 1 liter of gas then we wouldn't be dominated by the petroleum industry... The chemical energy storage in hydrocarbons is stupid efficient compared to the alternatives.

Oil refining is very energy intensive, but gasoline production is highly energy positive. Interestingly: atomic process heat for refining could tae a huge chunk of CO2 off our roadways and also improve oil production numbers significantly (20%-ish).

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by cesarb on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @01:14PM (#16586392)
You're comparing indirect emissions with direct emissions. For a fair comparison, if you're including manufacturing costs for the battery on one side, you should also include manufacturing costs for the fuel on the other side.
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by theobon on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @01:11PM (#16586355)
Feels disingenuous to use the end-to-end CO2 generation for the battery but only the burn costs of diesel.
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by fulafel on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @02:14PM (#16586975)
Fair point. But it'll still be in the same ballpark.
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by r00fus on Thursday March 15, 2018 @01:33AM (#16590623)
Did you calculate the cost of war to keep fuel cheap or refining and transporting the fuel?
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by jernfrost on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:12AM (#16591141)
No it wouldn’t as refining oil is extremely energy intensive.
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by durkie on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @12:48PM (#16586103)
From your [1] study:

"The largest part of the energy use in the production of lithium-ion batteries comes from electricity use."

Converting ships to batteries allows them to become cleaner as the grid becomes cleaner.

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by fulafel on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @12:51PM (#16586139)
It expands: "The largest part of the emissions, around 50%, is currently from battery (including cell) manufacturing, but if the material processing to battery grade is viewed as one total it is in the same order of magnitude."

So one half is amenable to improvements if the manufacturing transitions to clearn electricity. But this is not likely to happen in a big way anytime soon, because the manufacturing happens in coal-heavy Asian countries: https://www.statista.com/statistics/235323/lithium-batteries...

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by durkie on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @01:50PM (#16586761)
can you share your source? that statista link just wants me to sign up before it will show me anything.
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by fulafel on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @02:04PM (#16586882)
I was just Googling it, I don't have any better sources sorry. It is showing me a registration nag screen now too. But it was companies like Samsung, LG, Panasonic and then some Chinese companies that I hadn't heard of.

edit: BYD was the chinese one among the top 5.

There's a list of top lithium mining companies here: https://investingnews.com/daily/resource-investing/energy-in... - those don't sound like places with zero emission power generation, either. (not to mention that mining typically produces power on-site with diesel generators)

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @01:35PM (#16586605)
the same electricity could be used to displace dirty power if exported to Denmark

If you agree with the assertions in the green paradox[1] it's all a waste of time anyway. If Norway lowers its oil consumption then the price of oil falls in the global market and so Americans buy bigger trucks and we are back where we started.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_paradox

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by jernfrost on Thursday March 15, 2018 @03:37AM (#16591028)
You think electification of the transport sector has to wait until all the worlds coal plants are shut down!!??

That will take too long time. The transport sector has to be electrified WHILE the power production is going renewable.

Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by nine_k on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @12:45PM (#16586075)
You can charge batteries using hydro power. You can't (economically) produce hydrocarbon fuel using it, though.
Re:Norwegian Shipbuilders Turning to Battery Power by fulafel on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @12:56PM (#16586196)
Yes, I addressed this in the comment's [2] footnote.