Re:Report from the Geniatech vs. McHardy GPL violation court...
by rlpb on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:15PM
(#16570570)
> ...the legal distinction between editing author and co-author seems very dangerous.
It seems entirely reasonable to me. A pure reviewer (as opposed to a code contributor) has no copyright claim to the work because the reviewer didn't write it. The court wants to see evidence that the plaintiff does indeed have a copyright claim over the works he claimed he does.
> This case seems to imply that we should abandon this practice...
I don't think so. It simply demonstrates that one cannot bring a claim for copyleft license violation without actually having a copyright interest in the work, which is something we already knew.
It seems entirely reasonable to me. A pure reviewer (as opposed to a code contributor) has no copyright claim to the work because the reviewer didn't write it. The court wants to see evidence that the plaintiff does indeed have a copyright claim over the works he claimed he does.
> This case seems to imply that we should abandon this practice...
I don't think so. It simply demonstrates that one cannot bring a claim for copyleft license violation without actually having a copyright interest in the work, which is something we already knew.