News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by swfsql on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:25PM (#16570660)
I'm an average programmer, but I honestly don't get the goal of inclusiveness [edit: from the Rust 2017 Survey Results]

> Diversity and inclusiveness continue to be vital goals for the Rust project at all levels.

I mean.. lifetime checks won't stop working if you don't consider yourself heterosexual or anything o.O The two matters simply don't mix in my head

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by nemothekid on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:38PM (#16570783)
It's less about goals of the technical project, and more about goals of the organization. Rust the language is written by people, The Rust Team, most of whom I'd imagine are volunteers. In order to guarantee the life of the project, its important for potential contributors to not only feel comfortable using the language and writing code, but also feel comfortable in discussing the future potential features and use cases for the language.

It is important for projects, now, to state their goals upfront and be clear, especially when you could have 1000s of contributors from all over the world. This is something that's new for software projects, but as open source becomes larger and more diverse its becoming more necessary. The alternative has been a community based loosely around some invisible set of rules that alienates or drives away potential contributors or sparks some drama that ends up on the top of Reddit/HN/etc.

Lifetime checks will stop working if the project gets abandoned over political issues.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by swfsql on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:47PM (#16570873)
I see, but this is still a political issue. Maybe a lot of minorities people just voted "no" in that survey question.

Because.. why excluding people based on their skin color is discriminatory, but including people based on their skin color is not discriminatory?

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by andrewflnr on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:51PM (#16573785)
There is a difference between "including" and "not excluding" people based on color or whatever. It's (officially, anyway) about removing barriers, not roping people in. I'll grant in practice it's a blurry line.

So, yeah, it's a political issue, but an open source project is necessarily a political entity by virtue of being made of people. You can't escape making political decisions, and since "inclusivity" mostly just means being nice to people, I can't complain much.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by swfsql on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:41AM (#16577028)
I completely agree, and I'd like to add that if one is "not excluding", asking for color skin should be forbidden. Because knowing color skin cannot possibly help one to "not exclude".

In other words, "not excluding" implies not asking for color skins.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by andrewflnr on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @05:53PM (#16580220)
Eh, depending on the circumstances it might help you measure how well your anti-exclusion efforts are going. You'd definitely prefer it to be anonymous, and unlinked to any kind of entry process, including informal ones.
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by swfsql on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @06:51PM (#16580592)
This is correct. I mistakenly assumed that if they wanted to know about it, then they wanted to change something according to it, which may not be the case.

They have talks, documentation is awesome, examples may even run online, ide stuff is cool, In my opinion, it hard to be more welcoming than that, and special treatment based on any individual traits (except for "what OS you're using" and stuff) would not only be unneeded, but also should be repelled ([subjective] personal value).

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by matthewmacleod on Monday March 12, 2018 @04:14PM (#16571106)
You’ve described something that isn’t happening and won’t happen.
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by awestroke on Monday March 12, 2018 @05:17PM (#16571730)
Discrimination, noun:

> the unjust or prejudicial treatment of different categories of people, especially on the grounds of race, age, or sex.

Is it unjust to make sure people from a minority do not feel alienated?

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by swfsql on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:55PM (#16573351)
then this brings a discussion on what "just" is. Does just implies impartiality? if so, different treatment by color would not be just, from what I can understand.

Secondly, one can't be sure that others won't feel alienated. You just put them in a different classification. I would definitely tend to feel alienated..

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by xedrac on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:23PM (#16573477)
Is it just to alienate the majority to encourage the minority? A lot of companies promoting "diversity" certainly think so.
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by webkike on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @02:23AM (#16574177)
The rust team isn't alienating anyone
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by jhasse on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:31PM (#16572637)
Yes, you should instead make sure everyone doesn't feel alienated, not only the people from a minority regarding their race, age or sex.
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by Rusky on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:07PM (#16572812)
That... does seem to be the goal.
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by staticassertion on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:03PM (#16573630)
No no no, you see, by making minorities safer we must then be making the majority feel less safe! Safety is a zero sum game after all.
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by littlestymaar on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @04:59AM (#16574637)
> Safety is a zero sum game after all.

That's what we thought before Rust came, that you could only have safety if you sacrificied speed. But now we know it was wrong ;)

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by kbenson on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @02:44AM (#16574232)
It upsets me that the reason this joke plays so well is because we can see how this kind of thinking has become common in the world. Take your upvote, but know you've also made me sad. :/
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by zbraniecki on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @04:14AM (#16574490)
exactly. I also gave them my sad upvote for a really spot on commentary on the diversity and inclusion issues. :(
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by zkomp on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @02:31AM (#16574194)
In this minefield, I really miss the irony tag here.

I do, really do, belive this should just boil down to: - don't be a jerk - don't discriminate

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by jhasse on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @04:39AM (#16574577)
I wasn't talking about Rust, but wanted to give a direct answer to "Is it unjust to make sure people from a minority do not feel alienated?".
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by jayroh on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:01PM (#16573626)
If you're open to learning about why it _actually is_ important, there are some good resources out there to give you a little more context as to the reasons why.

You could read this: http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-diversity-righ...

Or maybe if you like listening instead: https://www.gimletmedia.com/reply-all/52-raising-the-bar

So, while it's a nuanced and complicated topic, there are actual reasons why this benefits a project like Rust. Diversity amongst any organization is not only good for society, but objectively the output of the org itself.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by swfsql on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:37AM (#16576997)
What if it happens that you can only hire one person, and one "externally looks" homogeneous to the rest of the hired workers, but the other one "externally looks" like a minority member,

but you think that the first one, based on your own judgment, will be more "out of the box" when having solutions for the company.

So no matter what you think, the one from a minority is certainly preferable for hiring?

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by kbenson on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @02:01PM (#16578210)
> So no matter what you think, the one from a minority is certainly preferable for hiring?

I think the idea is to include as best as possible what may be hard to assess factors such as difference of experience, culture and upbringing and using that, make a decision as the hirer who you think will benefit the company best, not to choose a person and then override who you think is best just because of one factor.

All this really takes is valuing an outside perspective. An yes, sometimes just the skin color can be enough, if that skin color has affected how people see them or any unique problems it has come with. That does mean it is or must be enough though, just that it may be something worth including.

As a simple example, I'll leave you this: How We Accidentally Made a Racist Videogame.[1] It should be easy to see how a slightly more diverse group of developers and/or QA testers could have avoided that problem. Similar things exist with dealing with other cultures or countries, or people with disabilities, or if you're really unlucky, just people of the other sex if you're unlucky enough to have that much of a homogeneous set of coworkers.

1: http://www.kotaku.co.uk/2017/01/12/how-we-accidentally-made-...

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by solidsnack9000 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @02:07AM (#16574141)
There are many axes along which a community can be non-inclusive. I will always remember being made fun of in #gentoo for using Haskell. (Although I can not argue with the general guidance to install Gentoo.)

Once you see that worthy men can be made to feel unwelcome, merely due to their choice of programming language, it makes one wonder if other worthy people do not feel unwelcome when they are treated dismissively in some other way, as by by referring to every one as “men” indifferently.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by chmln on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:39PM (#16570792)
Its all just fluff. Might have something to do with Mozilla being left-leaning. Skin color has nothing to do with non-lexical lifetimes.

They will say that they value diversity of thoughts that may come when you have people with various backgrounds, but it is much more primitive in practice, always boiling down to companies acquiring people with certain skin color or gender just for the sake of it.

There are well-known but taboo reasons behind the lack of so-called diversity in tech and other highly intellectually demanding areas. And as long as uncomfortable truth cannot come out in the overly sensitive cultural climate of today, initiatives and policies in this direction will remain misguided.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by matthewmacleod on Monday March 12, 2018 @04:17PM (#16571133)
The only fluff I’m seeing here is your nonsense about about “taboo” or “uncomfortable truths”, which are usually a hallmark or someone with nudge-nudge-wink-wink dogwhistle objectionable opinion.

Let’s make it simple - having a diverse and welcoming community makes a project more attractive to contributors, and means that it’s more likely to succeed in the long term.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by chmln on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:47PM (#16573021)
> Let’s make it simple - having a diverse and welcoming community makes a project more attractive to contributors, and means that it’s more likely to succeed in the long term.

Sure, I never argued against fostering a welcome environment for contributors. We need more of this especially in open source, where contributions can be sorely lacking.

Instead I question the notion that Rust needs to have some sort or diversity to succeed. The assumption that it does implies that without diversity Rust will fail. However, Rust is not particularly diverse at the moment and it is certainly successful.

[dead]
Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by kiriakasis on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @10:10AM (#16576212)
> It means you have already spewed your privilege in believing that the diverse opinions are already bad/dumb ones.

this sounds uncalled for in my opinion. there is a difference between saying that something is "needed" and that something is "good". The parent simply said that the statement on the need of diversity was likely political.

Diversity is something worth investing into, many agree with this, but to saying that a project needs it implies that you cannot succeed (whatever your idea of success is) without it.

EDIT: I am totally ok with a project choosing to support diversity both within itself and in the broader community, i believe that many ways of doing it are extremely beneficial. yet often that _is_ a political stance and can be discussed as one.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by kbenson on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @02:16PM (#16578364)
> but to saying that a project needs it implies that you cannot succeed (whatever your idea of success is) without it.

Sure. I think a lot of people are also defining succeed as "be somewhere or something I still want to associate with in the future."

There have been a few high profile projects that have gotten themselves into hot water because of either unwanted behavior by some that wasn't corrected (or they didn't have a good policy to point to for correction) or was too strongly corrected (different people have different thresholds, and without a clear concept to point to, even if somewhat vaguely defined, some people tend to go nuclear before a warning shot has been fired, which is also unfair).

We may at some time get to the point where communities are including too many general and positive policies, but I don't think we're there yet. In the meantime, when correctly followed they provide help and protection to people on both sides of whatever issue they are concerning.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by camplum on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @02:06PM (#16578256)
Something is "needed". If you don't create "political" change in a world where nothing otherwise would transform, then what? If we don't "force" schools to be diverse a class of people never excel and Obama would never be president.

All projects need it, because that project is made of humans. That project can succeed and die but those individuals will carry those experiences forward. I get what everyone here is doing linguistic math with diversity, but none of the replies are taking the impact on humanity in parallel with the success of a business that humans create.

We are reaping the benefits from many political changes 50+ years ago that inspired us to see the world differently and we cannot and should not stop now.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by skeleton on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @02:06AM (#16574137)
Okay but what does one actually do to make the community more 'diverse and welcoming'? What is preventing a particular person from contributing to the project?

Are contributions currently being rejected based on personal traits?

I think the answer to this question would help me a lot in understanding any of this.

Re:Rust's 2018 roadmap by jhasse on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:35PM (#16572663)
Could also be correlation: Projects succeeding in the long term attract diverse and welcoming communities.