News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by Quanttek on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @07:23AM (#16575238)
I must say I'm against this development. First of all, even if electric, this is certainly a very inefficient way of transportation that will 'waste' a lot of energy to transport maybe 4 people.

The resulting price of this technology will result in the 99% stuck on the ground while the only te 1% can afford the fare.

And even if it becomes a regular mode of transportation, do you really want these planes to fly over your apartment/house every few minutes? They might be more quiet than a Cessna but they wll certainly still be disturbing

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by clon on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @07:41AM (#16575305)
I agree. People talking about flying cars sound a lot like people demanding faster horses. Or flying horses.

I do not think the American dream of a private car scales too well to the future, be it with rubber wheels or tiny propellers. Especially given the population growth.

Instead, a brief visit to Singapore, for example, will convince anyone what the future of transportation looks like. A public transport system, enabling a lifestyle that makes cars redundant.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by vadimberman on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:00AM (#16575408)
> Instead, a brief visit to Singapore, for example, will convince anyone what the future of transportation looks like. A public transport system, enabling a lifestyle that makes cars redundant.

Living in Singapore, I agree with what you say, but in this future, there will be a lot of whining, too:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15928972

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by Bizarro on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:43AM (#16575998)
Instead, a brief visit to Singapore, for example, will convince anyone what the future of transportation looks like

It might have convinced you, but it won't "convince anyone", or the majority of people.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by ajmurmann on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:59AM (#16577175)
Being a huge advocate for public transportation, I have to admit that it doesn't translate that well to many American cities. Most American cities have too low density.

There is another issue I've noticed with public transit in the US which I haven't experienced elsewhere and have no good explanation for: Too frequent stops. May it be buses in LA or light rail in SF or PDX, they constantly are stopping. It seems like there is a stop on at least every other block making it super slow to go cross town.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by ryandrake on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @12:21PM (#16577323)
Great for dense urban areas. Not so much for the remaining 97% of the Earth’s surface. If the future of transportation means packing myself in a crowded city, count me out. I’ll keep my car, thanks.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by Bromskloss on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:58AM (#16575725)
The point of flying cars is that they would be cool to fly. I mean, at least _if_ you get to fly them, as opposed to you just being their cargo.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by mrep on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @10:30AM (#16576379)
How safe is Singapore public transportation and walking?

The reason I ask is that neither are as safe as driving here in the US which i consider a major blocker in the public transportation utopia people keep dreaming up.

Relevant discussion I have had about this topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16462803

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by vadimberman on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:30PM (#16582050)
> How safe is Singapore public transportation and walking?

Extremely safe. Even the whiniest people in Singapore (and that's a high bar to clear) will never say that Singapore is unsafe.

Once in a while I see videos of cars not stopping in front of a pedestrian crossing. These posts result in a universal condemnation.

Also note that the UK-style pedestrian crossings include a buffer space next to the actual crossing.

In terms of public transportation, you have the subway (MRT), the light rail (LRT), and the buses. All new, and most of the MRT plus LRT are automated.

Additional aspect is drink-driving. The alcohol is also heavily taxed (almost Demolition Man style: "x is not good for you. What's not good for you is illegal") and the way the government views drugs is clarified in the disembarkation cards saying "Death to drug traffickers" (and they actually mean it), and with the combination of high availability of public transport complemented with cheap taxis / ride-sharing and low availability of intoxicating the DUI is pretty much non-existent.

In the US, the sidewalks are scarce in many places. But that's pretty unique, you don't need to go to Singapore to see streets with normal sidewalks.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by aqme28 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:06AM (#16576679)
I have a hard time believing that public transportation or walking are more dangerous than driving in the US or elsewhere.

Do you have any statistics on walking or public transit safety? I couldnt find any, though car safety is very accessible.

edit: It seems the vast majority of pedestrian accidents are because of collisions with cars. In a future with more public transport and walking, they will be even safer.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by mrep on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:40AM (#16577027)
I should have clarified that the safety I am referring to is from other people in the form of harassment and assaults.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by ecshafer on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:11AM (#16576726)
The reason public transport and walking can be unsafe is the us has deliberate policies making it so. We have more police presence on roads, and less on transport. We have urban design explicitly supporting the car, with human unfriendly design. Look at how many roads have no side walks or bike paths. A 1 mile journey in many areas is unsafe without a car. We need a massive rethink of how we design cities, and there are issues at all levels of government. Federal government tax incentives favor single family detached homes, and Grant money goes towards expanding infrastructure in an unsustainable and unsafe manner.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by astrobase_go on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @07:35AM (#16575290)
I agree with your opposition to this development with respect to people moved per unit of energy consumed. I think development funds are much better spent on improving the efficiency, reliability, and capacity of mass transit systems for large and crowded urban areas. However, that's not really fodder for sexy startup material.

Additionally, if these are widely adopted, I can imagine a highly-crowded Class G (or D, if near an airport -- and how do you establish two-way comms between ATC and an autonomous flying taxi?) airspace ending badly for passengers or bystanders in crowded metropolitan areas. This may be why KittyHawk has done their R&D in New Zealand, rather than in the US under FAA regulations.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by annerajb on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:39AM (#16575975)
The way it will work on the US based on what Uber and others are talking about. Is a special corridor where only autonomous traffic is allowed. This planes allowed on this corridor will have digital air traffic controllers and only be allowed if they have certain amount of capacity similar to ADS-B mandate in the future.

This allows the plane to all fly and not hit each other and pilots won't be allowed in that corridor.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by akerro on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @07:54AM (#16575370)
I'm personally against it because I don't want anything to fall down into my garden or on my head in case of a failure.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by mrybczyn on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:27AM (#16575889)
I'm pretty sure this is a literal "Not In My Back Yard" comment.

I'm okay with it. Yes it will be for the 1% for a long time, but so were trains and cars and airlines...

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by endless1234 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:39AM (#16575969)
But how does this system scale? Thousands of these simultaneously in the air above cities? The noise must be quite something.

I think it's a novel helicopter replacement idea, but not really anything for mass transportation.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by jhall1468 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:09AM (#16576710)
These would be extremely quiet while cruising but likely pretty loud on take off. The latter is moot since that's happening at an airport.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by endless1234 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @05:19PM (#16579903)
They're supposed to be able to land and take off buildings I thought?
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by Bizarro on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:46AM (#16576013)
Although autonomous doesn't solve the failure problem, it does (for the most) part solve the crazy/incompetent problem of the past, future visions of flying cars for everybody.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by fastball on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:29AM (#16576911)
You realize someone can probably crash their car into your garden, right?
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by t3po7re5 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:21AM (#16575525)
Can't you say the same about helicopters and airplanes?
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by blocked_again on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:43AM (#16575635)
Yup. But probability is close to Zero.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by nl on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:17AM (#16575507)
Do planes often fall on your head?
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by akerro on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:31AM (#16575913)
> Do planes often fall on your head?

No, but once per week I see a broken car on a motorway on my commute.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by blocked_again on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:45AM (#16575646)
Nope. Given the number of planes in the world the probability of that happening is close to Zero. But a lot of birds has pooped on my head. The more KittyHwaks and other mass used flying cars in the air the more the probability of one falling on your head.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by ryanlol on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @12:20PM (#16577319)
I don't think it would be acceptable for an aircraft like this to have a failure rate comparable to a birds poop rate.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by icc97 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:36AM (#16575601)
If it reduces the din of the awful noise of living anywhere near to a helipad in the south west of London, just so rich kids can come and go as they please, then it's worth it.

The choppers are already there, so there's already the risk of something falling out of the sky.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by vadimberman on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:09AM (#16575458)
It's true that they should not be adopted en masse, but in some cases, it is very useful:

* transportation across mountainous terrain - it will actually increase safety

* a few tightly controlled shuttles in gridlocked megalopolises like those in Asia with nightmarish traffic

Basically, taking over the role of the helicopters, but safer and more affordable.

I would, however, prefer fewer smaller bus-sized vehicles.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by markdown on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:20AM (#16575520)
These would work great in Fiji flying tourists from the international airport on the main island to the dozen or so little resort islands nearby.

And since a significant proportion of our electricity is generated by hydro power, could be almost carbon neutral travel.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by coldcode on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @07:32AM (#16575280)
I don't fear flying cars. I fear flying car crashes. Instead of a fender bender they "land" in your bedroom.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by ryandrake on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @12:26PM (#16577355)
Do you fear small airplanes (which have been flying over your house for almost a century) too?
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by jp555 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:10AM (#16575465)
Ever heard of a ballistic parachute? Not a 100% solution of course, but then again zero customers died in all passenger aircraft flights last year.

That’s saying a lot when every single day, there are times when there are over a million people simultaneously sitting in chairs in the sky

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by michrassena on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:46AM (#16576019)
I believe it was zero deaths on commercial jets last year, but when comparing that safety record to these smaller craft, it's a category error. Light planes are generally less safe than commercial jets per miles traveled.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by mrep on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @10:46AM (#16576510)
Five people just died in a NYC heliopter crash on sunday: https://www.cnn.com/2018/03/11/us/new-york-city-helicopter-a...
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by 908087 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:39AM (#16575967)
> but then again zero customers died in all passenger aircraft flights last year.

This isn't even remotely accurate.

Also, even when a BRS deployment goes well, there's a good chance that the aircraft is coming through someone's roof if flying over a populated area.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by product50 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:57AM (#16575717)
Typical cynical hacker news comment. Have you seen any numbers wrt mileage? Do you know if this will be debuted as a taxi which can transport users vs. something one can own? Have you seen any wrt emissions vs. a normal suv which carries a family of 4?

I am amazed how you can come to this conclusion without knowing anything about the product.

Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by CodeWriter23 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @10:30AM (#16576378)
I’m amazed you missed the parts where everyone in the video referred to it as an “air taxi”.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by product50 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:32AM (#16576934)
I did not. The person who was commenting before me did.
Re:Cora – Kitty Hawk's prototype air taxi [video] by bfuller on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:11AM (#16575468)
What about in places like Bogota where the rich are already using helicopters to travel the city? Surely a service like this opens air travel up for a larger audience.

And as for efficiency, again, places like Bogota or Guatemala City are so congested all day/evening, surely idling in your car for 1+hr to go a few miles is not efficient.